A probability problem by harsh poddar

( 7 + 4 3 ) n = p + q (7+4\sqrt{3})^{n}=p+q where n n and p p are positive integers and q q is a proper fraction. Find ( 1 q ) ( p + q ) (1-q)(p+q)


The answer is 1.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Harsh Khatri
Feb 29, 2016

This is quite a popular problem.

By binomial expansion we have:

( 7 + 4 3 ) n = r = 0 n ( n r ) ( 7 ) n r ( 4 3 ) r = p + q (7+ 4\sqrt3)^n = \displaystyle \sum_{r=0}^{n} {n\choose r} (7) ^{n-r} (4\sqrt3) ^{r} = p+q

for p I , q ( 0 , 1 ) p \in I, q \in (0,1)

and

( 7 4 3 ) n = r = 0 n ( n r ) ( 7 ) n r ( 4 3 ) r = t (7 - 4\sqrt3)^n = \displaystyle \sum_{r=0}^{n} {n\choose r} (7)^{n-r} (-4\sqrt3)^r = t

Now,

0 < 7 4 3 < 1 0<7-4\sqrt3<1

0 < ( 7 4 3 ) n < 1 \displaystyle \Rightarrow 0< (7-4\sqrt3)^n<1

t ( 0 , 1 ) \displaystyle \Rightarrow t \in (0,1)

Adding the two expansions, we get:

( 7 + 4 3 ) n + ( 7 4 3 ) n = 2 ( ( n 0 ) ( 7 ) n ) + ( 0 ) + 2 ( ( n 2 ) ( 7 ) n 2 ( 4 3 ) 2 ) + ( 0 ) + \big( 7+4\sqrt3\big)^n + \big(7-4\sqrt3\big)^n = 2\big( {n\choose 0} (7)^n\big) + (0) + 2\big( {n\choose2} (7)^{n-2} (4\sqrt3)^2\big) + (0) + \ldots

All the terms where r r is odd get cancelled and only even powers of ( 4 3 ) (4\sqrt3) remain, i.e., the RHS of the equation is an integer.

p + q + t = i n t e g e r \displaystyle \Rightarrow p + q + t = integer

For q , t ( 0 , 1 ) ; 0 < q + t < 2 q, t \in (0,1) ; 0<q+t<2

And since the RHS and p p are integers, q + t q+t is also an integer. We conclude q + t = 1 q + t = 1 since 0 < q + t < 2 0< q + t < 2 .

( 1 q ) = t = ( 7 4 3 ) n \displaystyle \Rightarrow (1-q) = t = (7-4\sqrt3)^n

( 1 q ) ( p + q ) = { ( 7 4 3 ) ( 7 + 4 3 ) } n = ( 49 16 ( 3 ) ) n = 1 \displaystyle \Rightarrow (1-q)(p+q) =\{ (7-4\sqrt3)(7+4\sqrt3) \} ^{n} =(49 - 16(3))^n = \boxed{1}

Note : Some problems might even ask to comment whether p p is divisible by 2 or 4 or any multiple of 2, also what is the remainder when p p is divided by 2 and other similar questions. It is now trivial to prove that p p is odd. I'll leave the proof as an exercise.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...