Any Real?

Algebra Level 4

P ( x ) P(x) and Q ( x ) Q(x) are two polynomials with real coefficients satisfying below conditions:

( 1 ) (1) : a a and b b are the roots of P ( x ) P(x) and Q ( x ) Q(x) respectively.

( 2 ) (2) : P ( b ) Q ( a ) > 0 P(b)Q(a)>0 .

Then is there any real c c exists such that P ( c ) = Q ( c ) P(c)=Q(c) ?

False 0 True Can not be determined Value exists but not real

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Kushal Bose
May 10, 2016

As said in the question that a and b are roots of P ( x ) P(x) and Q ( x ) Q(x) respectively then it can be said that P ( a ) = 0 P(a)=0 and Q ( b ) = 0 Q(b)=0 .

Let, consider a new polynomial such that R ( x ) = P ( x ) Q ( x ) R(x)=P(x)-Q(x) .

Put a a and b b in this equation and we get
R ( a ) = P ( a ) Q ( a ) = Q ( a ) R(a)=P(a)-Q(a)=-Q(a) and R ( b ) = P ( b ) Q ( b ) = P ( b ) R(b)=P(b)-Q(b)=P(b) .

Now, R ( a ) R ( b ) = P ( b ) Q ( a ) < 0 R(a)R(b)= -P(b)Q(a) <0 because P ( b ) Q ( a ) > 0 P(b)Q(a)>0 in the question

So, there exists a real c c in between ( a , b ) (a,b) such that R ( c ) = 0 R(c)=0 because R ( a ) R ( b ) < 0 R(a)R(b)<0 .

Then R ( c ) = 0 R(c)=0 i.e. P ( c ) Q ( c ) = 0 P(c)-Q(c)=0 so, P ( c ) = Q ( c ) P(c)=Q(c)

Nice problem, Kushal. As Deeparaj has pointed out, this holds true for any continuous functions P ( x ) P(x) and Q ( x ) Q(x) . I have also edited the Latex in your solution, so the math equations are easier to read.

Pranshu Gaba - 5 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Yeah Thank you...

Kushal Bose - 5 years, 1 month ago

Simple math is more important for humanity. But ones you label things as level 4.there is tendency for people to complicate things. There are extremely mysterious looking things which can be proved by using simple theorems like mean value theorems. Thanks for the problem.

Srikanth Tupurani - 2 years, 11 months ago

Consider the function f ( x ) = P ( x ) Q ( x ) f(x)=P(x)-Q(x)

As both P ( x ) P(x) and Q ( x ) Q(x) are continuous functions (since they are polynomials), so is f ( x ) f(x) .

Note that f ( a ) = Q ( a ) f ( b ) = P ( b ) f(a)=-Q(a) \\ f(b)=P(b) by the given hypothesis.

Now, f ( a ) f ( b ) = P ( b ) Q ( a ) < 0 ( By the given hypothesis ) f(a)f(b)=-P(b)Q(a)<0 \quad (\text{By the given hypothesis})

Hence, f ( a ) f(a) and f ( b ) f(b) are of opposite signs . Therefore, by the intermediate value theorem we have f ( c ) = 0 P ( c ) = Q ( c ) for some c lying between a and b f(c)=0\\ \implies P(c)=Q(c) \\ \text{for some } c \text{ lying between } a \text{ and } b


Note:

Even if we were merely given that P ( x ) a n d Q ( x ) P(x)\: and \: Q(x) are continuous with the fact that P ( b ) Q ( a ) > 0 P(b)Q(a)>0 the conclusion still holds.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...