3 Rectangles + 1 Triangle = ?

Geometry Level 5

Triangle A B C ABC has integer side lengths. Rectangles B C D E , A C F G , A B H J BCDE, ACFG, ABHJ are constructed so that C D = A C + A B CD = AC + AB , C F = A B + B C CF = AB + BC , and B H = ( A C + B C ) 2 BH = (AC + BC)^2 . If [ A B H J ] = [ B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] [ABHJ] = [BCDE] + [ACFG] , how many different values can [ A B C ] [ABC] have?

Details and assumptions

[ P Q R S ] [PQRS] refers to the area of figure P Q R S PQRS .


The answer is 1.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

13 solutions

Ahaan Rungta
May 20, 2014

Let the side lengths of A B C \triangle ABC be a a , b b , and c c . Then, we have: a ( b + c ) + b ( a + c ) = c ( a + b ) 2 , a(b + c) + b(a + c) = c(a + b)^2, from our conditions in the problem. We expand each side and simplify as follows: 2 a b + a c + b c = ( a 2 ) c + ( b 2 ) c + 2 a b c 2ab + ac + bc = (a^2)c + (b^2)c + 2abc 2 a b ( c 1 ) + a c ( a 1 ) + b c ( b 1 ) = 0 2ab(c - 1) + ac(a - 1) + bc(b - 1) = 0 Since a 0 , b 0 a \ne 0, b \ne 0 , and c 0 c \ne 0 , we have that a , b , c 1 a, b, c \ge 1 . So: 2 a b ( c 1 ) 0 , b c ( b 1 ) 0 , a c ( c 1 ) 0 2ab(c - 1) \ge 0, bc(b - 1) \ge 0, ac(c - 1) \ge 0 We want the equality case; i.e. a = b = c = 1. a = b = c = 1. Thus, there is only this one possibility, and equilateral triangle with area 3 1 2 4 . \frac {\sqrt{3} \cdot 1^2}{4}. The answer is 1 \boxed {1} .

Common mistakes

  1. Make sure that you expanded your terms and grouped them correctly.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago
Wilson Kan
May 20, 2014

Let a = B C , b = A C , c = A B a = BC, b = AC, c = AB . Then the [ A B H J ] = [ B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] [ABHJ]=[BCDE]+[ACFG] becomes c ( b + a ) 2 = a ( b + c ) + b ( a + c ) c(b+a)^2=a(b+c)+b(a+c) , which simplifies to b c ( b 1 ) + a c ( a 1 ) + 2 a b ( c 1 ) = 0 bc(b-1)+ac(a-1)+2ab(c-1)=0 Now using the fact that a 1 , b 1 , c 1 , a , b , c Z a\geq1, b\geq1, c\geq1, a,b,c \in \mathbb{Z} Each part of the left hand side is non-negative. So it can only sum to zero if each of them is 0. Thus, the sides are a = b = c = 1 a = b = c = 1 .

Jefferson Irawan
May 20, 2014

Let B C = a , A C = b , A B = c BC=a, AC=b, AB=c where a , b , c N a,b,c \in \mathbb{N} \;\;\;

then C D = b + c , C F = c + a , B H = ( a + b ) 2 CD= b+c, CF= c+a, BH= (a+b)^2 \;\;\;

so, [ A B H J ] = c ( a + b ) 2 [ABHJ] = c(a+b)^2 , [ B C D E ] = a ( b + c ) [BCDE] = a(b+c) , [ A C F G ] = b ( a + c ) [ACFG] =b(a+c)

then we have

c ( a + b ) 2 = a ( b + c ) + b ( a + c ) c(a+b)^2 = a(b+c) +b(a+c)

a 2 c + 2 a b c + b 2 c = a b + a c + a b + b c a^2c + 2abc + b^2c = ab+ac +ab+bc

a c ( a 1 ) + 2 a b ( c 1 ) + b c ( b 1 ) = 0 ac(a-1) + 2ab(c-1) + bc(b-1) = 0

we can conclude that there is only one solution ( a , b , c ) = ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) (a,b,c) = (1,1,1)

because of a , b , c 1 a,b,c \geq 1 so a c ( a 1 ) , 2 a b ( c 1 ) , b c ( b 1 ) 0 ac(a-1),2ab(c-1),bc(b-1) \geq 0 and the equality holds only for ( a , b , c ) = ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) (a,b,c) = (1,1,1)

