Arithmetic Progression With Primes

There is only one arithmetic progression with 10 terms and positive difference which are all primes less than 3000.
Find the sum of the 10 terms.


The answer is 11440.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Karim Fawaz
Jun 18, 2016

Relevant wiki: Arithmetic and Geometric Progressions Problem Solving

Before starting: Assume the Arithmetic Progression (AP) has its first term a and its difference d. So its general term will be:

t n = a + ( n 1 ) d . t_{n} = a + (n - 1)d.

Since all primes (except for 2) are odd, therefore the difference d between any 2 successive terms should be even or a multiple of 2.

Since any consecutive 3 terms must be prime, none of them should be divisible by 3. Therefore, the difference d between any 2 successive terms should be a multiple of 3.

Since any consecutive 5 terms must be prime, none of them should be divisible by 5. Therefore, the difference d between any 2 successive terms should be a multiple of 5.

Since any consecutive 7 terms must be prime, none of them should be divisible by 7. Therefore, the difference d between any 2 successive terms should be a multiple of 7.

Therefore d should be a multiple of 2 X 3 X 5 X 7 = 210.

Therefore d should be in the form 210k where k is a positive integer.

Since all terms are less than 3000, therefore:

t 10 = a + 9 d < 3000 t_{10} = a + 9 d < 3000

a + 9 X 210 k < 3000 a + 1890 k < 3000 1890 k < 3000 k < 1.587 k = 1 That means d = 210.

Since a + 1890 < 3000 a < 3000 – 1890 a < 1110.

Conclusion: This AP has the first term is a prime number less than 1110 and the difference is 210.

The general term of this AP is : a + (n – 1)d = a + (n – 1) X 210.

t n = a + 210 n 210. t_{n} = a + 210 n - 210.

Since all terms are prime so none of the numbers should be a multiple of 11 except if the first term a = 11. Therefore :

t n t_{n} mod 11 > 0 for n > 1.

For n = 1, we can have a = 11. In this case,

t 2 = 11 + 210 = 221 = ( 13 X 17 ) t_{2} = 11 + 210 = 221 = (13 X 17) which is composite and not prime. This should be rejected.

We have now:

(a + 210 n – 210) mod 11 > 0 for n = 1, 2, 3, … 10.

(a + 210(n – 1)) mod 11 > 0 for n = 1, 2, 3, … 10.

(a + n – 1) mod 11 > 0 for n = 1, 2, 3, … 10.

That means a, a + 1, a + 2, … a+9 are not multiples of 11. That happens only if a + 10 is a multiple of 11 or a mod 11 = 1. That means a = 11 k + 1.

Since a < 1110 11 k + 1 < 1110 11 k < 1109 k < 100.8, therefore k = 1, 2, 3, … , 100.

Also note that when k is odd a is even and vice vera. Since we want a to be odd, k has to be even. We can rewrite the formula for a in the form: a = 22 m + 1 where m = 1, 2, 3, … 50

In that case:

t n = 22 m + 1 + 210 n 210 = 22 m + 210 n 209. t_{n} = 22 m + 1 + 210 n - 210 = 22 m + 210 n - 209.

Since /(t_{n}/) mod 13 > 0, therefore (22 m + 210 n – 209) mod 13 > 0.
(9m + 2n – 1) mod 13 > 0 for m = 1,2,3 … 50 and for n = 1,2,3 … 10

Substituting n by the values 1,2,3 to 10 we get: 9m mod 13 > 0, 9m + 1 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 2 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 3 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 4 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 5 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 6 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 7 mod 13 > 0, 9m + 9 mod 13 > 0, and 9m + 11 mod 13 > 0. (for m = 1,2,3 … 50)

That means the only possibles values for m will be when : 9m + 8 mod 13 = 0, 9m + 10 mod 13 = 0, and 9m + 12 mod 13 = 0. (for m = 1,2,3 … 50)

This will give us the possible values for m: Since 9m + 8 mod 13 = 0 gives us m = 2, 15, 28 and 43. 9m + 10 mod 13 = 0 gives us m = 9, 22, 35 and 48. 9m + 12 mod 13 = 0 gives us m = 3, 16, 29 and 44.

Since a = 22m + 1, these 12 values of m will give us the following 12 values for a (in order): a = 45, 67, 199, 331, 353, 485, 617, 639, 771, 947, 969, 1057

Excluding the composite numbers we get the possible values for a to be prime are: a = 67, 199, 331, 353, 617, 947.

If a = 67: AP will be: 67, 277, 487, 697 (= 17 X 41) to be rejected

If a = 331: AP will be: 331, 541, 761, 971, 1181, 1391 (= 13 X 107) to be rejected

If a = 353: AP will be: 353, 563, 773, 983, 1193, 1403 (= 23 X 61) to be rejected

If a = 617: AP will be: 617, 827, 1037 (= 17 X 61) to be rejected

If a = 947: AP will be: 947, 1157 (= 13 X 89) to be rejected

The only one which works is when a = 199: AP will be: 199, 409, 619, 829, 1039, 1249, 1459, 1669, 1879, 2089

In this case: the total will be: 10 2 \frac{10}{2} X (199 + 2089) = 11440

Answer = 11440 \boxed{11440}

why not this Since any consecutive 13 terms must be prime, none of them should be divisible by 13. Therefore, the difference d between any 2 successive terms should be a multiple of 13. then 17,19 and why a = 11. ?

A Former Brilliant Member - 4 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

You can not consider the case of 13 terms because the problem states that they are only 10 terms. This means the 11th term and all following terms don't have to be primes.

Karim Fawaz - 4 years, 10 months ago

I arrived at d = 210 d = 210 using exactly the same argument as presented and had the very same idea about the starting point: a 11 1 a\underset{11}{\sim}1 , thus eliminating a lot of primes. I thought about using the same scheme for 13, 17, etc., but at that point there are just 18 primes left that are smaller than 1100 and are congruent 1 modulo 11, so I just checked them all...

Carsten Meyer - 2 years, 4 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...