Action...

In a bombing action there is 50% chance that any bomb with strike the target. Two direct hits are needed to destroy the target completely. How many bombs are required to be dropped to give a 99% chance or better of completely destroying the target?


The answer is 11.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Christian Daang
Nov 18, 2014

Solution 1.

It is sufficient to find the maximum n such that n bombs are required to be dropped to give a less than 1% chance of not destroying the target, i.e. either no bomb or only one bomb strike the target. Thus

1/2^n+n/2^n < 0.01,

(n+1)/2^n < 0.01.

If n = 10, then (n+1)/2^n = 11/1024 > 11/1100 = 0.01.

If n = 11, then (n+1)/2^n = 12/2048 < 20/2048 < 0.01.

Hence the maximum number of bomb drops is n = 11.

Solution 2.

Let A _k be the event that k bombs are required to strike the target twice, i.e. one and only one out of the first k-1 and the kth bomb drops strike the target. Thus Pr(A _k) = (k-1) _C _1 *(1/2)^(k-1) *(1/2) = (k-1)/2^k. The question asks to find the minimum n such that P = sum _(k = 2)^(n) {Pr(A _k)} >= 0.99. Now P = sum _(k = 2)^(n) {Pr(A _k)}, P = 1/2^2+2/2^3+3/2^4+...+(n-2)/2^(n-1)+(n-1)/2^n. Multiplying both sides by 1/2, we get

P/2 = 1/2^3+2/2^4+3/2^5+...+(n-2)/2^n+(n-1)/2^(n+1). Subtracting this from the previous equation, we get

P/2 = 1/2^2+1/2^3+1/2^4+...+1/2^n-(n-1)/2^(n+1). Multiplying both sides by 1/2, we get

P/4 = 1/2^3+1/2^4+1/2^5+...+1/2^(n+1)-(n-1)/2^(n+2). Subtracting this from the previous equation, we get

P/4 = 1/2^2-n/2^(n+1)+(n-1)/2^(n+2),

P = 1-n/2^(n-1)+(n-1)/2^n. Now we seek the minimum n such that P >= 0.99,

1-n/2^(n-1)+(n-1)/2^n >= 0.99, or

n/2^(n-1)-(n-1)/2^n <= 0.01.

If n = 10, then n/2^(n-1)-(n-1)/2^n = 10/512-9/1024 = 11/1024 > 11/1100 = 0.01.

If n = 11, then n/2^(n-1)-(n-1)/2^n = 11/1024-10/2048 = 11/2048 < 11/1100 = 0.01. Hence the minimum number of bomb drops is n = 11.

Solution 3 (by Nishan Ranabhat).

The target is destroyed if at least two out of n(say) bombs dropped hits it directly. But 3 or more bombs may hit the target so;

[nC2 + nC3 +....+nCn] (1/2)^n >= 0.99

which give (2^n - n-1)/2^n >=0.99 => 2^n = 100(n+1) => n = 11 ( by trial method).

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...