Constant Electric Field

Consider a medium with spherically symmetric volume charge density ρ ( r ) = C r α \rho(r)= C r^{\alpha} where C and α \alpha are constants. Find the value of α \alpha that generates a constant electric field (constant in magnitude).


The answer is -1.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

7 solutions

Vitor Terra
May 20, 2014

Consider a sphere with radius R R centered on the origin of the coordinate system (i.e., the point where r = 0 r=0 ) and let that be our Gaussian surface. The electric flux at a point on the surface depends only on the enclosed electric charge and on the permissivity of the medium. Therefore, the charges at a distance greater than R R from the origin can be ignored when evaluating the electric field at a distance R R from the origin (i.e., the electric field on the sphere of radius R R ).

The charge (consider it positive) enclosed by the sphere is q = 0 R ρ ( r ) d V q = \int\limits_0^R \rho (r)dV , where d V dV is a volume element (i.e., the volume of the infinitesimal shell between the spheres of radius r r and r + d r r+dr ). It follows that d V = 4 π 3 ( r + d r ) 3 4 π 3 r 3 dV = \frac {4\pi}{3}(r+dr)^3 -\frac {4\pi}{3}r^3 . Neglecting the terms in ( d r ) 2 dr)^2 and ( d r ) 3 (dr)^3 , the result is d V = 4 π r 2 d r dV = 4\pi r^2dr . Now it's possible to find the value of the enclosed charge:

q = 0 R C r α 4 π r 2 d r = 4 π C 0 R r 2 + α d r = 4 π C r 3 + α 3 + α 0 R = 4 π C R 3 + α 3 + α q = \int\limits_0^R Cr^{\alpha}4\pi r^2dr = 4\pi C\int\limits_0^Rr^{2+\alpha}dr = \left. 4\pi C \frac {r^{3+\alpha}}{3+\alpha} \right|_0^R = 4\pi C \frac {R^{3+\alpha}}{3+\alpha} (this is an alternative to computing a triple integral)

Gauss's Law states that:

E d S = 4 π C ϵ 0 R 3 + α ( 3 + α ) \oint \overrightarrow{E}\cdot d\overrightarrow{S} = \frac{4\pi C}{\epsilon_{0}} \frac {R^{3+\alpha}}{(3+\alpha)}

Because of the spherical symmetry, the electric field is constant on all points of the Gaussian surface. Also, since E \overrightarrow{E} and d S d\overrightarrow{S} are parallel on all points of the sphere (both are radially outward), E d S = E S = E 4 π R 2 \oint \overrightarrow{E}\cdot d\overrightarrow{S} = ES = E4\pi R^2 , which implies:

E = C ϵ 0 R 1 + α ( 3 + α ) E = \frac{C}{\epsilon_{0}} \frac {R^{1+\alpha}}{(3+\alpha)}

If the electric field is constant in magnitude, its value must be the same at every point in space, all of which correspond to a value of R R . Since C C and ϵ 0 \epsilon_{0} are constant, the expression of the electric field cannot have a term in R R . In other words, the exponent of R R must be zero. That leads to 1 + α = 0 α = 1 1+\alpha=0 \rightarrow \alpha= -1 and E = C 2 ϵ 0 E = \frac{C}{2\epsilon_{0}}

Solutions are in general wonderful this week. Here's another example.

David Mattingly Staff - 7 years ago
Beakal Tiliksew
Apr 26, 2014

Q T o t = ρ v = ( C r α ) 4 3 π r 3 { Q }_{ Tot }=\rho *v=(C{ r }^{ \alpha })\frac { 4 }{ 3 } \pi { r }^{ 3 }

Since we want the electric field to be constant We take it out of the integral

E d A = C r α e 4 3 π r 3 E = 1 3 C r α e π r E = 1 3 e C π ( r α + 1 ) α = 1 E\oint { dA= } \frac { C{ r }^{ \alpha } }{ e } \frac { 4 }{ 3 } \pi { r }^{ 3 }\\ E=\frac { 1 }{ 3 } \frac { C{ r }^{ \alpha } }{ e } \pi { r }\\ E=\frac { 1 }{ 3e } C\pi ({ r }^{ \alpha +1 })\quad \Longrightarrow \alpha =-1

But, shouldn't an elemental volume be considered for finding or the charge?

Praveen Jaladanki - 6 years, 8 months ago
Daniel Fajardo
May 20, 2014

E=Q/Eo dQ=spheric surface * dR * density of charge(depending of radius) so I want the electric field to be constant in the space, so dE/dR = 0 Solving this you get the answer.

electric field is directly propotional to current density* radius(By dimensional analysis) so C.D must be proptional to 1/r to make E constant

Raymond Lin
Jul 16, 2014

By Gauss' Law, S E d A = q e n c ε 0 \oint_S E \cdot dA = \frac{q_{enc}}{\varepsilon _0 } .

In the case of a spherically symmetric distribution, we have E ( 4 π r 2 ) = 4 3 π r 3 ρ ( r ) ε 0 E(4\pi r^2)=\frac{\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3 \rho(r)}{\varepsilon_0} , which yields E = 1 3 r ( C r α ) ε 0 E=\frac{\frac{1}{3} r (Cr^{\alpha}) }{\varepsilon_0} .

In order for E E to be constant in magnitude, α = -1 \alpha = \fbox{-1} .

David Mattingly Staff
May 13, 2014

Let us consider a spherical Gaussian surface of radius R. Applying Gauss Law yields Φ = 4 π R 2 E ( R ) = Q ( R ) ϵ 0 \Phi=4\pi R^{2} E(R)= \frac{Q(R)}{\epsilon_{0}} where Q ( R ) Q(R) is the charge enclosed by surface. This charge can be computed as follows: Q ( R ) = ρ ( r ) d V = 4 π 0 R r 2 ρ ( r ) d r = 4 π C R α + 3 α + 3 . Q(R)=\int \rho(r) dV = 4\pi \int_{0}^{R} r^{2} \rho(r) dr= 4\pi C \frac{R^{\alpha+3}}{\alpha+3}. Comparing the above equation we find that for α = 1 \alpha=-1 the electric field is constant and it is given by E ( r ) = C 2 ϵ 0 . E(r)=\frac{C}{2\epsilon_{0}}. The conclusion is that a charge density of the form ρ ( r ) 1 r \rho(r) \sim \frac{1}{r} generates a spherically symmetic field of constant magnitude.

Arjen Vreugdenhil
Apr 30, 2016

Gauss' law in differential form is E = ρ ε 0 . \vec\nabla \cdot\vec E = \frac \rho {\varepsilon_0}. Because of symmetry, E \vec E is radial: E = E r r ^ \vec E = E_r\:\hat r . Using spherical coordinates, 1 r 2 d d r ( r 2 E r ) = ρ ε 0 . \frac 1{r^2}\ \frac{d}{dr}(r^2E_r) = \frac \rho{\varepsilon_0}. If E r E_r is constant, this reduces to 2 E r r r 2 = ρ ε 0 ρ = 2 ε 0 E r r , \frac {2E_r r}{r^2} = \frac \rho{\varepsilon_0}\ \ \ \therefore\ \ \ \rho = \frac{2\varepsilon_0 E_r}r, from which it is clear that C = 2 ε 0 E r C = 2\varepsilon_0 E_r and α = 1 \alpha = \boxed{-1} .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...