Balancing Problem - More Shapes!

Algebra Level 2

In the diagram to the right, both beams are balanced.

Which of the following options will not balance any of the other options?

Note that there are 5 options (not 4).

3 triangles and 1 circle 3 circles and 2 stars 4 triangles 5 triangles 7 stars

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Chew-Seong Cheong
Apr 24, 2015

Let the masses of circle (round), star and triangle be r r , s s and t t respectively. It is given:

{ 3 s + r = 3 t 3 t = r + 3 s . . . ( 1 ) 2 t + s = 2 r 2 t = 2 r s 6 t = 6 r 3 s . . . ( 2 ) \begin{cases} 3s+r=3t & & \Rightarrow 3t = r + 3s &...(1) \\ 2t+s = 2r & \Rightarrow 2t = 2r - s & \Rightarrow 6t = 6r -3s &...(2) \end{cases}

E q . 1 + E q . 2 : 9 t = 4 r t = 7 9 r E q . 2 : 2 t = 2 r s s = 2 r 2 t = 4 9 r \begin{array}{c}\Rightarrow Eq.1+Eq.2: & 9t = 4r & \Rightarrow t = \frac{7}{9}r \\ \quad \space Eq.2: & 2t=2r-s & \Rightarrow s = 2r-2t = \frac{4}{9}r \end{array}

{ Option 1: 5 t = 5 × 7 9 r = 35 9 r Option 2: 3 r + 2 s = 3 r + 2 × 4 9 r = 35 9 r Option 3: 7 s = 7 × 4 9 r = 28 9 r Option 4: 4 t = 4 × 7 9 r = 28 9 r Option 5: 3 t + r = 3 × 7 9 r + r = 30 9 r \begin{cases} \text{Option 1: } 5t & = 5\times \frac{7}{9}r & = \frac{35}{9}r \\ \text{Option 2: } 3r+2s & = 3r + 2\times \frac{4}{9}r & = \frac{35}{9}r \\ \text{Option 3: } 7s & = 7\times \frac{4}{9}r & = \frac{28}{9}r \\ \text{Option 4: } 4t & = 4\times \frac{7}{9}r & = \frac{28}{9}r \\ \text{Option 5: } 3t+r & = 3\times \frac{7}{9}r + r & = \color{#D61F06} {\frac{30}{9}r} \end{cases}

The option that will not balance any of the others is 3 triangles and 1 circle \color{#D61F06}{\boxed{\text{3 triangles and 1 circle}}} .

Here is another good problem that you may try. https://brilliant.org/problems/who-gets-the-buck-2/ It has been qualified for level 2 algebra but the no. of solvers required is yet not met.

Shubhrajit Sadhukhan - 1 year, 1 month ago

Buddy absolutely wrong...
What question is asked which doesnt balance any of the options all four options are unbalanced and only 4 triangles option is balanced then answer should be 4 triangles

Irtaza Sheikh - 6 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

5 = 3 + 2 5\triangle = 3\circ+ 2\star and 7 = 4 7\star = 4 \triangle but 3 + 1 3\triangle + 1\circ is alone.

Chew-Seong Cheong - 6 years, 1 month ago

Note that there are actually 5 options, and I mentioned that in the question. "4 triangles" would pair up with "7 squares".

Chung Kevin - 6 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Now I got it what to do....
I was balancing each option so I got that 4 are unbalanced and one is balanced but we have to do it from all 5 options which are balancing or not .... Thanks for solution and explaination

Irtaza Sheikh - 6 years, 1 month ago
Patrick Engelmann
Apr 25, 2015

1 T = 1 1T = 1 Triangle

1 C = 1 1C = 1 Circle

1 S = 1 1S = 1 Star

We can write the following equations:

3 S + 1 C = 3 T 3S + 1C = 3T

2 T + 1 S = 2 C 2T + 1S = 2C

First, we can rewrite our first equation from above:

3 S + 1 C = 3 T 1 C = 3 T 3 S 3S + 1C = 3T \Leftrightarrow 1C = 3T - 3S

And put it into the second equation:

2 T + 1 S = 2 C 2 T + 1 S = 2 ( 3 T 3 S ) 2 T + 1 S = 6 T 6 S 2T + 1S = 2C \Leftrightarrow 2T + 1S = 2(3T - 3S) \Leftrightarrow 2T + 1S = 6T - 6S

Rewrite that again to:

2 T + 1 S = 6 T 6 S 2 T + 7 S = 6 T 7 S = 4 T 2T + 1S = 6T - 6S \Leftrightarrow 2T + 7S = 6T \Leftrightarrow \boxed{7S = 4T}

Now, we can cancel the 7 7 Stars option and the 4 4 Triangle option from our list, since there is a solution that will balance them. Because the 7 7 Stars option will be balanced by the 4 4 Triangle option and the 4 4 Triangle option will be balanced by the 7 7 Stars option.

Now, let's see if the 5 5 Triangles option can be balanced by one of the remaining options. To do so, let's rewrite our first and second equation from the beginning :

3 S + 1 C = 3 T 3 S + 1 C + 2 T = 5 T 3S + 1C = 3T \Leftrightarrow 3S + 1C + 2T = 5T

2 T + 1 S = 2 C 2 T = 2 C 1 S 2T + 1S = 2C \Leftrightarrow 2T = 2C - 1S

Now, put the second rewritten equation into the first rewritten equation to get:

3 S + 1 C + 2 T = 5 T 3 S + 1 C + ( 2 C 1 S ) = 5 T 3S + 1C + 2T = 5T \Leftrightarrow 3S + 1C + (2C - 1S) = 5T

Now, let's rewrite that again to get eventually:

3 S + 1 C + ( 2 C 1 S ) = 5 T 2 S + 3 C = 5 T 3S + 1C + (2C - 1S) = 5T \Leftrightarrow \boxed{2S + 3C = 5T}

And we see that the 5 5 Triangles option can be balanced by the 2 2 Stars and 3 3 Circles option and vice versa. And since we know that one option can't be balanced by any of the other, we know that our remaining option 3 3 Triangles and 1 1 Circles must be our desired solution, as we've showed that all other options can be balanced by at least one of the other options.

Hm, I think that trying to figure out which option balances against which becomes tedious. It is not immediately obvious how we should proceed. I feel that it is better to find a solution and then substitute these values in.

Chung Kevin - 6 years, 1 month ago

Absolutely brilliant

Zi yang Lim - 6 years, 1 month ago

I did the same thing but my final conversions were in fractions of stars

Jerry McKenzie - 4 years, 6 months ago
Terrell Bombb
Jul 15, 2016

Star(S), Circle(C), Triangle(T)
Given: 3S+C=3T
2C=2T+S

replace C with (2T+S)/2 => 3S + (2T+S)/2 = 3T ----> 7S = 4T (therefore, option 4 and 5 are out)
rewrite option1: 3C + 2S in terms of T ---> (27/7)T + (8/7)T = 5T (option 1 and 2 are out)
remaining option is the 3rd option.

Moderator note:

It helps to express the options in terms of 1 shape, so that we can directly compare them.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...