Build it tall

You're visiting a burgeoning architectural firm that wants to design a skyscraper that stands strong and tall above the local city skyline. One of the architects storms into the lunchroom with a grand announcement: they've built an incredible model for a floor of the building. It weighs just 0.1 kg \approx\SI{0.1}{\kilo\gram} yet it can sustain a W = 50 kg W = \SI{50}{\kilo\gram} weight before it breaks. Extrapolating from the test, they figure that a full-scale model built using the same material could reach 500 stories!

<strong>A</strong>: the scale model, <strong>B</strong>: layout of the unit floor, <strong>C</strong>: the human-scale building. A : the scale model, B : layout of the unit floor, C : the human-scale building.

This sounds suspicious, so you decide to do some quick figuring to estimate how tall their design could possibly stand under its own weight. Approximately how many stories would a human-scale version of a building with this floor plan sustain?

Details:

  • Each floor has the dimensions of a cube of side length \ell , and a fraction f = 0.7 f = 0.7 of the volume is missing to make room for occupants.
  • The architect's model floor has linear dimension 0 = 10 cm , \ell_0 = \SI{10}{\centi\meter}, and the material has a density of ρ = 340 kg / m 3 . \rho = \SI[per-mode=symbol]{340}{\kilo\gram\per\meter\cubed}.
  • The height of one story in a human-scale building is 3 m . \SI{3}{\meter}.
15 stories 60 stories 125 stories 250 stories 500 stories

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Steven Chase
May 3, 2018

The volume (and thus the weight) goes as l 3 l^3 , and the structural strength goes as l 2 l^2 . Therefore, the strength to weight ratio goes as l 1 l^{-1} . Since the human-scale building is 30 times as big, it is only 1 / 30 1/30 as strong relative to its weight. Therefore, the expected number of floors the human-scale building will support is:

N = 500 30 = 16.67 15 N = \frac{500}{30} = 16.67 \approx 15

Valid, because it was stated a fraction f=0.7 is missing, so the thickness grows proportionally. However, it is an interesting question how to increase/decrease the thickness (but using the same size and material strength) to reach optimum height?

Attila Kiss - 3 years, 1 month ago

This is really helpful

Vadarai Ingram - 3 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Glad you think so

Steven Chase - 3 years, 1 month ago

how did u understand that the human-scale building is 30 times bigger???

erica phillips - 3 years ago

Log in to reply

It says so in the "details"

Steven Chase - 3 years ago

@Steven Chase's solution is very clean! I did it the longer way because it was not clear if the model included a floor and a ceiling adjacent to each other. The B picture shows no ceiling, so this could mean that the floor of one level acts as the ceiling of another. Of course, this does not apply to the first floor or the top ceiling. One solution yields ~16 floors and the other ~20. Yes, I guess I was over thinking it, but being fairly new to Brilliant.org I find I'm not always sure what is important in the engineering questions. In any case, the choices we were given precluded having to decide what the precise model was.

Ian Leslie - 3 years ago
Michael Mendrin
May 6, 2018

The weight of each cube floor in the human scale building is, in kilograms

3 3 3 0.3 340 = 2754 3 \cdot 3 \cdot 3 \cdot 0.3 \cdot 340=2754

Scaling up one cube's ability to sustain a load in the human scale building is, in kilograms

3 0.1 3 0.1 50 = 45000 \dfrac{3}{0.1} \cdot \dfrac{3}{0.1} \cdot 50 = 45000

The ratio is is approximately 16.34 16.34 , so 15 15 stories

Wrong way to do this:

3 0.1 3 0.1 3 0.1 50 = 1350000 \dfrac{3}{0.1} \cdot \dfrac{3}{0.1} \cdot \dfrac{3}{0.1} \cdot 50 = 1350000

giving us a ratio of approximately 490.20 490.20 , or optimistically 500 500 stories

The compression strength of any material is a function of cross section area, not volume. Here, we disregard structural failure from buckling, as that does depend on the height of the tower relative to its width.

Additional comments:

The cross section area of the model cube, assuming that there is a cubical void 0.7 0.7 of the total volume, is, in square centimeters

10 10 ( 1 ( 0.7 ) 2 3 ) = 21.16 10 \cdot 10 \cdot \ (1-(0.7)^\frac{2}{3}) = 21.16 or about 3.5 3.5 square inches. If this sustains a load of 50 50 pounds, this works out to roughly 14 14 pounds per square inch. Steels commonly can safely sustain loads of 10 10 s of thousands of pounds per square inch. The strength of this model cube would be typical for cardboard boxes of about the same size. Some homes and buildings have successfully been constructed using laminated cardboard, but they are generally limited to one story.

Very nice description. Thank you.

Shepal Bhansali - 3 years, 1 month ago

I think you mistyped for the weight of the floor.

3 3 3 0.3 50 3 \cdot 3 \cdot 3 \cdot 0.3 \cdot 50 , I think the 50 should be 340 for the density. Though the weight of the floor is correct.

Yama Takimoto - 3 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

oh, thanks for that catch

Michael Mendrin - 3 years, 1 month ago
Manoah Scharff
May 7, 2018

Let W 0 W_0 be the weight the model floor can sustain, n n , the number of floors the human-scale building can sustain and W s = ( 1 f ) ρ l 3 g W_s = (1-f)\rho l^3g , the weight of a single story. Assuming the human-scale floor can sustain the same pressure as the model floor, we have: P = W 0 l 0 2 = n W s l 2 P = \frac{W_0}{l_0^2} = \frac{nW_s}{l^2} .

So, n = ( l l 0 ) 2 W 0 W s n = \left(\frac{l}{l_0}\right)^2 \frac{W_0}{W_s} .

The ratio l : l 0 l:l_0 is 30:1, the model floor can sustain 50 kg and a single story weighs 2754 kg. The equation finally results in:

n = 900 50 2754 = 16.34 15 n = 900 * \frac{50}{2754} = 16.34 \simeq 15

Daniel Hernandez
May 13, 2018

The linear dimension of the human-scale structure is 30 times bigger (3m/0.1) than that of the model, so the area of the floor is 900 ( l 2 l^2 ) times bigger and the volume 27000 ( l 3 l^3 ) times. When the structure gets bigger in area, weight and area cancel each other out since while there is ( l 1 l 0 \frac{l_1}{l_0} ) 2 ^2 times more weight there is also ( l 1 l 0 \frac{l_1}{l_0} ) 2 ^2 times more area to distribute the weight.

This doesn't happen with height, an increase in height does not come with more capacity to support the increase in weight. Therefore, when we increase the volume of the building by 3 0 3 30^3 it only matters the factor of height (30). Since each floor is 30 times taller each has to support 30 times more weight, so the structure will only support 1 / 30 1/30 of the stories compared to the model. The model can support 500 times its weight so 500/30 =16.67

Dylan Karzen
May 9, 2018

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...