Submitted by Somesh Patil

Bella keeps a supply of red, blue, and black pens in a drawer. The drawer has 17 red pens, 18 blue pens, and 12 black pens. If Bella wants a red pen, what is the minimum number of pens she has to pull out from the drawer to make sure she gets a red pen?


The answer is 31.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

18 solutions

To make sure Bella gets a red pen ( at least one), we must suppose the worst case .

The worst case is, Bella is not so lucky to pull out a red pen immediately, she pulls out all the blue pens and black pens. However, the next pen that she will pull out will be a red pen .(Because there are no pens in other colours in the drawer)

As stated in the problem, the drawer has 18 18 blue pens and 12 12 black pens. There are 18 + 12 = 30 18+12=30 blue and black pens altogether. Therefore, the minimum number of pens she must pull out = 30 + 1 = 31 =30+1=\boxed{31} .

what a explanation!!!!! thanks

baasra jamal - 7 years, 5 months ago

Great explanation!

Mira B - 7 years, 5 months ago

Thank you

AAditya Barot - 7 years, 5 months ago

Thanks !

soha elghool - 7 years, 3 months ago

lets see, chance for bella to get red pens is 17/47 that almost 1/3, so bella only need to take 3 pens to make sure that she gets the red pen

Aldi Dwi Putra - 7 years, 3 months ago

Man you are amazing

Shaikh Iqbal - 7 years, 3 months ago

In the worst case scenario, Bella would have to pull out all of the blue and black pens to get a red one.

Because there are 30 30 non-red pens, Bella will have to pull out a minimum of 30 + 1 = 31 30 + 1 = 31 pens out of drawer to be one-hundred percent sure she has taken out a red pen.

A very nice solution !

Devesh Rai - 7 years, 5 months ago
Cedomir Timovski
Dec 22, 2013

Worst situation, she has pulled out only black and blue pens. Finally, she pulled out pens of other color, in the box there are only red pens. Answer is: 12+18+1=31... She must pull out 31 pens. :)

Bhargav Das
Dec 20, 2013

We need to take here extreme cases that is we consider whatever we take, we first take out the blue and the black pens out(if possible). 18 18 pens + 12 +12 pens = 30 =30 pens, what I mean is that if our answer is 30 30 ,then we can claim that those 30 30 belong to only blue and black colours,so our answer is 31 31 ,why?Since there are no more pens of colour other than red.Hence, our answer is 31 \boxed{31} .

  1. To get the possibility that red pens are pulled out, we must eliminate the possibility that black or blue pens are pulled out.
  2. To make sure that there is a not-blue pen has been picked, we must pulled out 19 of the total pens. If so, there must be at least 1 not-blue pen.
  3. Assume (the worst possibility) that there is still 12 black pens inside the drawer. Add 19 with 12 to make sure that we have picked at least 1 pen which is not blue or black. This gives us 31 \boxed {31}
Sai Bulusu
Dec 21, 2013

18 blue 12 black 17 RED

You can pull 30 (18 + 12) in a row and still end up without a red pen. Draw one more, and the last one is guaranteed to be a red pen. 31 is the answer

Palash Som
Sep 30, 2014

SHE MIGHT BE TOO UNLUCKY TO GET A RED PEN UNTIL ALL THE BLUE AND RED PENS ARE TAKEN OUT - therefore total no. of pens she need ton take out to get atleast 1 red pen is 18+ 12+1 = 31

Pola Forest
May 7, 2014

Add the blue and black pens togheter, as if she would pull out all of them. Then add 1 - wich will surely be a red one. ( the answer is 31).

Shaikh Iqbal
Mar 13, 2014

i agree with Peng Ying Tan amazing job man

Balaji Kumar
Feb 20, 2014

IF BELLA GETS A RED PEN THEN SHE NEVER SEARCHES AGAIN FOR PENS . ALSO THERE MAY BE A CHANCE OF PICKING 18 BLUE AND 12 BLACK PENS BEFORE SHE GETS A RED PEN. THEREFORE 18+12+1 = 31

Tamil Arasan
Feb 13, 2014

well ! bella have totally 47 pens! if she get 30 pen assume until no red pen come in drawer ..so after that if she get 1 pen (31 pen) that should red pen so the minimum possibility is 31

Sathiya Narayanan
Dec 21, 2013

blue=18+black=12

Prasun Biswas
Dec 21, 2013

To make sure that Bella gets a red pen on pulling out the pens, we have to take out all the blue and black pens first so as to make the drawer full of only red pens.

Then, since only one red pen is required, so we have to pull out one more pen from the drawer. So, total no. of pens to be pulled out = ( 18 + 12 + 1 ) = 31 =(18+12+1) = \boxed{31}

Abishanka Saha
Dec 21, 2013

If she draws any less than 31 31 pens then that may only comprise blue and black pens. As there are in total 30 30 blue and black pens, if she draws 31 31 pens then at least one has to be red.

Hamza Waseem
Dec 20, 2013

Since a red pen is required, sum up all the pens of other colours and add 1. The result is the answer.

Barath K
Dec 20, 2013

given that there are 17 red pens , 18 blue pens and 12 black pens. We may think that at first draw only we can get a red pen, so min. no. of draws is 1, we think. But we can't sure to that the drawn pen is red. If we have drawn all black pens and blue pens we can surely say that next drawn pen is red so the min. no. of pens she has to pull out from the drawer to make sure she gets a red pen is no. of black pens + no. of blue pens + next draw(for red pen) = 12+18+1=31

Stephen Liu
Dec 20, 2013

Suppose that Bella is a very unlucky person. In this worst case scenario, Bella pulls out all the pens that are not red before finally getting a red one. Thus, the minimum number of pens she has to pull out is 18 + 12 + 1 = 31 18+12+1=\boxed{31} .

Hùng Minh
Dec 20, 2013

If she pull out 30 pens, so it can be 18 blue pens + 12 black pens <=> she has to pull out one more. So, the result is 31

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...