Diophantine Resistors

Suppose all the available resistors in the world are only 1000 Ω 1000 \Omega resistors. What is the minimum number of resistors needed to make an equivalent resistance of 600 Ω 600 \Omega ?

3 4 6 7 11 12 You can't produce 600 Ω 600 \Omega out of 1000 Ω 1000 \Omega resistors None of these choices

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Chew-Seong Cheong
Aug 19, 2016

We know that to get a resultant resistance lower than the original component resistance of 1000 Ω 1000 \ \Omega , the connection must be in parallel. Let the equivalent circuit of 600 Ω 600 \ \Omega with the least number of resistors in parallel which is two. Let one of the resistor be 1000 Ω 1000 \ \Omega , then the other resistor R 1 R_1 is given by:

R 1 1000 = 600 1000 R 1 1000 + R 1 = 600 1000 R 1 = 600000 + 600 R 1 R 1 = 1500 Ω \begin{aligned} R_1||1000 & = 600 \\ \frac {1000R_1}{1000 + R_1} & = 600 \\ 1000R_1 & = 600000 + 600R_1 \\ R_1 & = 1500 \ \Omega \end{aligned}

We know that the resultant resistance of two similar resistors in parallel is half the resistance of one of the resistor. Therefore, we have:

1500 = 1000 + 500 = 1000 + 1000 1000 \begin{aligned} 1500 & = 1000 + 500 \\ & = 1000 + 1000||1000 \end{aligned}

That is, one 1000 1000 - Ω \Omega resistor in series with two 1000 1000 - Ω \Omega resistors in parallel. And the final equivalent circuit is these three 1000 1000 - Ω \Omega resistors in parallel with another single 1000 1000 - Ω \Omega resistor, therefore, a total of 4 \boxed{4} 1000 1000 - Ω \Omega resistors.

Efren Medallo
Aug 19, 2016

The LCM of 600 600 and 1000 1000 is 3000 3000 .

Assuming that it has to be a parallel network (since the resultant resistance is smaller than the original resistance/s).

We get that the resultant should have been of this form

1 R = 5 3000 \frac{1}{R} = \frac{5}{3000} .

If we investigate the partitions of 5 5 providing us with resistances which are easily achievable, we get this

2 3000 + 3 3000 \frac{2}{3000} + \frac{3}{3000}

Which means to achieve 600 Ω 600 \Omega , we need 1500 Ω 1500 \Omega and 1000 Ω 1000 \Omega in parallel.

To achieve 1500 Ω 1500 \Omega , we find that we can split it into 1000 Ω 1000 \Omega and 500 Ω 500 \Omega , with which the latter can be achieved by having two 1000 Ω 1000 \Omega resistors in parallel.

Thus, we can just need four resistors to achieve 600 Ω 600 \Omega .

TL;DR version:

( 1000 + ( 1000 1000 ) ) ( 1000 ) (1000 + (1000||1000))||(1000)

( 1000 + 500 ) ( 1000 ) (1000 + 500)| (1000)

( 1500 ) ( 1000 ) (1500)||(1000)

600 Ω 600 \Omega

Gunjas Singh
Oct 14, 2016

Let 1000 ohm = R Required Resistance is 600 i.e. 3R/4

Therefore, it is clear that parallel circuit is involved (Resultant < Each Resistor)

Formula for R1 and R2 in parallel:

R 1 X R 2 R 1 + R 2 \frac{R_{1} X R_{2}}{R_{1} + R_{2}}

therefore by inspection one can see that R1 X R2 =3R*R and R1 + R2 = 3R+R

Hence, 4 resistors are required

3 in series and 1 in parallel

This system yields 750 ω 750 \omega , not 600 ω 600 \omega .

Efren Medallo - 4 years, 8 months ago

Sorry, Ω \Omega not ω \omega

Efren Medallo - 4 years, 8 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...