Connecting heat engines

What is the smallest number of identical heat engines of efficiency η 0 = 0.3 \eta _{0}=0.3 that should be connected in series in order to get an effective efficiency η e f f > 0.8 \eta _{eff}>0.8 ?

Details and Assumptions :

  • Efficiency of a system is defined as the ratio of total work done by the system to the heat delivered to the system.
  • Connecting engines in series means that the heat rejected by one of the engines is completely transferred the one next to it, and so on.


The answer is 5.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Lets consider N identical heat engines connected in series, with heat Q d e l i v e r e d Q_{delivered} being delivered to the "first" engine. Since we know that:

η 0 = W Q d e l i v e r e d \eta _{0}=\frac{ W }{Q_{delivered}}

and:

W = Q d e l i v e r e d Q r e j e c t e d W=Q_{delivered}-Q_{rejected}

We can easily conclude that for the "first" engine:

Q r e j e c t e d = Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) Q_{rejected}=Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})

For the second engine, the heat rejected by the first one is the heat delivered, which means that for the "second" engine:

η 0 = W 2 Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) \eta _{0}=\frac{ W_{2} }{Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})}

and:

W 2 = Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) Q r e j e c t e d 2 W_{2}=Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})-Q_{rejected_2}

Q r e j e c t e d 2 = Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) η 0 Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) = Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) 2 Q_{rejected_2}=Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})-\eta_{0}Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})=Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})^2

It is now easy to conclude (or prove by induction if you wish) that for N identical heat engines, the total rejected heat will be equal to:

Q r e j e c t e d N = Q d e l i v e r e d ( 1 η 0 ) N Q_{rejected_N}=Q_{delivered}(1-\eta_{0})^N

And so, the effective efficiency of such a system will be:

η e f f = 1 Q r e j e c t e d N Q d e l i v e r e d = 1 ( 1 η 0 ) N \eta_{eff}=1-\frac{Q_{rejected_N}}{Q_{delivered}}=1-(1-\eta_{0})^N

substituting η 0 = 0.3 \eta_{0}=0.3 lets us easily get to the answer:

N = 5 N=5

WOW! You are a true beast.

Anagh Malik - 4 years, 10 months ago

Really nice solution. Makes me roll down an inclined wedge. Room

Igor Kuszczak - 4 years, 11 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...