Holy field

A sphere is uniformly charged with charge density ρ \rho and has radius R R . A spherical cavity of radius R / 4 R/4 is made in it such that center of original sphere lies on its circumference. P is a point on the line segment joining the two centers. Find the electric field strength at P , E P E_\text{P} .

71 ρ R / 54 ϵ \rho R/54\epsilon 35 ρ R / 108 ϵ \rho R/108\epsilon 27 ρ R / 112 ϵ \rho R/112\epsilon ρ R / 12 ϵ \rho R/12\epsilon

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Gregory Ruffa
May 15, 2014

A standard "trick" in dealing with a cavity in a uniform (constant density) charge distribution is to treat it as a volume with the same charge density of opposite sign . We thus impose a sphere of radius R 4 \ \frac{R}{4} \ with charge density ρ \ -\rho \ , embedded within a space with charge density + ρ +\rho \ . (It is not terribly important that this "space" is inside a sphere, since its surface is relatively far away.) This "imagined" negative charge distribution "cancels" the ambient positive charge, effectively producing a region of zero net charge.

Our little sphere is centered at r = R 4 \ r \ = \frac{R}{4} , relative to the center of the large sphere. So the point P is at a distance of R 8 \ \frac{R}{8} \ from the centers of both spheres. Using "Gauss' Law" (the Divergence Theorem, as applied to electostatic charge distributions), since the densities are constant and the fields of electric charges are "radial" (they point away or toward the charge in every direction, with a specific field strength at any fixed distance from the charge), we may write, describing the field at P ,

S E d A = V E d V E 4 π ( R 8 ) 2 = ρ ϵ 0 4 π 3 ( R 8 ) 3 , \iint_S \ \vec{E} \ \cdot \ d\vec{A} \ = \ \iiint_V \ \nabla \cdot \vec{E} \ dV \ \ \Rightarrow \ \ \vec{E} \cdot \ 4 \pi \ \left( \frac{R}{8} \right)^2 \ = \ \frac{\rho}{\epsilon_0} \cdot \frac{4 \pi}{3} \left( \frac{R}{8} \right)^3 ,

the strength of the field E \ \vec{E} \ over the surface area of the sphere of radius R 8 \ \frac{R}{8} \ , which extends from either center to point P , being equal to the total charge within that sphere divided by ϵ 0 \ \epsilon_0 \ . This reduces to

E = ρ 3 ϵ 0 ( R 8 ) = ρ R 24 ϵ 0 \vec{E} \ = \ \frac{\rho}{3 \epsilon_0} \left( \frac{R}{8} \right) \ = \ \frac{\rho \ R}{24 \ \epsilon_0}

for the field due to each charge distribution. For the positive charge distribution of the large sphere, the field points radially outward from its center, and thus toward P . For the effective negative charge distribution, its field points radially inward toward the center of the cavity, and so also toward P . The sum of these fields is then the total field at P ,

E P = ρ R 12 ϵ 0 \vec{E_P} \ = \ \frac{\rho \ R}{12 \ \epsilon_0} \ directed outward from the center of the large sphere.

How take P is at a distance R/8

bincy mathew - 6 years, 11 months ago

This solution appears to make an assumption not supported by the statement of the problem. The problem says "P is a point on the line segment joining the two centers." It does not say that P is half way between the two centers, which is assumed by the solution in saying "So the point P is at a distance of R/8 from the centers of both spheres."

I believe the solution should be based on the position of P which is limited but not exactly specified in the problem. Can anyone clarify this?

jaime castells - 4 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

Exactly, even I have the same doubt. But I assumed point P to be right at the center of the original sphere and the answer I got was still the same. So it seems that the answer is independent of the position of the point p, as long as it is on the specified line.

Anuj Shikarkhane - 11 months, 2 weeks ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...