An equation involving divisors

For a positive integer n n , let d ( n ) d(n) be the number of positive divisors of n n . Find the sum of all positive integers n n such that d ( n ) 3 = 4 n d(n)^3=4n

If you think there are no such n n , then insert 1 -1 as your answer.


The answer is 2130.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Brian Moehring
Aug 3, 2018

Let p m p_m denote the m m th prime number. Then we can write the prime factorization of n n as n = m = 1 M p m a m n = \prod_{m=1}^M p_m^{a_m} for some positive integer M M and non-negative integers a m a_m for m = 1 , 2 , , M . m=1,2,\ldots, M. Then the given equation becomes ( m = 1 M ( a m + 1 ) ) 3 = 4 n = 2 a 1 + 2 3 a 2 5 a 3 m = 4 M p m a m \left(\prod_{m=1}^M (a_m+1)\right)^3 = 4n = 2^{a_1+2}\cdot 3^{a_2}\cdot 5^{a_3}\cdot \prod_{m=4}^M p_m^{a_m} Since the left-hand side is a perfect cube, the right-hand side must be as well, so each of the exponents in the prime factorization must be a multiple of 3. 3. Therefore, there are non-negative integers b m b_m such that a 1 = 3 b 1 + 1 a_1 = 3b_1+1 and a m = 3 b m a_m = 3b_m for all m = 2 , 3 , , M , m=2,3,\ldots, M, giving ( ( 3 b 1 + 2 ) ( 3 b 2 + 1 ) ( 3 b 3 + 1 ) m = 4 M ( 3 b m + 1 ) ) 3 = 2 3 b 1 + 3 3 3 b 2 5 3 b 3 m = 4 M p m 3 b m \left((3b_1+2)(3b_2+1)(3b_3+1)\prod_{m=4}^M (3b_m+1)\right)^3 = 2^{3b_1+3} \cdot 3^{3b_2} \cdot 5^{3b_3} \cdot \prod_{m=4}^M p_m^{3b_m} ( 3 b 1 + 2 ) ( 3 b 2 + 1 ) ( 3 b 3 + 1 ) m = 4 M ( 3 b m + 1 ) = 2 b 1 + 1 3 b 2 5 b 3 m = 4 M p m b m (3b_1+2)(3b_2+1)(3b_3+1)\prod_{m=4}^M (3b_m+1) = 2^{b_1+1} \cdot 3^{b_2} \cdot 5^{b_3} \cdot \prod_{m=4}^M p_m^{b_m} From here, we note that the left-hand side isn't divisible by 3 3 , so the right-hand side isn't divisible by 3 3 either, so b 2 = 0 , b_2=0, now yielding ( 3 b 1 + 2 ) ( 3 b 3 + 1 ) m = 4 M ( 3 b m + 1 ) = 2 b 1 + 1 5 b 3 m = 4 M p m b m (3b_1+2)(3b_3+1)\prod_{m=4}^M (3b_m+1) = 2^{b_1+1} \cdot 5^{b_3} \cdot \prod_{m=4}^M p_m^{b_m} 2 b 1 + 1 3 b 1 + 2 5 b 3 3 b 3 + 1 = ( m = 4 M p m b m 3 b m + 1 ) 1 \frac{2^{b_1+1}}{3b_1+2} \cdot \frac{5^{b_3}}{3b_3+1} = \left(\prod_{m=4}^M \frac{p_m^{b_m}}{3b_m+1}\right)^{-1}

We can check that the minimum of the left-hand side of this equation occurs when b 1 = 1 , b 3 = 0 b_1=1, b_3=0 so 4 5 ( m = 4 M p m b m 3 b m + 1 ) 1 m = 4 M p m b m 3 b m + 1 5 4 \frac{4}{5} \leq \left(\prod_{m=4}^M \frac{p_m^{b_m}}{3b_m+1}\right)^{-1} \\ \implies \prod_{m=4}^M \frac{p_m^{b_m}}{3b_m+1} \leq \frac{5}{4} Obviously this is satisfied when all the b m = 0 b_m = 0 for m = 4 , 5 , , M m=4,5,\ldots,M , but if we assume that at least one of them is nonzero, then the minimum value would occur when b 4 = 1 b_4=1 and b m = 0 b_m=0 for m = 5 , 6 , , M m=5,6,\ldots,M , giving 7 4 = 7 1 3 ( 1 ) + 1 m = 5 M p m 0 3 ( 0 ) + 1 m = 4 M p m b m 3 b m + 1 5 4 \frac{7}{4} = \frac{7^1}{3(1)+1} \prod_{m=5}^M \frac{p_m^0}{3(0)+1} \leq \prod_{m=4}^M \frac{p_m^{b_m}}{3b_m+1} \leq \frac{5}{4} which is a contradiction, so we must have b m = 0 b_m=0 for all m 4 m\geq 4 .


