Check your Watch

Logic Level 4

How many times in a day do the hour and minute hands of a clock form a right angle?


The answer is 44.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Start at 0:00 (midnight); the hands of the clock make a 0 0^\circ angle. The angle between the two increases at a constant rate until they coincide again, a little after 1:05. After eleven of these cycles it is 12:00 (noon).

Thus in one day the angle between the hands turns through 2 × 11 = 22 2 \times 11 = 22 full cycles. During each cycle, there is one moment where the minute hand is 90 degrees ahead and one moment where it is 90 degrees behind the hour hand. Thus we get 44 \boxed{44} instances of perpendicular hands.

The angular speeds of the minute and hour hands are ω m = 36 0 60 = 6 / min \omega_m = \dfrac {360^\circ}{60} = 6^\circ /\text{min} and ω h = 36 0 12 × 60 = 0. 5 / min \omega_h = \dfrac {360^\circ}{12\times 60} = 0.5^\circ /\text{min} respectively.

Now, let time zero t = 0 min t = 0 \text{ min} at 03:00 H, when the hands are at right angle and the time it takes the two hands are at right angle again be t t' , Then, the hour-hand will have moved forward ω h t = 0.5 t \omega_h t' = 0.5 t'^\circ . Within t t' minutes, the minute-hand will have to move forward 0.5 t + 18 0 0.5 t'^\circ + 180^\circ . Therefore, ω m t = 6 t = 0.5 t + 180 \omega_m t' = 6 t' = 0.5 t' + 180 5.5 t = 180 \implies 5.5 t' = 180 t = 180 / 5.5 32.72727 min \implies t' = 180/5.5 \approx 32.72727 \text{min} . Thereafter, the two hands are at right angle every 32.73 minutes, and there are 24 × 60 ÷ 32.73 = 44 \lfloor 24 \times 60 \div 32.73 \rfloor = \boxed{44} times in a day.

It is I think as easy to start from 12:00 and calculate the moments in which the hands coincide. But anyway , cute solution.

A A - 4 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

No, coincidence cases are only 22. It was my first answer here and was wrong.

Chew-Seong Cheong - 4 years, 11 months ago

Ups , sorry. I meant not "coincide" but "in a right angle".

I meant it is easy to calculate this without starting from a case of right angle. The equation for calculating when starting from 12:00 the hands will be in a right angle is done easily.

Simply you have to take the speeds of the hands , they being as you observed , 6/m and 0,5m , and calcualte when the minute hand is at a distance of 90 degrees from the hour hand which therefore can be described by 6t = 0,5t+90 giving you that the first moment in the day is at t0 = 90/5,5. Next time is when the minute hand is when the minute hand made 270 degrees pass the hour hand because then the distance is again of 90 degrees between the 2 hands and this is described by the equation 6t = 0,5t +270 the next moment being therefore it can be said at t1 = 270/5,5.

Observe that only this 2 times happen in a complete revolution meaning when the distance between the hands is at 270 and when the distance is at 90 degrees. It means this happens every time the minute hand gains 270-90 = 180 degrees over 24 hours. And calculating when this happens in 24 hours with the absolute difference t0 -t1 you get the answer as it describes somehow the relations between the increase of the minute hand and the difference it gains over 24 hours over the hour hand. I think this would imply a use of calculus but I haven't studies calculus and that it can be done yet nonetheless as I said observe that by reasoning in this way it is not necessarily to start from an given so to say configuration as the calculations can be done in this more "abstract" manner anyway.

A A - 4 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

I get your point. It should work easier.

Chew-Seong Cheong - 4 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

Wonderful. It's so marvelous when someone truly understands what I say even if anyway I don't express it very well , thanks.

A A - 4 years, 11 months ago
Kai Ott
Jul 5, 2016

Consider this: Both hands coincide at time t=0, [t]=h. The minute hand will be at the same spot at t=1 and the hour hand will have moved 1 12 \frac{1}{12} of the circle, which the minute hand has to catch up. In that time the hour hand will have moved another 1 144 \frac{1}{144} and so on. This forms a geometric series i = 0 1 1 2 i \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{12^i} which is equal to 12 11 \frac{12}{11} which is the period T between two coincidences of the two hands. In a day there are 24 hours, so 24 T = 22 \frac{24}{T} =22 such coincidences. In one coincidence there are two times when the hands are perpendicular. Therefore there are 22 × 2 = 44 22 × 2 = 44 times a day when the hands are perpendicular.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...