Christmas lights

Christmas tree lights can be put together in either series or parallel. Consider 100 Christmas tree lights, each with a resistance of 1 Ω \Omega . Let circuit P be all the lights hooked up in parallel to an electrical outlet, and circuit S be all the lights hooked up in series. What is the ratio of the power used in P to the power used in S?


The answer is 10000.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

4 solutions

Discussions for this problem are now closed

Milly Choochoo
Dec 27, 2013

Well let's clear out the stuff that we already know. The total resistance for a number N N of resistors hooked up in parallel is given by...

1 Ω P = 1 Ω 1 + 1 Ω 2 + 1 Ω 3 + . . . 1 Ω N \frac{1}{\sum \Omega_{P}} = \frac{1}{\Omega_{1}} + \frac{1}{\Omega_{2}} + \frac{1}{\Omega_{3}} + ... \frac{1}{\Omega_{N}}

The total resistance for a number N N of resistors hooked up is series is given by...

Ω S = Ω 1 + Ω 2 + Ω 3 + . . . Ω N \sum \Omega_{S} = \Omega_{1} + \Omega_{2} + \Omega_{3} + ... \Omega_{N}

The power dissipated by a circuit is given by P = I 2 Ω P = I^{2}\sum\Omega , and we all know Ohm's law as V = I Ω V = I\sum\Omega with I I being the current running through the circuit, V V being the voltage drop across the circuit, and P P being the power dissipated by the circuit.

The trick to solving this is understanding that the voltage drop across both of these circuits is the same , so what we can do is get both of their dissipated power functions/formulas in terms of V V , and then divide them both. I'll show you the math.

Ω P = 1 100 Ω \sum \Omega_{P} = \frac{1}{100} \Omega

Ω S = 100 Ω \sum \Omega_{S} = 100 \Omega

P = V 2 Ω P = \frac{V^{2}}{\sum \Omega}

P P P S = V 2 Ω P V 2 Ω S = Ω S Ω P = 100 Ω 1 100 Ω = 10 , 000 Ω \frac{P_{P}}{P_{S}} = \frac{\frac{V^{2}}{\sum \Omega_{P}}}{\frac{V^{2}}{\sum \Omega_{S}}} = \frac{\sum \Omega_{S}}{\sum \Omega_{P}} = \frac{100 \Omega}{\frac{1}{100} \Omega} = \boxed{10,000 \Omega}

Dhruv Baid
Dec 24, 2013

Analysing circuit P first, we see that the P.D. across each light is the same, and is equal to the voltage of the power supply. Hence, total power is given by

100 V 2 / R 100V^2/R

In circuit S, the potential is equally divided across the 100 lights (as they have equal resistance); hence, total power is given by

( 100 ( V / 100 ) 2 ) / R (100(V/100)^2)/R

Hence,

P P / P S = 100 V 2 / ( V 2 / 100 ) = 10000 P_{P}/P_{S} = 100V^2/(V^2/100) = \boxed {10000} .

total resistance in circuit P is : R P = 1 / 100 R_{P} = 1/100 Ω

total resistance in circuit S is : R S = 100 R_{S} = 100 Ω

P P / P S = ( V 2 / R P ) / ( V 2 / R S ) = R S / R P = 100 / ( 1 / 100 ) = 10000 P_{P}/P_{S} = (V^{2}/R_{P})/(V^{2}/R_{S}) = R_{S}/R_{P} = 100 / (1/100) = 10000

Ahaan Rungta
Dec 25, 2013

Since Power = V 2 R 1 R \text {Power} = \dfrac {V^2}{R} \propto \dfrac {1}{R} , we want the ratio of the net resistance in S to the net resistance in P. The net resistance in S is 1 100 Ω 1 \cdot 100 \, \Omega and the net resistance in P is 1 100 Ω \dfrac {1}{100} \, \Omega , so our answer is 1 0 4 \boxed {10^4} .

when we use P=V^2/R we know that p is inversely proportional to r

but when we use P=I^2.R, p is proportional to r

what's gonna be wrong with this formula?

if we use P=V^2/R the answer is 10^4 but when we use P=I^2.R the answer is 10^-4

why does in this question we should use P=V^2/R?

Dina Andini Sri Hardina - 7 years, 5 months ago

we will get 10^4 as the answer even if we use P=I^2.R. the mistake committed here is that the currents(I) are not same in both the cases.

Since voltage(V) is the same in both cases we use P=V^2/R.

Ashuthosh Upadhyaya - 7 years, 5 months ago

In most of the cases the source that we consider is a voltage source and the current is purely dependant on the circuit or resistance . so both the formulas are right, thing is that, in both the cases i.e in series and parallel , the current that flows is different.

subham jyoti mishra - 7 years, 1 month ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...