Circuit with three capacitors 2

The above diagram is a circuit that consists of three capacitors A , B and C with capacitances C 0 , C_0, 2 C 0 2C_0 and 2 C 0 , 2C_0, respectively. The voltage of the power supply is constant. Let E 1 E_1 be the electric energy charged on capacitor A when the switch S is open. Let E 2 E_2 be the electric energy charged on capacitor A when the switch S is closed. Then what is the ratio E 1 : E 2 ? E_1:E_2?

E 1 : E 2 = 9 : 16 E_1:E_2=9:16 E 1 : E 2 = 3 : 4 E_1:E_2=3:4 E 1 : E 2 = 16 : 9 E_1:E_2=16:9 E 1 : E 2 = 4 : 3 E_1:E_2=4:3

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Chew-Seong Cheong
Aug 20, 2014

The relation between charge Q Q , voltage V V and capacitance C C is Q = C V Q=CV .

The energy charged on a capacitor is E = Q V = Q 2 C E=QV=\cfrac{Q^2}{C} .

When capacitors are connected in series, Q Q on each capacitor is same. When the switch S S is closed, the equivalent capacitance:

C 1 = 1 1 C 0 + 1 2 C 0 + 1 2 C 0 = 1 2 C 0 C_1=\cfrac{1}{\frac{1}{C_0}+\frac{1}{2C_0}+\frac{1}{2C_0}}= \frac{1}{2}C_0

Q 1 = C 1 V = 1 2 C 0 V E 1 = Q 1 2 C 0 = 1 4 C 0 V 2 \Rightarrow Q_1= C_1V = \cfrac{1}{2}C_0V \quad \Rightarrow E_1= \cfrac{Q_1^2}{C_0}= \cfrac{1}{4}C_0V^2

Similarly,

C 2 = 1 1 C 0 + 1 2 C 0 = 2 3 C 0 C_2=\cfrac{1}{\frac{1}{C_0}+\frac{1}{2C_0}}= \frac{2}{3}C_0

Q 2 = C 2 V = 2 3 C 0 V E 2 = Q 2 2 C 0 = 4 9 C 0 V 2 \Rightarrow Q_2= C_2V = \cfrac{2}{3}C_0V \quad \Rightarrow E_2= \cfrac{Q_2^2}{C_0}= \cfrac{4}{9}C_0V^2

Therefore, E 1 : E 2 = 1 4 : 4 9 = 9 : 16 E_1:E_2= \cfrac{1}{4} : \cfrac{4}{9} = \boxed{9:16}

Arghyanil Dey
Apr 30, 2014

When the switch is open the the net capacitance is C 2 \frac {C}{2} . So the charge in A in first case is C 2 × E \frac{C}{2}×E . So the energy stored in the capacitor is C E 2 8 \frac {CE^{2}}{8} .

In the second case when the switch is closed the net capacitance is 2 C 3 \frac {2C}{3} . So the energy stored in the capacitor is 2 C E 2 9 \frac {2CE^{2}}{9} .

So the ratio of stored energy in capacitor in two cases is 9 16 \frac {9}{16} .

Mahmoud Yehia
Apr 19, 2014

when the capacitor are in series they all accumulate the same amount of charge Q=C.V so the capacitor with less capacity will have a higher voltage drop the switch when closed cuts capacitor B out of the circuit when the switch is open the capacitor A will have 1/2 V of the power supply
when the switch is closed the capacitor A will have 2/3 V of the power supply

the energy stored E=1/2 C.V^2 E1=1/4 E E2=4/9 E so E1:E2 = 9:16

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...