Going back to a previous equation, we now want to solve ( 3 b 1 + 2 ) ( 3 b 3 + 1 ) = 2 b 1 + 1 5 b 3 (3b_1+2)(3b_3+1) = 2^{b_1+1} \cdot 5^{b_3} which we can do just by cases with b 3 b_3 as follows:

  • Case b 3 = 0 b_3=0 : Then 3 b 1 + 2 = 2 b 1 + 1 3b_1+2 = 2^{b_1+1} . We can check that b 1 = 0 , 2 b_1=0,2 are solutions and b 1 = 1 b_1=1 is not a solution just by plugging in those values. Further, for b 1 > 2 b_1 > 2 we have 2 b 1 + 1 > 3 b 1 + 2 2^{b_1+1} > 3b_1+2 , so the only two solutions are b 1 = 0 , 2. b_1=0,2.
  • Case b 3 = 1 b_3=1 : Then 3 b 1 + 2 = 5 2 b 1 1 3b_1+2 = 5 \cdot 2^{b_1-1} , then similarly, we can see that b 1 = 0 b_1=0 is not a solution and b 1 = 1 b_1=1 is a solution by plugging values in. Further, for b 1 > 1 b_1>1 we have 5 2 b 1 1 > 3 b 1 + 2 5\cdot 2^{b_1-1} > 3b_1+2 , so the only solution is b 1 = 1. b_1=1.
  • Case b 3 > 1 b_3>1 : Then ( 2 b 1 + 1 3 b 1 + 2 ) 1 = 5 b 3 3 b 3 + 1 > 5 4 2 b 1 + 1 3 b 1 + 2 < 4 5 \left(\frac{2^{b_1+1}}{3b_1+2}\right)^{-1} = \frac{5^{b_3}}{3b_3+1} > \frac{5}{4} \\ \implies \frac{2^{b_1+1}}{3b_1+2} < \frac{4}{5} but as our previous analysis implied, 2 b 1 + 1 3 b 1 + 2 4 5 , \frac{2^{b_1+1}}{3b_1+2} \geq \frac{4}{5}, so this is a contradiction, and there is no solution in this case.

Therefore we have shown three solutions, given by ( b 1 , b 3 ) { ( 0 , 0 ) , ( 2 , 0 ) , ( 1 , 1 ) } (b_1,b_3) \in \{(0,0), (2,0), (1,1)\} and all other b m = 0 b_m =0 . Since then n = 2 3 b 1 + 1 5 3 b 3 n = 2^{3b_1+1} \cdot 5^{3b_3} which means the answer is 2 3 ( 0 ) + 1 5 3 ( 0 ) + 2 3 ( 2 ) + 1 5 3 ( 0 ) + 2 3 ( 1 ) + 1 5 3 ( 1 ) = 2 + 128 + 2000 = 2130 2^{3(0)+1}\cdot 5^{3(0)} + 2^{3(2)+1}\cdot 5^{3(0)} + 2^{3(1)+1}\cdot 5^{3(1)} = 2 + 128 + 2000 = \boxed{2130}

I was a little lazy in justifying the minima I used, but all of them can be shown using elementary methods. In my case, I had taken the derivatives of functions of the form f ( x ) = 2 x + 1 3 x + 2 , g ( x ) = p x 3 x + 1 f(x) = \frac{2^{x+1}}{3x+2}, \qquad g(x) = \frac{p^x}{3x+1} to find their critical points on the real line, and then just plugged in integers around each critical point. This ended up sufficing for each time I needed to use them.

Brian Moehring - 2 years, 10 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...