Calculus needed here?

Algebra Level 4

f ( x ) = 1 x 3 + x + 3 3 , x R \large f(x) =\sqrt [ 3 ]{ 1-x } +\sqrt [ 3 ]{ x+3 }, \,\,x\in \mathbb{R}

Suppose L L is the maximum value of the function f f . Find the value of 10000 L \lfloor 10000L\rfloor .


Notation : \lfloor \cdot \rfloor denotes the floor function .


The answer is 25198.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

6 solutions

Chan Lye Lee
May 2, 2017

Let a = 1 x 3 a=\sqrt [ 3 ]{ 1-x } and b = x + 3 3 b=\sqrt [ 3 ]{ x+3 } . Now a + b = y a+b=y . If each side is raised to the 3rd power, we have a 3 + b 3 + 3 a b ( a + b ) = y 3 a^3+b^3+3ab(a+b)=y^3 . Substitute a + b = y a+b=y and a 3 + b 3 = 4 a^3+b^3 = 4 to the left-hand-side, and finally obtain a b = y 3 4 3 y ab=\frac{y^3-4}{3y} .

Since a + b = y a+b=y and a b = y 3 4 3 y ab=\frac{y^3-4}{3y} , we note that a a and b b are roots to the equation u 2 y u + y 3 4 3 y = 0 u^2-yu+\frac{y^3-4}{3y}=0 . As a a and b b are real, the discriminant of the quadratic equation is non-negative, which means that y 2 4 ( y 3 4 3 y ) 0 y^2 -4\left(\frac{y^3-4}{3y}\right)\ge 0 . Now we have 0 < y 3 16 0< y^3 \le 16 . Thus L = 16 3 2.5198420 L=\sqrt [ 3 ]{ 16 } \approx 2.5198420 . So 10000 L = 25198 \lfloor 10000L\rfloor = 25198 . Note that the value L L is obtained when x = 1 x=-1 .

That was really good.But using calculus wouldn't be that messier in this case i think.Just some simple differentiation.

Md Atiq Shahriar - 4 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

You are right! Should think of some related questions in future where calculus does not help a lot. Thanks!

Chan Lye Lee - 4 years, 1 month ago

Really a great approach without involving calculus. Hats off!!

Srinivasan Sundaravaradhan - 4 years, 1 month ago

Great approach!

Vipul Shukla - 4 years, 1 month ago

This one got me good!

Elethelectric Penguin - 3 years, 10 months ago

f(x) itself does not have a finite maximum value. x=-1 is just a local max. It diverges at both ends. You can verify it with wolfram.

Xinle Yang - 4 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Nowhere in the problem do they define the range of the function, only the domain. The function enters the complex range outside of -3 <= x <= 1, and indeed neither the real parts of f nor the magnitude of f have a true finite maximum.

Ranjan Khan - 4 years, 1 month ago

How do you get that f ( x ) f(x) diverges?

The function can be written as x + 3 3 x 1 3 \sqrt[3]{x+3} - \sqrt[3] {x-1} , which is the difference of cube roots of two numbers which differ by 4. What happens to this difference as x x becomes very large?

Pranshu Gaba - 4 years, 1 month ago

You're mistaken. The domain of f ( x ) f(x) is 3 x 1 -3\leq x \leq 1 . Subsitute x = 3 x=-3 or x = 1 x=1 shows that f ( x ) f(x) is finite (and does not diverge).

Pi Han Goh - 4 years, 1 month ago

First we symmetrize the situation by defining y = x + 1 y = x+1 . Then f ( y ) = 2 y 3 + 2 + y 3 . f(y) = \sqrt[3]{2-y} + \sqrt[3]{2+y}. Calculus: d d y ( 2 ± y ) 1 / 3 = ± 1 3 ( 2 ± y ) 2 / 3 . \frac{d}{dy}(2\pm y)^{1/3} = \pm\frac 1 3(2\pm y)^{-2/3}. If therefore f ( y ) = 0 f'(y) = 0 , we must have ( 2 + y ) 2 / 3 = ( 2 y ) 2 / 3 . (2+y)^{-2/3} = (2-y)^{-2/3}. This is the case if either 2 + y = 2 y 2+y = 2-y or if 2 + y = ( 2 y ) 2+y = -(2-y) , but the latter is impossible. We conclude that y = 0 y = 0 , so that L = 2 2 3 2.51984 L = 2\sqrt[3]{2} \approx 2.51984\dots Thus we post the answer as 25198 \boxed{25198} .

