Cool Trig Equation

Geometry Level 2

Given that

cos ( A ) 4 sin ( A ) = 1 , \cos(A)-4\sin(A)=1,

what are the possible values of

sin ( A ) + 4 cos ( A ) ? \sin(A) + 4\cos(A)?

0 +1, -1 +2, -2 +4, -4

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

10 solutions

Here a different way to look at the problem that has the advantage of being extremely easy. Add 4 sin ( A ) \displaystyle 4\sin(A) to both sides and you get cos ( A ) = 1 + 4 sin ( A ) . \cos(A)=1+4\sin(A). Since 1 cos A 1 A R -1\leqslant\cos A\leqslant 1\;\forall A\in\Bbb R one of the ways this could be possible is if sin A = 0 A = 0 or A = π \sin A=0\implies A=0 \text{ or }A=\pi . Plug in those values in sin ( A ) + 4 cos ( A ) \sin(A)+4\cos(A) gives us the answer: 4 and -4.

If A = π A = \pi the first equation doesn't work; cos π = 1 \cos \pi = -1 is distinct to 1 + 4 sin π = 1 1 + 4\sin \pi = 1

Guillermo Templado - 5 years, 4 months ago

How do we get -4 if A= pi doesn’t work?

Adolphout H - 10 months, 2 weeks ago
Ahmed Essam
Jun 6, 2014

let t = t a n ( A 2 ) t = tan( \frac{A}{2} )

then s i n ( A ) = 2 t 1 + t 2 sin(A) = \frac{2t}{1+t^{2}} and c o s ( A ) = 1 t 2 1 + t 2 cos(A) = \frac{1-t^{2}}{1+t^{2}}

c o s ( A ) 4 s i n ( A ) = 1 cos(A) - 4 sin(A) = 1 .. we subtract two sides by 1

c o s ( A ) 4 s i n ( A ) 1 = 0 cos(A) - 4 sin(A) - 1 = 0

1 t 2 1 + t 2 4 2 t 1 + t 2 1 + t 2 1 + t 2 = 0 \frac{1-t^{2}}{1+t^{2}} -4\frac{2t}{1+t^{2}} - \frac{1+t^{2}}{1+t^{2}} = 0

Bring them together and they will be equal to

2 t 2 + 8 t 1 t 2 = 0 \frac{2t^{2} + 8t } { -1-t^2} = 0 .. and we multiply both sides by 1 t 2 -1-t^2

2 t 2 + 8 t = 0 2t^2 + 8t = 0 .. and we take 2 t 2t common factor

2 t ( t + 4 ) = 0 2t(t+4) = 0

so there is two solution t = 0 t=0 ... and t = 4 t=-4

when t = 0 t = 0 .. A = 0 A=0 .. and .. s i n ( A ) + 4 c o s ( A ) = 4 sin(A)+4cos(A) = 4

when t = 4 t = -4 .. A = 208.0724869 A=208.0724869 .. and ... s i n ( A ) + 4 c o s ( A ) = 4 sin(A)+4cos(A) = -4

please tell me my mistake cosA - 4sinA=1...(i) and let sinA +4cosA=x ....(ii) and multiply eq (ii) by 4. and add it with eq (i) we get 17cosA=4x+1 and cosA=(1+4x)/17 hence -1<cosA<1 so -1<(1+4x)/17<1 and we get -18<4x<16 so -9/2<x<4

varun singhal - 6 years, 11 months ago

What if i differentiate ???

Mayank Chouhan - 6 years, 12 months ago

Log in to reply

Differentiation is only defined for functions, not equations!

Prasun Biswas - 6 years, 5 months ago
Saurabh Panda
Jun 6, 2014

\sin{A}+ 4 \cos{A}= x.

Square both equations and add. Use (sine)^{2} + (cos)^{2} = 1 Get ans.

Can't we differentiate cosA-4sinA=1 with respect to A. ??

shail patel - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

I did the same.. 😥 May be we didn't consider that it's not a free function. Actually correct logic is, Function is defined as, f ( θ \theta ) = c o s θ cos\theta - 4 s i n θ sin\theta Then given condition is, f (A) = c o s A cosA - 4 s i n A sinA = 1 Now, f' ( θ \theta ) = - s i n θ sin\theta - 4* c o s θ cos\theta So find f' (A) by putting the value of A found out from the 1 st eq. Thus ultimately we have to find A by trigonometry only.

Shreejit Jadhav - 7 years ago

This is an equation, and not an identity.

If you know that x 2 = 10 x^2 = 10 , can you differentiate both sides and say that 2 x = 0 2x = 0 ?

