Arithmetic Sequence in Sides

Geometry Level 3

Consider three regular polygons adjacent to each other. As shown below, it is possible to completely cover 36 0 360^{\circ} of space with the adjacent vertices and edges.

Is it possible to do the same for regular polygons with different numbers of sides of arithmetic progression ?

We can arrange a triangle, \(9\)-gon and \(18\)-gon in the following manner. However, their numbers of sides are not in arithmetic progression. We can arrange a triangle, 9 9 -gon and 18 18 -gon in the following manner. However, their numbers of sides are not in arithmetic progression.


Inspiration.

Not enough information. No , it is not possible. Yes, it is possible.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Aareyan Manzoor
Mar 9, 2018

consider number of sides to be ( a d , a , a + d ) (a-d,a,a+d) . then the 3 interior angle of the three polygons should add to 2 π 2\pi or: 2 π = π 2 π a d + π 2 π a + π 2 π a + d 1 = 2 a d + 2 a + 2 a + d a 3 a d 2 = 6 a 2 2 d 2 d 2 = a 3 6 a a 2 d = a 3 6 a 2 a 2 2\pi=\pi-\dfrac{2\pi}{a-d}+\pi-\dfrac{2\pi}{a}+\pi-\dfrac{2\pi}{a+d}\to 1 = \dfrac{2}{a-d}+\dfrac{2}{a}+\dfrac{2}{a+d} \\ \to a^3-a d^2 = 6a^2-2d^2 \to d^2 = \dfrac{a^3-6a}{a-2}\to d=\sqrt{\dfrac{a^3-6a^2}{a-2}} notice that d d is a positive integer so a 2 a 3 6 a 2 = a a ( a 6 ) a 2 2 2 ( 4 ) a-2|a^3-6a^2=a*a*(a-6) \to a-2| 2*2*(-4) this means a 2 = 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 , 16 a = 3 , 4 , 6 , 10 , 18 a-2=1,2,4,8,16 \to a= 3,4,6,10,18 . non of this yields a positive integer for d and hence there is no solution.

David Vreken
Mar 15, 2018

Let the number of sides be a a , a + d a + d , and a + 2 d a + 2d for each regular polygon such that a a < a + d a + d < a + 2 d a + 2d to follow an arithmetic progression. Then a 3 a \geq 3 and a a is an integer since it is the number of sides of a polygon, d d is an integer since a a is an integer and a + d a + d is the number of sides of a polygon, and a < 6 a < 6 since 3 3 regular hexagons already cover the space around the point and any more sides would cause an overlap of the polygons.

Since the 3 3 interior angles for each regular polygon must add up to 2 π 2\pi to cover the space around the point, and each interior angle for a regular polygon with n n sides is ( n 2 ) π n \frac{(n - 2)\pi}{n} , we have: ( a 2 ) π a + ( a + d 2 ) π a + d + ( a + 2 d 2 ) π a + 2 d = 2 π \frac{(a - 2)\pi}{a} + \frac{(a + d - 2)\pi}{a + d} + \frac{(a + 2d - 2)\pi}{a + 2d} = 2\pi This simplifies to: ( 4 2 a ) d 2 + ( 12 3 a 2 ) d + ( 6 a 2 a 3 ) = 0 (4 - 2a)d^2 + (12 - 3a^2)d + (6a^2 - a^3) = 0 Then according to the quadratic equation: d = 3 a 2 12 a ± a a 2 8 a + 48 8 4 a d = \frac{3a^2 - 12a \pm a\sqrt{a^2 - 8a + 48}}{8 - 4a}

Since 3 a < 6 3 \leq a < 6 and a a is an integer, a = 3 a = 3 , a = 4 a = 4 , or a = 5 a = 5 . These values give a 2 8 a + 48 a^2 - 8a + 48 values of 33 33 , 32 32 , and 33 33 respectively, and none of these numbers are perfect squares, and so none of these values give a required integer value for d d , and so the situation described in the problem is not possible.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...