Superb solution

Aditya Moger - 4 years, 1 month ago

First, one must be careful taking derivatives (i.e the chain rule).

f ( y ) = 2 y 3 + 2 + y 3 f(y) = \sqrt[3]{2-y} + \sqrt[3]{2+y}

f ( y ) = 1 3 ( 2 y ) 2 / 3 + 1 3 ( 2 + y ) 2 / 3 f'(y)=-\frac {1}{3}(2-y)^{-2/3} + \frac {1}{3}(2+y)^{-2/3}

Secondly, One must be careful to taking a square root to both sides. Thus

( 2 + y ) 2 / 3 = ( 2 y ) 2 / 3 (2+y)^{-2/3}=(2-y)^{-2/3}

2 + y = 2 y \Rightarrow 2+y=2-y [[ (2+y>0 & 2-y>0) or (2+y<0 & 2-y<0) ]]

y = 0 \Rightarrow y=0 [[-2 <y <2]]

( 2 + y ) 2 / 3 = ( 2 y ) 2 / 3 (2+y)^{-2/3}=(2-y)^{-2/3}

2 + y = y 2 \Rightarrow 2+y=y-2 [[ (2+y<0 & 2-y>0) or (2+y>0 & 2-y<0) ]]

2 = 2 \Rightarrow 2=-2 ※ [[y <-2 or y>2]]

This comes directly from

a 2 = b a = b [ [ a > 0 ] ] a^{2}=b \Rightarrow a=\sqrt{b}\enspace [[a>0]]

a 2 = b a = b [ [ a < 0 ] ] a^{2}=b \Rightarrow -a=\sqrt{b}\enspace [[a<0]]

Jerry McKenzie - 4 years, 1 month ago

@Jerry McKenzie Thanks for those details. I like to keep my solutions short, so I did not mention them. If the solution of 2 + y = 2 y 2 + y = 2 - y had some value of y y greater than 2, we should have rejected it in light of your analysis. Since I knew that y = 0 y = 0 (which is somewhat obvious once the problem is made symmetrical), I did not bother writing all that.

Arjen Vreugdenhil - 4 years, 1 month ago

Isn't it necessary to do a second derivative test to show that f(y) is maximized?

Pi Han Goh - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

Yes, or some alternative... It is not difficult to see that lim y f ( y ) = 0 , \lim_{y\to\infty} f(y) = 0, so that a positive value of L L must correspond to a maximum rather than a minimum.

Arjen Vreugdenhil - 4 years ago
Kevin Tong
May 8, 2017

To find the maximum value of the function, we first take the first derivative of the function (or the equation for the slope at each x value). d d x 1 x 3 + x + 3 3 = d d x 1 x 3 + d d x x + 3 3 = ( 1 x ) 2 3 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 3 . \frac{d}{dx} \sqrt [3]{1-x} + \sqrt [3]{x+3} = \frac{d}{dx} \sqrt[3]{1-x} + \frac{d}{dx} \sqrt[3]{x+3} = -\frac{(1-x)^\frac{-2}{3}}{3} +\frac{(x+3)^\frac{-2}{3}}{3}. In order to find the maximum point of this function, we would have to set the first derivative to 0. 0. ( 1 x ) 2 3 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 3 = 0 ( 1 x ) 2 3 3 = ( x + 3 ) 2 3 3 ( x + 3 ) 2 3 = ( 1 x ) 2 3 x + 3 = 1 x 2 x = 2 x = 1 -\frac{(1-x)^\frac{-2}{3}}{3} +\frac{(x+3)^\frac{-2}{3}}{3} = 0 \\ -\frac{(1-x)^\frac{-2}{3}}{3} = -\frac{(x+3)^\frac{-2}{3}}{3} \\ (x+3)^\frac{-2}{3} = (1-x)^\frac{-2}{3} \\ x+3 = 1-x \\ 2x = -2 \\ x = -1 Now that we have an x position, we would have to check if it is the point of maximum value, minimum value, or an inflection point. Therefore, we find the second derivative of the function (the equation for the acceleration of the function at a given point). This turns out to be 2 ( 1 x ) 5 3 9 2 ( x + 3 ) 5 3 9 -\frac{2(1-x)^\frac{-5}{3}}{9} - \frac{2(x+3)^\frac{-5}{3}}{9} We see that at x = 2 x=-2 , the second derivative is positive and at x = 0 x=0 , the second derivative is negative, therefore the maximum value of the function is at x = 1 x = -1 Computing the y value gets us 1 ( 1 ) ) 3 + ( 1 + 3 ) 3 2 3 + 2 3 2 2 3 2.5198421 \sqrt[3]{1-(-1))} + \sqrt[3]{(-1+3)} \\ \sqrt[3]{2} + \sqrt[3]{2} \\ 2 \cdot \sqrt[3]{2} \approx 2.5198421 Now we compute L = 2.5198421 10000 = 25198 L = \lfloor2.5198421 \cdot 10000\rfloor = \boxed{25198}

