A Trigonometric Dilemma!

Geometry Level 5

sin ( x ) = x 100 \large{\sin(x) = \dfrac{x}{100}}

Let A A be the number of real roots of the above equation if x x is measured in degrees.

Let B B be the number of real roots of the above equation if x x is measured in radians.

Find the value of A + B A+B ?


The answer is 66.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Nihar Mahajan
Sep 5, 2015

If we graph the line given by y = x 100 y=\dfrac{x}{100} and the curve y = sin ( x ) y=\sin(x) , the number of points they have in common is what we require.

When x x is measured in degrees , it can be easily seen that the line intersects sine graph at 2 2 distinct points and the origin , that is 3 3 in total.Thus A = 3 A=3 .

Now consider when x x is measured in radians . Since y = x 100 y=\dfrac{x}{100} , as value of y y exceeds 1 1 , the line goes away from the sine curve and doesnot intersect.Let x = k π x=k\pi for some real k k such that k π 100 = 1 k = 100 π 700 22 31.8 \dfrac{k\pi}{100}=1 \Rightarrow k=\dfrac{100}{\pi} \approx \dfrac{700}{22} \approx 31.8 . Since 31 π < 31.8 π < 32 π 31\pi < 31.8\pi < 32\pi , the last point that the line intersects lies on the part of curve that terminates on 31 π 31\pi . Thus the line intersects the curve at 31 31 distinct points on right side of Y Y axis. By symmetry , it also intersects the curve at 31 31 distinct points on left side of Y Y axis. Origin is also common point to the line and curve. And hence B = 31 + 31 + 1 = 63 B=31+31+1=63 .

Thus A + B = 3 + 63 = 66 A+B=3+63=66 .

Farah Roslend
Aug 6, 2015

Consider the graph sin(x)=f(x) and x/100=g(x) separately.

-1<f(x)<1 inclusive of the values, as its limit.

g(x) has +- infinity as its limit.

The idea is to find the number of cycles g(x) passes through f(x), and later rationalize the number of intersections.

If x=radian,

then for g(x)=1, x=100 rad.

This means, number of cycles=100 rad/(2pi)=15.9 cycles

At f(0.9x2pi)=-0.5...

Hence, from x= 0 to 100 rad. , we know there must be 16x2=32 points of intersection, since g(x) is a continuous linear function, and for each cycle g(x) must pass through two points at f(x)'s positive crest. Note that at the first cycle g(x) passes through the origin.

From x=0 to -infinity inclusive, f(x) and g(x) is a reflection of f(x) and g(x) in its region in the positive values of x, about the x-axis. So points of intersection= 32 points, including the point at the origin.

Hence, total points of intersection = 64-1=63

If x=degree, and it is also assumed that the 100 in g(x) has a unit of degrees,

the same method is repeated and it will yield a total point of intersection of 3.

Thus, A+B= 63+3=66.

Moderator note:

Because 100 2 π \frac{100}{ 2 \pi } is not an integer, you have to be careful with justifying why that is indeed the number of cycles.

For example, if we used 97, 96, 95 in place of 100, then the corresponding value of A A would have been 63, 61, 59. IE It doesn't simply correspond to 4 × n 2 π 1 4 \times \lceil \frac{n}{ 2 \pi } \rceil - 1

I used x=100 rad. because as mentioned in my working, it's when g(x)=1, which is the highest positive value in the range of f(x). Between -1 to 1 inclusive would be the maximum range of values on the y-axis that g(x) can intersect with f(x). And that range corresponds to the domain -100 rad. to 100 rad. on the x-axis. Beyond that range and domain there's no intersection.

Farah Roslend - 5 years, 10 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...