Blue Or Red?

Geometry Level 2

The red figure at the right is made of two hemispheres of equal radius. The blue cylinder at the left has the same radius and height as the red figure.

Which shape has a larger surface area?

Note : Both figures are capped on the top and bottom by circles.

Cylinder Two hemispheres Both have the same surface area Not enough information

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

7 solutions

Let h h denote the height of the blue cylinder. Note that the blue cylinder of has a height equivalent to the height of the 2 hemispheres, h = r + r = 2 r h = r + r = 2r .

Recall that the total surface area of a cylinder is equal to the sum of areas of the two base circles (one on top, one at the bottom) and the curved rectangular side. Expressing it mathematically, we have

2 ( π r 2 ) + 2 π r h = 2 π r 2 + 2 π r ( 2 r ) = 6 π r 2 ( 1 ) 2(\pi r^2) + 2\pi r h = 2 \pi r^2 + 2\pi r (2r) = 6\pi r^2 \qquad \qquad (1)

The total surface area of the two hemispheres in pink is equal to the sum of curved surface area and the sum of the two base circles (one on top, one at the bottom). And the curved surface area of each of these hemisphere is simply half the surface area of a sphere , 4 π r 2 4\pi r^2 . Expressing all of these mathematically, we have

2 ( 1 2 4 π r 2 ) + 2 ( π r 2 ) = 6 π r 2 ( 2 ) 2 \left ( \dfrac12 \cdot 4 \pi r^2 \right) + 2 ( \pi r^2) = 6 \pi r^2 \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad (2)

Since the values we've found in ( 1 ) (1) and ( 2 ) (2) are equal, then both the blue figure and the pink figure has equal surface area.

Moderator note:

Nice observation!

Thanks for sharing that the curved surface area of the sphere is equal to the curved surface area of the cylinder. This certainly doesn't seem obvious, in part because "the sphere gets smaller".

Thank you for the review. It's from Archimedes' Hat-Box theorem actually. ;)

Worranat Pakornrat - 5 years, 3 months ago

Computation of the surface area of the cylinder:

h = 2 r h=2r

A = l a t e r a l a r e a + a r e a o f t h e t w o b a s e s = ( 2 π r ) ( 2 r ) + 2 ( π r 2 ) = 4 π r 2 + 2 π r 2 = 6 π r 2 A=lateral~area+area~of~the~two~bases=(2 \pi r)(2r)+2(\pi r^2)=4 \pi r^2+2 \pi r^2=6 \pi r^2

Computation of the surface area of the two hemisphere:

A = 2 ( 2 π r 2 ) + 2 ( π r 2 ) = 4 π r 2 + 2 π r 2 = 6 π r 2 A=2(2 \pi r^2) + 2(\pi r^2)=4 \pi r^2 + 2 \pi r^2=6 \pi r^2

Conclusion: The surface areas are equal.

Nice solution.

Marvin Kalngan - 3 months ago
Robert DeLisle
Jun 3, 2018

Both have equal circular surfaces at the ends that can be disregarded.

The height is 2r, dictated by the configuration of the two hemispheres. (Same deal as the chocolate sphere in the volume quiz)

The area of the cylinder side is that of a rectangle 2r x 2πr (that is height x circumference), that is, 4 π r 2 4πr^2 as if the side were simply cut at a right angle then rolled out flat.

There are two hemispheres with the total area of one one sphere, 4 π r 2 4πr^2 (formula from Archimedes) .

Thus they are the same.

Cylinder:

assume r = 1

from the figure, h = 2r = 2(1) = 2

A = area of the two bases + lateral area = 2 pi r² + 2 pi r*h = 2pi + 4pi = 6pi

Two Hemispheres:

A = 2 x area of one hemisphere = 2(2 pi r² + pi*r²) = 2(2pi + pi) = 4pi + 2pi = 6pi

Conclusion: The two areas are equal.

Nice solution.

Marvin Kalngan - 3 months ago
Yara Akkila
May 29, 2020

the surface area is = to the area of the cross section x the height. both shapes have the same cross sectional area ( area of the the circle ) and the same height which leads to an = surface area

Cas Collany
May 6, 2020

The top surfaces are both the same shape and size and the radius is the same

Nikkil V
Feb 23, 2016

The height of blue cylinder is 2r and now calculate both of their surface areas.You will get 6πr^2 as their total surface area

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...