One must be careful to taking a square root to both sides. Thus

( x + 3 ) 2 / 3 = ( 1 x ) 2 / 3 (x+3)^{-2/3}=(1-x)^{-2/3}

x + 3 = 1 x \Rightarrow x+3=1-x [[ (x+3>0 & 1-x>0) or (x+3<0 & 1-x<0) ]]

x = 1 \Rightarrow x=-1 [[ 3 < x < 1 -3 <x <1 ]]

( x + 3 ) 2 / 3 = ( 1 x ) 2 / 3 (x+3)^{-2/3}=(1-x)^{-2/3}

x + 3 = x 1 \Rightarrow x+3=x-1 [[ (x+3>0 & 1-x>0) or (x+3<0 & 1-x<0) ]]

3 = 1 \Rightarrow 3=-1 ※ [[ x < 3 x <-3 or x > 1 x>1 ]]

This comes directly from

a 2 = b a = b [ [ a > 0 ] ] a^{2}=b \Rightarrow a=\sqrt{b}\enspace [[a>0]]

a 2 = b a = b [ [ a < 0 ] ] a^{2}=b \Rightarrow -a=\sqrt{b}\enspace [[a<0]]

Jerry McKenzie - 4 years, 1 month ago
Pi Han Goh
May 11, 2017

Relevant wiki: Power Mean Inequality (QAGH)

Disclaimer: This solution only works if we assumed the principal root of the cube root function. That is, we treat the domain of x 3 \sqrt[3]{x} to be x 0 x\geq 0 , not x R x\in \mathbb R .


Since f ( x ) f(x) is real when 1 x 0 1-x \geq 0 and x + 3 0 x+3\geq 0 , then the domain of f ( x ) f(x) is 3 x 1 -3 \leq x \leq 1 .

Let a = 1 x 3 a = \sqrt[3]{1-x} and b = x + 3 3 b = \sqrt[3]{x+3} for 3 x 1 -3 \leq x \leq 1 , then both a a and b b are non-negative numbers.

We can apply the power mean inequality ,

a 3 + b 3 2 3 a + b 2 4 2 ( f ( x ) 2 ) 3 f ( x ) 16 3 . \sqrt[3]{ \dfrac{a^3+b^3}2 } \geq \dfrac{a+b}2 \qquad \qquad \Leftrightarrow \qquad \qquad \dfrac42 \geq \left( \dfrac{f(x)}2 \right)^3 \qquad \qquad \Leftrightarrow \qquad \qquad f(x) \leq \sqrt[3]{16}.

Equality occurs when a = b x = 2 a = b \Leftrightarrow x = 2 .

Hence, L = 16 3 1 0 4 L = 25198 L = \sqrt[3]{16} \Rightarrow \lfloor 10^4 \cdot L \rfloor = \boxed{25198} .

The cube root of a negative number is real, so your domain logic is faulty. The domain, as the problem states, is the reals. Assuming your limited domain could miss the actual maximum.

Jerry Barrington - 3 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

Yes, hence my disclaimer at the beginning of my solution.

Pi Han Goh - 3 years, 10 months ago
Richard Desper
May 8, 2017

Let g ( x ) = 1 x 3 g(x) = \sqrt[3]{1-x} and h ( x ) = x + 3 3 h(x) = \sqrt[3]{x+3} . Note that f ( x ) = g ( x ) + h ( x ) f(x) = g(x) + h(x) . And since g ( 1 x ) = h ( x 3 ) , g(1-x) = h(x-3), their sum, f ( x ) f(x) , is symmetric about the line x = 1 x=-1 .

Now g ( x ) = 1 3 ( 1 x ) 2 / 3 < 0 g'(x) = \frac{-1}{3} (1-x)^{-2/3} < 0 for all x x and h ( x ) = 1 3 ( x + 3 ) 2 / 3 > 0 h'(x) = \frac{1}{3} (x+3)^{-2/3} > 0 for all x x . We only care about the sign of f = g + h f' = g' + h' , so let's ignore the (1/3) for the moment.

