Calculus - Minimizing Distance

Calculus Level 3

A power house, P, is on one bank of a straight river 200 m wide, and a factory, F, is on the opposite bank 400m downstream from P. The cable has to be taken across the river, under water at a cost of $6/m. On land the cost is $3/m. Tell the least cost with shortest angle?

NOTE: path should be chosen so that the cost is minimized

90°.$7239 0°,$3239 40°,$4239 30°,$2239.23

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

4 solutions

Jake Lai
Dec 7, 2014

It can be seen that cost y y is a function of distance q q (as denoted in the diagram).

y = 400 q + q 2 + 20 0 2 y = 400-q+\sqrt{q^2+200^{2}}

We can find the minimum of y y by taking its derivative and equating with zero:

d y d q = 1 + 2 q q 2 + 20 0 2 = 0 \frac{dy}{dq} = -1+\frac{2q}{\sqrt{q^2+200^{2}}} = 0 .

Hence, q = 200 3 3 q = \frac{200 \sqrt{3}}{3} . The value of q q obtained is a minimum as as can be seen by the second derivative test.

Let θ \theta be the angle from the power house. tan θ = 200 3 600 = 3 3 \tan \theta = \frac{200 \sqrt{3}}{600} = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{3} . Thus, θ = π / 6 \theta = \boxed{\pi/6} .

Anandhu Raj
Jan 18, 2015

Just check the options.......The least cost is $2239.23.... :p

L= 400 ; W=200 ; c1= 3; c2 =6

Cost function Q= c1 (L- W tan p) + c2*W/(cos p)

making dQ/dp = 0

c1 W/(cos p)^2- c2 W* sin p /(cos p)^2= 0

Simplifying we get sin p = c1/c2

Plugging values c1=3 and c2=6 result sin p = 1/2; p = 30

It is interesting to note that angle to be chosen only depends on the cost.

Aditya Raj
Dec 5, 2014

Let's look at the extreme cases first:

Straight across the river is 200 m @ $6/m = $1200 plus 400 m on land @ $3/m = $1200, total $2400.

If we go diagonal, then by Pythagoras, it's 200 sqrt(5) m @ $6/m = 1200 sqrt(5) ~= $2683

Let the point straight across from P be P'. Let's choose a landfall point Q, somewhere P' and F. Let distance from P' to Q be q.

So total distance is sqrt (200² + q²) (diagonal under the river) + 400 - q (on land) Cost is 6 * sqrt(40000+q²) + 3 * (400 - q) We want to minimize that. First we can divide by 3 -- same value for q will be maximum. 2 * sqrt(40000+q²) + 400 - q Derivative is 2q / sqrt(40000+q²) - 1 We set that to 0 2q / sqrt(40000+q²) = 1 2q = sqrt(40000+q²) Square: 4 q² = 40000 + q² 3 q² = 40000 q = 200/sqrt(3)

Length under water is then 400/sqrt(3) = approx 231 and length on land is 400 - 200/sqrt(3) = approx 284

Cost is 6 * 400/sqrt(3) + 3 (400 - 200/sqrt(3)) = $2239.23 The triangle P-P'-Q has sides 200 - 200/sqrt(3) - 400/sqrt(3) and therefore it is a 30-60-90 triangle. The angle QPQ' = 30°.

That solution is way too long man.

Jake Lai - 6 years, 6 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...