the different value of [ A B C ] [ABC] only 1 1

Let B C = a , A C = b , A B = c BC=a,AC=b,AB=c

then C D = b + c , C F = c + a , B H = ( a + b ) 2 CD=b+c,CF=c+a,BH=(a+b)^2

so, [ A B H J ] = c ( a + b ) 2 , [ B C D E ] = a ( b + c ) , [ A C F G ] = b ( a + c ) [ABHJ]=c(a+b)^2, [BCDE]=a(b+c) , [ACFG]=b(a+c)

then we have

c ( a + b ) 2 = a ( b + c ) + b ( a + c ) c(a+b)2=a(b+c)+b(a+c)

a c ( a 1 ) + 2 a b ( c 1 ) + b c ( b 1 ) = 0 ac(a-1)+2ab(c-1)+bc(b-1)=0

so that there is only one solution (a,b,c)=(1,1,1)

because of a,b,c≥1 so ac(a−1),2ab(c−1),bc(b−1)≥0 and the equality holds only for (a,b,c)=(1,1,1)

the different value of [ABC] only 1

Nishanth Hegde
May 20, 2014

Let the side opposite to A , B \angle A, \angle B and C \angle C be a , b a, b and c c respectively.

Given:

C D = A C + A B = b + c CD=AC+AB=b+c

C F = A B + B C = c + a CF=AB+BC=c+a

B H = ( A C + B C ) 2 = ( a + b ) 2 BH=(AC+BC)^{2}=(a+b)^{2}

[ A B H J ] = [ B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] ( a + b ) 2 c = a ( b + c ) + b ( c + a ) [ABHJ]=[BCDE]+[ACFG] \Rightarrow (a+b)^{2} \cdot c=a(b+c) +b(c+a)

Expanding out, we have

a 2 c + 2 a b c + b 2 c = a c + 2 a b + b c a^{2}c + 2abc + b^{2}c = ac+ 2ab + bc

Rearranging and grouping like terms we have

a c ( a 1 ) + b c ( b 1 ) + 2 a b ( c 1 ) = 0 ac(a-1) +bc(b-1) + 2ab(c-1) = 0

Also a > 0 , b > 0 , c > 0 a>0, b>0, c>0

Since the triangle has integer side lengths the only solution possible is a = 1 , b = 1 , c = 1 a=1, b=1, c=1

But since a , b , c a, b, c are sides of the triangle they can not be 0 0

So the only possible solution is a = b = c = 1 a=b=c=1

So only 1 triangle is possible.

Elvin Gu
May 20, 2014

Since the area of a rectangle is base times height, we know that [ A B H J ] = [ B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] [ABHJ] = [BCDE] + [ACFG] becomes B C ( A C + A B ) + A C ( A B + B C ) = A B ( A C + B C ) 2 BC(AC+AB) + AC(AB+BC) = AB(AC+BC)^2 . Replacing A = B C , B = A C , C = A B A = BC, B = AC, C = AB , we get A ( B + C ) + B ( C + A ) = C ( A + B ) 2 = C A 2 + 2 C A B + C B 2 A(B+C) + B(C+A) = C(A+B)^2 = CA^2 + 2CAB + CB^2\ \Rightarrow A ( C + B C A C B ) + B ( A + C C A C B ) = 0 A(C+B-CA-CB) + B(A+C-CA-CB) = 0
Since we know that A and B are positive, C + B C A C B = A + C C A C B = 0 A = B C+B-CA-CB = A+C-CA-CB = 0 \Rightarrow A = B Plugging in we get C + A = 2 C A ( 2 C 1 ) ( A 1 / 2 ) = 1 / 2 C + A = 2CA \Rightarrow (2C-1)(A-1/2) = 1/2 A = 1 A = 1 (for C to be a positive integer), B = 1 B = 1 , and C = 1 C = 1 . This is the only solution, so there is only one possible value of [ A B C ] [ABC] .

