Circle in a Semicircle

Geometry Level 1

The first diagram shows 3 circles inscribed in a semicircle. The orange line shows their centers connected together with the endpoints of the diameter of the semicircle.

If we inscribe infinitely many circles, not just 3, the resulting orange curve is part of what kind of curve?

Circle Ellipse Parabola Hyperbola None of the above

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

4 solutions

David Vreken
Mar 4, 2018

Let A A be the center of the circle that forms the semicircle, B B be any point along the resulting orange curve, C C be the point of tangency of the inscribed circle with center B B at the flat part of the semicircle, D D be the point of tangency of the inscribed circle with center B B at the curved part of the semicircle, and E E be the intersection of B C BC and the tangent line through D D , as shown below.

Since A D AD is the radius of the semicircle, and D E DE is a tangent line of the semicircle, A D D E AD \perp DE at D D ; and since B D BD is the radius of the inscribed circle with center B B , and D E DE is the tangent line of the inscribed circle, B D D E BD \perp DE at D D . Since there is only one perpendicular line that passes through a given point on a line, A A , B B , and D D must lie on the same line.

Then B C B D BC \cong BD since they are both radii of the inscribed circle with center B B , A B C E B D \angle ABC \cong \angle EBD since they are vertical angles, and A C B E D B \angle ACB \cong \angle EDB since they are both right angles formed by radii and tangent lines. Therefore, A B C E B D \triangle ABC \cong \triangle EBD by angle-side-angle congruence.

Since A B C E B D \triangle ABC \cong \triangle EBD , A B E B AB \cong EB , and since B C B D BC \cong BD and A D = A B + B D AD = AB + BD and E C = E B + B C EC = EB + BC , A D E C AD \cong EC . Since A D AD is the radius of the semicircle, it is constant for any point B B chosen along the orange curve, and so E C EC is also constant. This means that the locus of points of E E for any chosen point B B along the orange curve is the line m m , a line that is parallel to the flat part of the semicircle and perpendicular to B E BE .

Since A B E B AB \cong EB , any point B B along the orange curve is equidistant from a focus at point A A and a directrix at line m m , which is by definition a parabola .

You do not seem to prove how A,B and D are aligned. This may seem evident, but it isn't granted.

Maxence Seymat - 3 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Good point!

Since A D AD is the radius of the semicircle, and D E DE is a tangent line of the semicircle, A D D E AD \perp DE at D D .

Since B D BD is the radius of the inscribed circle with center B B , and D E DE is the tangent line of the inscribed circle, B D D E BD \perp DE at D D .

There is only one perpendicular line that passes through a given point on a line, so A A , B B , and D D must lie on the same line.

I'll edit my solution with this for completeness.

David Vreken - 3 years, 3 months ago

Nice geometric solution without algebra!

Wei Chen - 3 years, 3 months ago

Beautiful solution. I used algebra to arrive at it

Ramasamy Pullappan - 3 years, 3 months ago

I do believe the answers to the problem are wrong. Even the enunciate does not indicate the procedure how to draw infinite circles inside the semicircle, here are my arguments it looks evident that all circles must be tangent simultaneously to the horizontal line and the semicircle.

Then taken as a center point O one of the end of semicircle (c) and with a radius equal to its diameter we draw a circle which will be the inversion circle.

The horizontal line will inverse in itself and the semicircle (c) will transform in line (c’). It is also evident that any circle, inside the original semicircle, will be transform in other circle that must be tangent simultaneously to the horizontal line and the vertical line (c’). Obviously its center will be on a line which form 45 degrees with the vertical line (c’) line and that will happen with any circle tangent to the semicircle and the horizontal line, so this line it is the inverse of the line of centers.

Now applying to the line of centers obtained the inversion transform we will get a circle passing thru both ends of semicircle and the center of the inscribe circle just in the middle of the semicircle.

Unfortunally the comments does not allow me to include the picture

Mara Jares - 3 years, 3 months ago

Fantastic solution! I would have never thought that algebra was unnecessary to solve the problem.

Zain Majumder - 3 years, 3 months ago
형준 유
Feb 24, 2018

Lets call the semicircle S S and the center of the inscribed circle P ( x , y ) {P(x, y)} .

You can represent the semicircle on a Cartesian coordinate like this (Radius= R R ):

S : y = R 2 x 2 S:y=\sqrt{R^2-x^2}

Since R R is equal to O P \overline{OP} +(radius of inscribed circle),

and radius of inscribed circle is always equal to y coordinate of P P ,

next equation is valid.

x 2 + y 2 + y = R \sqrt{x^2+y^2}+y=R ( R x R ) (-R\leq x\leq R)

Rearrange it a bit, and you get this.:

x 2 + y 2 = R y \sqrt{x^2+y^2}=R-y

x 2 + y 2 = ( R y ) 2 x^2+y^2=(R-y)^2

x 2 + ̸ y 2 = ̸ y 2 2 R y + R 2 x^2+\not{y^2}=\not{y^2}-2Ry+R^2

2 R y = x 2 + R 2 2Ry=-x^2+R^2

y = 1 2 R x 2 + R 2 y=-\frac{1}{2R}x^2+\frac{R}{2}

which is a general equation of parabola.

¡Great solution! Nice problem, I used GeoGebra to confirm 😂

Diego Valenzuela - 3 years, 3 months ago

Actually, very elegant problem!

Carl Furse - 3 years, 3 months ago

As @Maxence Seymat posted in the other solution, here you use the fact that the center of the semicercle, the center of any inscrived circle and his tangential point with the semicercle are colinear on the definition for your second equation, I understand. This may seem evident but you do not seem to prove it.

Pau Cantos - 3 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

If you call these three points O, P and T respectively, then OT and PT are both perpendicular to the (common) tangent at T. Thus O, P and T are collinear.

A Former Brilliant Member - 3 years, 3 months ago

Distance from the origin O to the center point C(x,y) of any inscribed circle (r=y!): 1-y=sqrt(x2+y2) => C( x , (1-x2)/2 )

Stephan E - 3 years, 1 month ago
Brandon Monsen
Mar 6, 2018

The general expression for a conic section in polar is

r ( θ ) = a 1 + ϵ cos ( θ ) r(\theta) = \frac{a}{1+\epsilon \cos(\theta)}

Where ϵ \epsilon is the eccentricity. The type of conic section is determined exclusively by ϵ \epsilon .

Let O O be the midpoint of the diameter of the semicircle. Then for any inscribed circle C C , there is some radius of the semicircle which passes through the inscribed circle's center. Let a a be the radius of the semicircle and r r be the distance from O O to the center of C C . Let θ \theta be the angle formed by a radius of the semicircle and the perpendicular bisector of the diameter of the semicircle. Then

r + r cos ( θ ) = a r = a 1 + cos ( θ ) r+r \cos (\theta) = a \Rightarrow r = \frac{a}{1+ \cos(\theta)}

This describes a conic section of eccentricity 1 1 , which is a parabola \boxed{\text{parabola}} .

Meneghin Mauro
Mar 7, 2018

For the big semicircle let's call O its center (used as origin) and R its ray. For a chosen inscribed circle let's call C its center and and r its ray

Let's call L the horizontal line y = R y=R

d i s t a n c e ( L , C ) = R r = d i s t a n c e ( O , C ) distance(L,C)=R-r=distance(O,C)

so it's a parabola with focus in O and directrix L

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...