Circle Packing

Geometry Level 4

How many unit circles can you fit inside a circle of diameter 7 7 such that no circle overlaps any other circle? Try to prove it.


The answer is 8.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

4 solutions

Anshul Shivhare
May 30, 2014

First of all we should take the no of unittouching circles touching the big circle

So if we draw a circle with same center but rad of 2.5 cm than center of all unit circle touching the main circle would lie on it Then, No. Of unit circle < (2πr)/d Here r=2.5. , d=diameter=2 Now, 2πr/d = 7.8 Hence, no. of unit circle touching big circle = 7 Now, only one circle can be inserted between 7 circles Hence total no of circles is 8

Exactly how I estimated it.

By the way, did you put 'Try to prove it.' because you don't/didn't have a formal proof of this?

Milly Choochoo - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

Almost. I know how to prove it until the very last part, where there is some casework needed. Hint: Pigeonhole Principle.

Daniel Liu - 7 years ago
Satyen Nabar
Jul 11, 2014

Consider two small circles touching the outer circle at periphery and also touching each other. Connect the centers of these two small circles to each other and to the center of big circle. We have an isosceles triangle with 2 equal sides a and b of 2.5 and base c= 2.

We want to find out the angle C subtended between the equal sides of this isosceles triangle. By law of cosines,

c^2 = a^2 + b^2 - 2abcos C.

Solving, Cos C = 0.68. Angle C = 47 degrees aprox.

360 degrees/47 degrees = 7.659.

Thus maximum of 7 circles at periphery and of course 1 circle in the center.

Viraj Malia
May 30, 2014

There is a logical solution to this question also. Here... Area of big circle=Πr^2=Π(3.5)^2. Area of unit circle=Π. Thus no. of circles=(area of big circle)/(area of unit circle)=(3.5)^2=12.25. But this cannot be the answer because the circles can't overlap each other so a lot of space will be wasted. Thus answer is less than 12. Now looking at the given diagram and the numbers...we draw 3 unit circles in a row touching each other such that if I draw a line passing through their centres, it will be parallel to the diameter of big circle. A similar row of 3 unit circles is possible on the other side of the diameter of big circle. Thus we have drawn 6 unit circles. Now using a little visual imagination you will find that one circle can be fitted on top of the row of 3 unit circles. Similarly one more at the bottom of the lower row of unit circles. Thus we have 2 more circles. Total=6+2=8.

Are you sure that after having the 2 rows of 3 circles each, you'll have enough space to add 2 more circles? Take a look at this (roughly, it is scaled).

Parth Thakkar - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

I also thought similarly... Your drawing makes sense....

Kiranmoy Sur - 7 years ago

Draw tangents to the unit circle from the center of the big circle.
The angle these tangent will sustain =2 * ArcSin(1/2..5) = A
The number of unit circles would be = 360/A = 7.
In the center a space left is a circle dia= 3. Only one unit circle here.


Total 7 + 1 = 8.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...