Defri Ahmad
May 20, 2014

[ A B H J ] = [ B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] [ABHJ] = [BCDE] + [ACFG] using formula area of rectangle i.e. length times width, we have; A B ( A C + B C ) 2 = B C ( A B + A C ) + A C ( A B + B C ) AB(AC+BC)^2 = BC(AB+AC) + AC(AB+BC) A B ( A C 2 + B C 2 + 2 A C B C ) \Leftrightarrow AB(AC^2 + BC^2 + 2AC \cdot BC ) = B C ( A B + A C ) + A C ( A B + B C ) = BC(AB+AC) + AC(AB+BC)

A B A C 2 + A B B C 2 + 2 A B A C B C \Leftrightarrow AB \cdot AC^2 + AB \cdot BC^2 + 2AB \cdot AC \cdot BC = B C A B + B C A C ) + A C A B + A C B C = BC \cdot AB+BC \cdot AC) + AC \cdot AB + AC \cdot BC

A B A C 2 A B A C + A B B C 2 A B B C \Leftrightarrow AB \cdot AC^2 - AB \cdot AC + AB \cdot BC^2 - AB \cdot BC + 2 A B A C B C 2 B C A C = 0 + 2AB \cdot AC \cdot BC - 2BC \cdot AC =0

A B A C ( A C 1 ) + A B B C ( B C 1 ) + 2 B C A C ( A B 1 ) = 0... ( @ ) \Leftrightarrow AB \cdot AC(AC - 1) + AB \cdot BC( BC - 1) + 2BC \cdot AC(AB - 1) =0 ...(@)

Since the Triangle ABC has integer side then A B , B C , A C 1 AB, BC, AC \geq 1 (length of side ABC cann't be 0). Hence

A B A C ( A C 1 ) 0 AB \cdot AC(AC - 1) \geq 0

A B B C ( B C 1 ) 0 AB \cdot BC( BC - 1) \geq 0

2 B C A C ( A B 1 ) 0 2BC \cdot AC(AB - 1) \geq 0

@ will be satisfy if this three inequlity hold them equality and the equality hold when A B = B C = A C = 1 AB = BC = AC = 1

the triangle that satisfy the condition is only the equilateral triangle with 1 unit side

so, the only value for [ A B C ] [ABC] is 3 / 4 \sqrt{3}/4 or only one value for [ A B C ] [ABC] that satisfy the condition.

a(b + c) + b(a + c) = c(a + b)^2 2ab + ac + bc = (a^2)c + (b^2)c + 2abc 2ab(c - 1) + ac(a - 1) + bc(b - 1) = 0

We know that none of a, b, c can be 0 => a, b, c ≥ 1 => 2ab(c - 1) ≥ 0, bc(b - 1) ≥ 0 and ac(c - 1) ≥ 0

Equality holds only if a = b = c = 1

So, ABC is an equilateral triangle with sides 1

=> [ABC] = (√3)/4

Tushar Gautam
May 20, 2014

Area of ABHJ = area of BCDE+area of ACFG

AB . BH=BC . CD + AC . CF

Since BH=(AC+BC)^2 , CD=AC+AB and CF=AB+BC we can say

AB . (AC+BC)^2 =BC . (AC+AB) + AC . (AB+BC)

AB. (AC^2+BC^2+2AC.BC)=BC.AC+BC.AB+AC.AB+AC.BC

for easy AB=x, BC=y, AC=z

xz^2+xy^2+2xyz-yz-xy-xz-yz=0

(xz^2-xz)+(xy^2-xy)+2 (xyz-yz)=0

xz (z-1) +xy (y-1)+2yz (x-1)=0

Triangle has positive integer side So each term of lhs would be zero We get x=y=z=1

Triangle are root(3)/4 Only 1 answer possible

Garvil Singhal
May 20, 2014

Let the side opposite to vertex A be a , vertex B be b and that to vertex C be c. Now label all the sides of the triangle along with the sides if the rectangles as stated in the question . Now, we shall equate the areas as directed above. We get, c ( a + b ) 2 = a ( c + b ) + ( a + c ) b c(a+b)^2=a(c+b) + (a+c)b . Divide the whole equation by c , ( a + b ) 2 = a + ( 2 a b ) / c + b (a+b)^2=a+(2ab)/c+b . Expanding the square , by the identity ( a + b ) ) 2 = a 2 + b 2 + 2 a b , a 2 + b 2 + 2 a b = a + ( 2 a b ) / c + b . (a+b))^2=a^2+b^2+2ab, a^2+b^2+2ab=a+(2ab)/c+b. Now, we take the like terms together to the L.H.S. a ( a 1 ) + b ( b 1 ) + 2 a b ( 1 1 / c ) = 0 a(a-1)+b(b-1)+2ab(1-1/c)=0 Now , as we know that a,b and c are positive as they are the sides of a triangle, we can see that each individual term should be equal to zero in order the final result to be zero. Taking each term 0 we get a=1, b=1 and c=1. Therefore , we can get only 1 such pair.

