Aren't Both Sides the Same for Both Degrees and Radians?

Geometry Level 3

We know that in radians cos ( π + θ ) = cos ( θ ) \cos\left(\pi + \theta\right) = -\cos\left(\theta\right) has infinite number of solutions. If suppose the arguments for both sides are in degrees , how many solutions are there for the interval [ 0 , 360 ) [0,360) ?

2 \infty 1 0

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

You might draw a circle and draw an angle theta to find out there are 2 solutions

Much easier approach is to observe the shifts of the cos \cos equations. Actually, you don't need to determine θ \theta to show that there are 2 2 solutions. I will post the solution when I have time.

Michael Huang - 4 years, 6 months ago

I have posted the new solution in case you are curious about the methods. :)

Michael Huang - 4 years, 6 months ago
Michael Huang
Dec 14, 2016

Relevant wiki: Graphical Transformation of Trigonometric Functions

There are several approaches for this problem.


Method 1 - Elementary Trigonometry


Recall that the general form of the sine equation is y = α sin ( β ( θ δ ) ) + γ y = \alpha \sin\left(\beta\left(\theta - \delta\right)\right) + \gamma where

  • α \left|\alpha\right| represents the amplitude, which determines the maximum and minimum value of sin \sin relative to γ \gamma
  • 2 π β \left|\dfrac{2\pi}{\beta}\right| represents the periodicity
  • δ \delta represents the phase shift, which horizontally shift the graph
  • γ \gamma represents the vertical shift

Let y 1 = cos ( π + θ ) y_1 = \cos\left(\pi + \theta\right) and y 2 = cos ( θ ) y_2 = -\cos\left(\theta\right) . If both of them are in degrees, then since 1 degree = π 180 radians 1\text{ degree} = \dfrac{\pi}{180}\text{ radians} , y 1 = cos ( π + θ ) = cos ( π 180 ( π + θ ) ) y 2 = cos ( θ ) = cos ( π 180 θ ) \begin{array}{rl} y_1 = \cos\left(\pi + \theta\right) &= \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\left(\pi + \theta\right)\right)\\ y_2 = -\cos\left(\theta\right) &= -\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) \end{array} Using the general sine form, we see that

For y 1 = cos ( π 180 ( θ + π ) ) y_1 = \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\left(\theta + \pi\right)\right) ...

  • The amplitude is 1 1 .
  • The periodicity is 2 π × 180 π = 360 \left|2\pi \times \frac{180}{\pi}\right| = 360 .
  • The phase shift is π -\pi , which represents sin \sin shifted horizontally to the left.
  • There is no vertical shift.

For y 2 = cos ( π 180 θ ) y_2 = -\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right)

  • The amplitude is also 1 1 . Note that since y 2 y_2 is negative, the graph is reflected with respect to the x x -axis.
  • The periodicity is also 360 360 .
  • Both phase and vertical shifts do not occur.

Figure 1. Orange graph represents \(y_1\), whereas red graph represents \(y_2\). Figure 1. Orange graph represents y 1 y_1 , whereas red graph represents y 2 y_2 . Since the only difference between y 1 y_1 and y 2 y_2 is the phase shift (see Figure 1), and since their periodicities are both 360 360 , this guarantees that there are 2 intersection points \boxed{\text{2 intersection points}} of both functions.


Method 2 - Direct Computation


This problem is also approachable by computation. Expanding the left hand side, we have cos ( π 180 ( π + θ ) ) = cos ( π 2 180 + π 180 θ ) \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\left(\pi + \theta\right)\right) = \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180} + \dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) The sum-angle formula of cos \cos shows that if cos ( α + β ) = cos ( α ) cos ( β ) sin ( α ) sin ( β ) \cos(\alpha + \beta) = \cos(\alpha)\cos(\beta) - \sin(\alpha)\sin(\beta) letting α = π 2 180 \alpha = \dfrac{\pi^2}{180} and β = π 180 θ \beta = \dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta , cos ( α + β ) = cos ( π 2 180 ) cos ( π 180 θ ) sin ( π 2 180 ) sin ( π 180 θ ) \cos(\alpha + \beta) = \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) - \sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) So we evaluate cos ( π 2 180 ) cos ( π 180 θ ) sin ( π 2 180 ) sin ( π 180 θ ) = cos ( π 180 θ ) \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) - \sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) = -\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) Solving for θ \theta , cos ( π 2 180 ) cos ( π 180 θ ) sin ( π 2 180 ) sin ( π 180 θ ) = cos ( π 180 θ ) cos ( π 2 180 ) sin ( π 2 180 ) tan ( π 180 θ ) = 1 Divide both sides by cos ( π 180 θ ) cos ( π 2 180 ) + 1 = sin ( π 2 180 ) tan ( π 180 θ ) Rearranging terms tan ( π 180 θ ) = cos ( π 2 180 ) + 1 sin ( π 2 180 ) π 180 θ = arctan ( cos ( π 2 180 ) + 1 sin ( π 2 180 ) ) + π k where k Z θ = 180 π arctan ( cos ( π 2 180 ) + 1 sin ( π 2 180 ) ) + 180 k Multiply both sides by 180 π \begin{array}{rlccl} \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) - \sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) &= -\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right)\\ \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) - \sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\tan\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) &= -1 & & & {\color{#3D99F6}\text{Divide both sides by }\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right)}\\ \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) + 1 &= \sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)\tan\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) & & & {\color{#3D99F6}\text{Rearranging terms}}\\ \tan\left(\dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta\right) &= \dfrac{\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) + 1}{\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)}\\ \dfrac{\pi}{180}\theta &= \arctan\left(\dfrac{\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) + 1}{\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)}\right) + \pi k & & & {\color{#3D99F6}\text{where }k\in\mathbb{Z}}\\ \theta &= \dfrac{180}{\pi}\arctan\left(\dfrac{\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) + 1}{\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)}\right) + 180k & & & {\color{#3D99F6}\text{Multiply both sides by }\dfrac{180}{\pi}} \end{array} Since in radians 0 < π 2 180 < π 2 0 < \dfrac{\pi^2}{180} < \dfrac{\pi}{2} , and since π 2 180 \dfrac{\pi^2}{180} is more close to 0 0 than to π 2 \dfrac{\pi}{2} , this shows that 0 < sin ( π 2 180 ) < cos ( π 2 180 ) < 1 0 < \sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) < \cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) < 1 which implies that tan > 0 \tan > 0 . Then 0 < θ 1 = 180 π arctan ( cos ( π 2 180 ) + 1 sin ( π 2 180 ) ) < 180 0 < \theta_1 = \dfrac{180}{\pi}\arctan\left(\dfrac{\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) + 1}{\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)}\right) < 180 which shows that θ 1 \theta_1 is one the solutions. However, another solution is θ 2 = 180 π arctan ( cos ( π 2 180 ) + 1 sin ( π 2 180 ) ) + 180 \theta_2 = \dfrac{180}{\pi}\arctan\left(\dfrac{\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right) + 1}{\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi^2}{180}\right)}\right) + 180 So we have found 2 unique solutions \boxed{2\text{ unique solutions}} between [ 0 , 360 ) [0,360) .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...