After the Big Bang

The Friedmann equation, derived from Einstein's theory of general relativity, describes the expansion of the Universe after the Big Bang. The equation is, in a slightly simplified form, ( a ˙ a ) 2 = H 0 2 ( 1 Ω a 3 + Ω ) , \left( \frac{\dot a}{a} \right)^2 = H_0^2 \left( \frac{1-\Omega}{a^3}+\Omega \right), where Ω \Omega is the fraction of dark energy in the Universe, H 0 H_0 is the Hubble constant today, and a ( t ) a(t) is a dimensionless "size factor" selected so that its value today is a = 1 a=1 ( \big( for example, a ( t ) = R ( t ) / R 0 a(t)=R(t)/R_0 , the distance R R between Earth and a distant galaxy at time t t divided by the current distance ) . \big).

Based on the solution of this equation, what was the scale factor a a when the Universe was half of the age today?

Notes: Use Ω = 0.68 \Omega=0.68 . The quantity 1 Ω = 0.32 1-\Omega=0.32 represents the fraction of matter (regular and dark) in the Universe. The Hubble constant is H 0 = 1 14 × 1 0 9 years H_0=\dfrac{1}{14\times 10^9\text{ years}} . We neglected the energy contained by radiation and assumed that the Universe is flat, i.e. the matter and energy fractions add up to 1.


The answer is 0.5653.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Laszlo Mihaly
Dec 11, 2018

We will use H 0 = 1 H_0=1 as its value does not influence the answer. That is equivalent of measuring the time in units of 1 / H 0 1/H_0 .

The equation can be solved by separation of variables (or using one of the online services) and the solution is

a = 1 ( 2 Ω ) 2 / 3 e Ω ( t + c ) ( e 3 Ω ( t + c ) ( 1 Ω ) Ω ) 2 / 3 a=\frac{1}{(2\Omega)^{2/3}}e^{-\sqrt{\Omega}(t+c)}\left(e^{3\sqrt{\Omega}(t+c)}-(1-\Omega)\Omega\right)^{2/3}

To make sure that the Universe starts at t = 0 t=0 (i.e. a ( t = 0 ) = 0 a(t=0)=0 ) we have to solve

e 3 Ω c ( 1 Ω ) Ω = 0 e^{3\sqrt{\Omega}c}-(1-\Omega)\Omega=0

that yields

c = 1 3 Ω l n ( 1 Ω ) Ω c=\frac{1}{3\sqrt{\Omega}} ln (1-\Omega)\Omega

With this value of e 3 Ω c = ( 1 Ω ) Ω e^{3\sqrt{\Omega}c}=(1-\Omega)\Omega , and e Ω c = [ ( 1 Ω ) Ω ] 1 / 3 e^{-\sqrt{\Omega}c}=[(1-\Omega)\Omega]^{-1/3} . The function a a can be re-expressed ^* as

a = ( 1 Ω Ω ) 1 / 3 sinh 3 2 ( Ω t ) 2 / 3 a= \left(\frac{1-\Omega}{\Omega}\right)^{1/3} \sinh \frac{3}{2} \left(\sqrt{\Omega} t\right)^{2/3} .

The age of the current Universe is obtained by finding the time when a = 1 a=1 . This can be done by solving

1 = ( 1 Ω Ω ) 1 / 3 sinh 3 2 ( Ω t ) 2 / 3 1= \left(\frac{1-\Omega}{\Omega}\right)^{1/3} \sinh \frac{3}{2} \left(\sqrt{\Omega} t\right)^{2/3}

or by integrating the original differential equation

t 0 = 0 1 a 1 Ω + Ω a 3 d a t_0= \int_0^1{ \sqrt{\frac{a}{1-\Omega +\Omega a^3} }}da

Either way, the result is

t 0 = 1 3 Ω l n 1 + Ω 1 Ω = 0.9468 t_0=\frac{1}{3\sqrt{\Omega}} ln \frac {1+\sqrt{\Omega}}{1-\sqrt{\Omega}}=0.9468

We evaluate a ( t ) a(t) at t = t 0 / 2 t=t_0/2 and we get

a = 0.5653 a=0.5653

The graphs below show the evolution of the scale factor a a , the density of dark energy, the density of matter and the second time derivative of the scale factor. The red arrow points to the present time. Notice that in this model the dark energy takes over the matter at around t = 0.78 t=0.78 . The Universe's expansion turns from slowing down (negative a a'' ) to accelerating (positive a a'' ) around t = 0.54 t=0.54 .

* Thanks to Mark Hennings for pointing this out.

This needs tidying up. Either you are using a a as both the size factor (on the LHS of your first equation) and a constant (on the RHS) or else your solution is highly implicit. Since you proceed to try to evaluate c c in terms of a a , this implies that at least some of the a a in this formula are meant to be constants - perhaps they should be Ω \Omega . I refer you back to my solution to your other version of this problem - your solution here is not consistent with my solution, which is a = ( 1 Ω Ω ) 1 3 ( sinh ( 3 2 H 0 Ω t ) ) 2 3 a \; = \; \left(\tfrac{1-\Omega}{\Omega}\right)^{\frac13}\left(\sinh\left(\tfrac32H_0\sqrt{\Omega}t\right)\right)^{\frac23} where Ω 1 Ω = sinh ( 3 2 H 0 Ω t 0 ) \sqrt{\tfrac{\Omega}{1-\Omega}} \; = \; \sinh\left(\tfrac32H_0\sqrt{\Omega}t_0\right) where t 0 t_0 is the current age of the universe.

Mark Hennings - 2 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

Thanks. Indeed, there was a typo with the a Ω a \leftarrow \rightarrow \Omega that you correctly pointed out. It is fixed now. I m pretty sure that we have the same solution, presented in different mathematical form. (The numerical values also agree, originally mine was off by 0.0001 because of a roundoff error in t 0 / 2 t_0/2 .) Thanks again for taking the time to check it.

I do not know if you have access to this information, but I can see that as of this time nobody else have solved the problem. Congratulations.

Laszlo Mihaly - 2 years, 5 months ago

I suspect another mistake in the differential equation. It should be H0^2 instead of H0......because solutions have involved sinh of something that has dimentions! Sinh of a dimentioned quantity has no meaning!

Hari Krishna - 2 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

Yes you are right. It is fixed now. Fortunately, the result does not depend on this parameter.

Laszlo Mihaly - 2 years, 5 months ago

Now the question has been edited to be dimensionally correct, I have modified my comment...

Mark Hennings - 2 years, 5 months ago

The differential equation seems to be dimensionally incorrect. LHS has units inverse time squared but RHS has units inverse time. Is that H_0 supposed to be squared on the RHS?

Tom Richards - 2 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

We have fixed that. The result did not depend on that term.

Laszlo Mihaly - 2 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

Thanks! It matters quite a lot if you don't set it to 1...

Tom Richards - 2 years, 5 months ago

integral 1/√(0.32/x + 0.68 x^2) dx from 0 to 1 = 0.94677

Thus, current time is 0.94677. Probably time interval is half of 0.94677=0.473385 for the problem.

integral 1/√(0.32/x + 0.68 x^2) dx from 0.5653 to 1= 0.4734

integral 1/√(0.32/x + 0.68 x^2) dx from 0 to 0.5653= 0.4734

Thus, Answer=0.5653

Vinod Kumar - 2 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

This one is correct.

Laszlo Mihaly - 2 years, 5 months ago

@Laszlo Mihaly Are you the mention[4614574:Laszlo Mihaly]? https://www.booktopia.com.au/solid-state-physics-l-szl-mih-ly/book/9783527408559.html

Krishna Karthik - 8 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...