× A D B C C B D D A
Given that A , B , C and D are distinct single digit non-negative integers satisfying the cryptogram above, find A + B + C + D .
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
You can't start out with a×d=d because there could be carries
Not true. A can't be zero and if A>1 then A D plus the carry would have to be greater than 10 if the last digit of A D+C = D
Log in to reply
your reasoning is still flawed. it's not AD+C=D, it's AD+carryfromhundreds=D. The conclusion that A=1 and D=9 is actually correct, you just arrived to it with the wrong reasoning.
Log in to reply
If there is a carry, then AD<D mod 10 which means that either A is less than 1 (can't be) or AD is multidigit. Sorry, This wasn't well explained above. I edited it.
I ran a progam that goes through all choices of A,B,C,D; there are no solutions with distinct digits between 0 and 9. Is there a typo in the question?
Log in to reply
Since 1089*9=9801 gives a valid solution, no, there's no typo. Your program doesn't work correctly.
As given here, if D = 1, A = 1 if D = 2, A = 4 if D = 3, A = 9 ... if D = 9, A = 1.
The only alternative where the answer stays in the scope of 4 digits without violating the rules of a cryptogram is A = 1, D = 9.
so 1BC9 * 9 = 9CB1.
Now, we know that 9CB1 is a multiple of 9, so 9 + C + B + 1 is divisible by 9 Maximum value of C and B is 8 and 7, so maximum value of 9 + C + B + 1 is is 25, and minimum is 10 + 0 + 3 = 13. The only number satisfying all conditions for 9 + C + B + 1 is 18
I think that solution is rather elegant; using the division rule for 9 to bypass working out the exact values of C & B. I also like how you reasoned the value for A & D. Shouldn't the minimum of 9+C+B+1=12? As 0 & 2 are the lowest unused values.
It's obvious that A is 1 and D is 9. Since except 1and0 all others on multiplication with 9 gives a number greater than 10 so a remainder is taken to the next set of numbers... B has to be 0. From this we can easily understand that C has to be 8.
AD < 10, which means that either AD = D or AD = D + 1. The only solution which satisfies this is D = 9 and A = 1.
This makes the equation (1009 + 100B + 10C)(9) = 9001 + 100C + 100B
=> 9081 + 900B + 90C = 9001 + 100C + 10B
=> 80 + 890B = 10C
=> 8 + 89B = C
The only solution for C that satisfies 0 < C < 10 is B = 0 and therefore C = 8.
The equation is therefore (1089)(9) = 9081 and the solution is 18.
A has to equal 1 since otherwise A * D would either not be a single digit integer or A would be greater than D which is not possible since A * D equals D. Therefore D has to be 9, since no other square has the unit digit 1 except 1 itself which isn't possible since then A and D would not be distinct. However, knowing that the sum of digits of any number divisible by 9 has to be divisible by 9, we can assume that D + C + B + A has to be a multiple of 9 and therefore 10 + C + B has to be a multiple of nine, which is just given in the case C + B = 8. Thus D + B + C + A = 18
A and D are so that : A < D A × D < 1 0 D 2 = A m o d ( 1 0 )
Naturally comes that A = 1 and D = 9 .
Then B is so that B × 9 < 1 0 and B = 1 . So B = 0
At last 8 + C × 9 = 0 m o d ( 1 0 ) . Then C = 8
A B C D = 1 0 8 9
We know that D*D ends with the digit A. For every value of D, A = 1 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 9.
D has to be higher than 1, as D = 0 would result in A = B = C = D = 0, and D = 1 in A = D & B = C.
Therefore, we cannot have A = 5, A = 6 or A = 9 as we would end up with a 5 digit number with the multiplication
We also know that D > A, because DCBA (which starts with the digit D) is greater than ABCD (which starts with the digit A), as D >=2. Therefore, A cannot be equal to 4, as we would at least get 4000 * 5, which is a 5 digit number.
We now know that A = 1.
D has to be equal to 9, so that 9 * 9 = 81 (the other choice being 1 * 1 = 1, which is illegal).
Then we can't have B >= 2, as 1200 * 9 is a 5 digit number, nor B = 1, as A = 1. We therefore end up with B = 0.
We now just need C, and can formulate that (only caring about the unit digit, not the tens):
D * C + 8 (from the 81) = B
=>
9 * C + 8 = 0
=>
9 * C = 2
=>
C = 8 (as 9*8 = 72).
We can verify that 1089 * 9 = 9081.
Easy to find 1089 x 9 = 9801. But a curiosity involves the double of 1089 (2178): 2178 x 4 = 8712. And this two 4-digit numbers (1089 and 2178) seems to be the unique which presents this curiosity.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
A*D=D gives A=1 as any other number either gets a bigger 1 digit number than D or a multi-digit number
Note that If there is a carry in for AD, then AD<D (mod 10) which means that either A is less than 1 (can't be for a 4 digit number) or AD is multidigit (can't be since the result has 4 digits).
D*D=1 (remainder 10) gives D=1,9 and since A=1, D=9
B*D can't have a carry out or else, the result will have more digits as this carry will be added to a 9 on the left side of the number
So B=0,1 given A=1 then B=0
C D+8(carry from 9 * 9)= 0 (remainder 10) C D->2 Given D=9 then C =8