Note that for x < 1 x < -1 , x + 3 < 1 x \left\|x+3\right\| < \left\|1-x\right\| , thus ( x + 3 ) 2 / 3 > ( 1 x ) 2 / 3 , (x+3)^{-2/3} > (1-x)^{-2/3}, as exponentiation to a negative power is order reversing. Thus in this range, h ( x ) > g ( x ) h'(x) > -g'(x) , and g ( x ) + h ( x ) > 0 g'(x) + h'(x) > 0 . Conversely, for 1 < x , x + 3 > 1 x -1 < x , \left\|x+3\right\| > \left\|1-x\right\| , thus ( x + 3 ) 2 / 3 < ( 1 x ) 2 / 3 (x+3)^{-2/3} < (1-x)^{-2/3} , which means h ( x ) < g ( x ) h'(x) < -g'(x) , and g ( x ) + h ( x ) < 0 g'(x) + h'(x) < 0 .

Thus f ( x ) > 0 f'(x) > 0 for x < 1 x < -1 and f ( x ) < 0 f'(x) < 0 for x > 1 x> -1 , so a max occurs at f ( 1 ) f(-1) . Evaluate f ( 1 ) = 2 2 3 = 2.5198 f(-1) = 2\sqrt[3]{2} = 2.5198\ldots , so the answer sought is 25198 25198 .

The possibility has been raised that f ( x ) f(x) diverges as x x goes to infinity. This is not so. Let us consider the behavior of f ( x ) f(x) as x x grows large. First, rewrite f ( x ) = x + 3 3 x 1 3 . f(x) = \sqrt[3]{x+3} - \sqrt[3]{x-1}. By the mean value theorem applied to the function g ( y ) = y 1 / 3 , g(y) = y^{1/3}, for large values of x x , there must be a value of z ( x ) z(x) in the interval [ x 1 , x + 3 ] [x-1,x+3] such that f ( x ) = 4 g ( z ( x ) ) . f(x) = 4*g'(z(x)). Now g ( y ) = y 2 / 3 3 0 g'(y) = \frac{y^{-2/3}}{3} \rightarrow 0 as y y \rightarrow \infty . Thus f ( x ) 0 f(x) \rightarrow 0 as x x \rightarrow \infty . By symmetry, the same argument holds as x x \rightarrow -\infty

Hobart Pao
May 23, 2017

This is my first time writing an actual algebraic solution for this type of problem so please critique me!

Using sum of two cubes identity, I rewrote f ( x ) f(x) as

f ( x ) = ( 1 x 3 + x + 3 3 ) ( ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 ( 1 x ) ( x + 3 ) 3 ) ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 ( 1 x ) ( x + 3 ) 3 f(x) = \dfrac{(\sqrt[3]{1-x} + \sqrt[3]{x+3})(\sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} - \sqrt[3]{(1-x)(x+3)})}{\sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} - \sqrt[3]{(1-x)(x+3)}}

= 4 ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 ( 1 x ) ( x + 3 ) 3 = 4 ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 + ( x 1 ) ( x + 3 ) 3 = \dfrac{4}{\sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} - \sqrt[3]{(1-x)(x+3)}} = \dfrac{4}{\sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x-1)(x+3)}}

I figured that I'd have to minimize the denominator (but only considering positive denominators) in order to maximize the numerator. We only consider positive denominators because if we were to consider a negative denominator, then consider when the denominator equal 1. Then f ( x ) f(x) would equal 4 4 , which is positive, and positive numbers are greater than negative numbers always, so dividing by a negative wouldn't give us a maximum value.

Looking at the denominator, I realized that ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 \sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} must always be positive since the innards of the cube roots are squared and thus positive, so ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 0 \sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} \geqslant 0 and ( x 1 ) ( x + 3 ) 3 \sqrt[3]{(x-1)(x+3)} can be minimized if its innards are minimized and not between 0 and 1, or between -1 and 0. We know how to find the minimum of an upward opening parabola, which is its vertex, which occurs at x = 1 x = -1 . So the minimum value of ( 1 x ) 2 3 + ( x + 3 ) 2 3 + ( x 1 ) ( x + 3 ) 3 \sqrt[3]{(1-x)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x+3)^2} + \sqrt[3]{(x-1)(x+3)} should occur at x = 1 x = -1 , and the maximum of f ( x ) f(x) is f ( 1 ) = 2 2 3 f(-1) = \boxed{ 2 \sqrt[3]{2} } .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...