Bill Dong
May 20, 2014

Let A B = x , A C = y , B C = z AB=x, AC=y, BC=z . Then, since the problem tells us that [ A B H J ] + [ B C D E ] = [ A C F G ] [ABHJ]+[BCDE]=[ACFG] , we have z ( x + y ) + y ( x + z ) = x ( y + z ) 2 z(x+y)+y(x+z)=x(y+z)^2 . Expanding and rearranging gives us x y 2 + 2 y z + z 2 x z 2 y z x y = 0 xy^2+2yz+z^2-xz-2yz-xy=0 . Rearranging this equation then gives us x ( y 2 + z 2 y z ) + 2 ( x y z y z ) = 0 x(y^2+z^2-y-z)+2(xyz-yz)=0 . Since x , y , z x,y,z are sides of a triangle, clearly both of the parts being added are equal to 0. We can quickly see that the only way that this can happen is if x , y , z x,y,z are 0 or 1, but since they are positive integers we have x = y = z = 1 x=y=z=1 . Thus, there is 1 \boxed{1} total possibility for the area of triangle ABC.

Expanded wrongly.

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago

W i t h u s u a l n o t a t i o n , [ B J H A ] = B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] c { a + b } 2 = a { b + c } + b { c + a } = 2 a b + c { a + b } . S o c { a 2 + b 2 } + 2 a b c = 2 a b + c { a + b } . c { a 2 + b 2 a b } + 2 a b { c 1 } = 0 B u t a , b , c 0. S o c 1 = 0 c = 1 . a n d a 2 + b 2 a b = 0. a 2 + b 2 = a + b . T h i s i s o n l y p o s s i b l e f o r i n t e g e r v a l u e s i f a = a 2 o r b 2 , w i t h b = b 2 o r a 2 . O n l y s u c h v a l u e s a r e a = 1 a n d b = 1. So ABC can take only ONE value. With\ usual\ notation,\ \ [BJHA]=BCDE]+[ACFG]\\ \implies c\{a+b\}^2=a\{b+c\}+b\{c+a\}=2ab+c\{a+b\}.\\ So\ c\{a^2+b^2\}+2abc=2ab+c\{a+b\} .\\ \implies \ c\{ a^2+b^2-a-b\}+2ab\{c-1\}=0\\ But\ \ a,\ b,\ c\ \neq\ 0.\\ So\ \ c-1=0\ \ \implies\ \color{#3D99F6}{c=1}.\\ and\ \ a^2+b^2-a-b=0.\\ \implies\ a^2+b^2= a+b.\\ This\ is\ only\ possible\ for\ integer\ values\ if\ \ a=a^2\ or\ b^2, \ with\ b= b^2\ or\ a^2.\\ Only \ such\ values\ are\ a=1\ and\ b=1.\\ \text{So ABC can take only ONE value.}

Luuk Weyers
Mar 27, 2014

Let A B = x AB=x , A C = y AC=y , and B C = z BC=z .

This will turn [ A B H J ] = [ B C D E ] + [ A C F G ] [ABHJ]=[BCDE]+[ACFG] into x y ( y 1 ) + x z ( z 1 ) + 2 y z ( x 1 ) = 0 xy(y-1)+xz(z-1)+2yz(x-1)=0 .

Because A B AB , A C AC , and B C BC are of integer length, x x , y y , and z z are all integers equal or greater than 1 1 . But then x y ( y 1 ) 0 xy(y-1) \geq 0 (equality in the case of y = 1 ) y=1) , x z ( z 1 ) 0 xz(z-1) \geq 0 (equality in the case of z = 1 ) z=1) , and 2 y z ( x 1 ) 0 2yz(x-1) \geq 0 as well (equality in the case of x = 1 ) x=1) .

So the only possible solution to x y ( y 1 ) + x z ( z 1 ) + 2 y z ( x 1 ) = 0 xy(y-1)+xz(z-1)+2yz(x-1)=0 is for all terms on the LHS to equal 0 0 , resulting in ( x , y , z ) = ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) (x,y,z)=(1,1,1) .

Therefore the number of possible values of [ A B C ] [ABC] is 1 \fbox{1} .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...