Christmas Streak 57/88: 2018 CSAT (Korean SAT) #20 of Natural Sciences

Geometry Level 3

There are three non-collinear points A , B , C . \mathrm{A},~\mathrm{B},~\mathrm{C}.

For a plane α \alpha that satisfies the below conditions, define d ( α ) d(\alpha) as the smallest distance among the distances from the three points to plane α . \alpha.

(1) Plane α \alpha intersects with line segments A C \mathrm{AC} and B C . \mathrm{BC}.

(2) Plane α \alpha does not intersect with line segment A B . \mathrm{AB}.

Among all the possible options for α , \alpha, the plane that maximizes d ( α ) d(\alpha) is plane β . \beta.

Which of the followings are true?

A. Plane β \beta is perpendicular to the plane that passes through all of A , B , C . \mathrm{A},~\mathrm{B},~\mathrm{C}.

B. Plane β \beta passes through at least one of the midpoint of line segments A C \mathrm{AC} and B C . \mathrm{BC}.

C. If the three points are A ( 2 , 3 , 0 ) , B ( 0 , 1 , 0 ) , C ( 2 , 1 , 0 ) , \mathrm{A}(2,~3,~0),~\mathrm{B}(0,~1,~0),~\mathrm{C}(2,~-1,~0), then d ( β ) d(\beta) is the same as the distance between plane β \beta and point B . \mathrm{B}.


Note: This shouldn't take more than 8~10 minutes to solve in order to have enough time to finish the whole test.

This problem is a part of <Christmas Streak 2017> series .

Only B Only C and A Only A and B Only A All of them None of them Only B and C Only C

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Boi (보이)
Nov 26, 2017

Intuitive solution (the solution you should be using when taking the test)

If you want to maximize d ( α ) , d(\alpha), then α \alpha must be as distant as possible from all the three points.

This means that α \alpha is vertical to A B C \triangle \mathrm{ABC} and since α \alpha doesn't touch A B , \overline{\mathrm{AB}}, we infer that α \alpha passes through the midpoint of A C \overline{\mathrm{AC}} and B C . \overline{\mathrm{BC}}.

Therefore, all of them are true.


Formal solution (the solution you should be using when you're proving your answer to your teacher)

Let's say that α \alpha is not perpendicular to A B C . \triangle \mathrm{ABC}.

Then let l l be the line that α \alpha intersects with A B C , \triangle \mathrm{ABC}, and let γ \gamma be the plane that is perpendicular to A B C \triangle \mathrm{ABC} and contains l . l.

The distances from the three points to α \alpha are always smaller than those to l , l, (and consequently to γ \gamma ) and therefore d ( α ) < d ( γ ) . d(\alpha)<d(\gamma).

So β α , \beta\neq\alpha, and this means β \beta is not equal to any plane that is not perpendicular to A B C . \triangle \mathrm{ABC}.

Therefore β \beta is perpendicular to A B C . \triangle \mathrm{ABC}. ( A. true)

Plane γ \gamma is perpendicular to A B C , \triangle \mathrm{ABC}, and as said before, let l l be the intersection of γ \gamma and A B C . \triangle \mathrm{ABC}.

Then saying that γ \gamma is equivalent to l l on plane A B C \triangle \mathrm{ABC} does not lose generality.

Then let M \mathrm{M} be the midpoint of A B \overline{\mathrm{AB}} and let δ \delta be the plane that is perpendicular to A B C , \triangle \mathrm{ABC}, parallel to A B , \overline{\mathrm{AB}}, and contains the intersection of C M \overline{\mathrm{CM}} and l , l, and let m m be the intersection of δ \delta and A B C . \triangle \mathrm{ABC}.

Let's say that l l is not parallel to A B . \overline{\mathrm{AB}}.

Then if the distance between A \mathrm{A} and l , l, compared to the distance between B \mathrm{B} and l , l, is:

i ) i) shorter, then d ( γ ) d(\gamma) is one of the distances from A , C \mathrm{A},~\mathrm{C} to l . l. But since the distances from A , C \mathrm{A},~\mathrm{C} to m m is longer than each of those respectively, d ( γ ) < d ( δ ) . d(\gamma)<d(\delta).

i i ) ii) longer, by similar reasons, d ( γ ) < d ( δ ) . d(\gamma)<d(\delta).

Then we know that β γ , \beta\neq\gamma, and this means β \beta is not equal to any plane that is not parallel to A B . \overline{\mathrm{AB}}.

Therefore β \beta is parallel to A B , \overline{\mathrm{AB}}, and for it to be maximized, we need it to pass through the midpoint of C M , \overline{\mathrm{CM}}, and consequently, it passes through both of midpoints of A C \overline{\mathrm{AC}} and B C . \overline{\mathrm{BC}}. ( B. true)

It's trivial that the distances from A , B , C \mathrm{A},~\mathrm{B},~\mathrm{C} to β \beta are all equal, and can be proved by congruence. ( C. true)

From above, all of them are true.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...