Calvin Lin Staff - 6 years, 9 months ago
Sujoy Roy
Jun 30, 2014

( s i n A + 4 c o s A ) 2 + ( c o s A 4 s i n A ) 2 = 1 + 16 (sinA+4cosA)^2+(cosA-4sinA)^2=1+16 or, ( s i n A + 4 c o s A ) 2 = 16 (sinA+4cosA)^2 = 16 or, ( s i n A + 4 c o s A ) = 4 , 4 (sinA+4cosA) = 4, -4

Ronak Agarwal
Jun 28, 2014

why everyone is complicating the problem just take s i n ( A ) + 4 c o s ( A ) = x sin(A)+4cos(A)=x and now notice that x 2 + 1 = ( s i n ( A ) + 4 c o s ( A ) ) 2 + ( c o s ( A ) 4 s i n ( A ) ) 2 = ( s i n 2 ( A ) + 16 c o s 2 ( A ) + 8 s i n ( A ) c o s ( A ) ) + ( c o s 2 ( A ) + 16 s i n 2 ( A ) 8 s i n ( A ) c o s ( A ) ) = ( s i n 2 ( A ) + c o s 2 ( A ) ) + 16 ( s i n 2 ( A ) + c o s 2 ( A ) ) = 17 { x }^{ 2 }+1={ (sin(A)+4cos(A)) }^{ 2 }+{ (cos(A)-4sin(A)) }^{ 2 }\\ \quad \quad \quad \quad ={ (sin }^{ 2 }(A)+16{ cos }^{ 2 }(A)+8sin(A)cos(A))+({ cos }^{ 2 }(A)+16{ sin }^{ 2 }(A)-8sin(A)cos(A))\\ \quad \quad \quad \quad =({ sin }^{ 2 }(A)+{ cos }^{ 2 }(A))+16({ sin }^{ 2 }(A)+{ cos }^{ 2 }(A))\\ \quad \quad \quad \quad =17\quad and we are done.

Tom Capizzi
Jun 16, 2016

Some of these "solutions" don't actually work. Others assume the correct answer because it contains the one trivial solution. Others which actually generate two correct answers are inordinately complicated. Here is mine.

Given cos(A) - 4 sin(A) = 1, rearrange the terms to cos(A) - 1 = 4 sin(A).

Then square both sides of the equation, cos(A)^2 - 2 cos(A) + 1 = 16 sin(A)^2 = 16 (1 - cos(A)^2).

Collect terms, 17 cos(A)^2 - 2 cos(A) - 15 = 0.

This is a simple quadratic in cos(A), and the 2 roots are [-(-2) +/- ((-2)^2 - 4 (17) (-15))^(1/2)] / 2 (17).

After the arithmetic, cos(A) = (2 +/- 32) / 34 = {1, -15/17}.

Checking our work, the first root is the trivial solution, A = 0, cos(A) = 1 and sin(A) = 0, and result is 4.

The second root is slightly more complicated. First, we observe that A is an acute angle of an 8, 15, 17 right triangle, and |sin(A)| = 8/17. If cos(A) is negative, to satisfy the given equation, sin(A) cannot be positive.

Plugging this data back into the second equation yields (-8/17) + 4 (-15/17) = -68/17 = -4.

Hence, the solution set is {4, -4}.

Nisarg Shah
Jun 9, 2014

abvious set of sol-cosA,sinA=(1,0)or (0,-1)now (1,0) fits for A=0deg but (0,-1) has no suc h solution set so A=0 hence ans 4 ,-4 achieved

Christian Brown
May 29, 2016

I did this in a somewhat different way, as well, but it worked, so here goes:

cos(A) – 4sin(A) = 1

Since cos^2(A) + sin^2(A) = 1, then

cos(A) – 4sin(A) = cos^2(A) + sin^2(A)

cos(A) – 4sin(A) = cos(A)cos(A) + sin(A)sin(A)

Looking at the coefficients, we can see that

cos(A) = 1

sin(A) = - 4

We can rule out the second option, since sin(A) must be within -1 and 1, then

A = πn

sin(A) + 4cos(A) = ± 4

Moderator note:

Unfortunately, this approach doesn't work. We can only compare coefficients if the variables are independent. However, since cos A , sin A \cos A, \sin A are not independent, we cannot just compare the variables. For example, since 1 1 and 1 2 \frac{1}{2} are not independent, looking at A × 1 + B × 1 2 = 3 × 1 + 2 × 1 2 A \times 1 + B \times \frac{1}{2} = 3 \times 1 + 2 \times \frac{1}{2} does not imply that we must have A = 3 , B = 2 A = 3, B = 2 .

Rezwan Arefin
Apr 8, 2016

c o s θ 4 s i n θ = 1 cos \theta - 4 sin\theta = 1 c o s 2 θ + s i n 2 θ 8 s i n θ c o s θ + 15 s i n θ = 1 \implies cos^2 \theta + sin^2 \theta - 8sin\theta cos \theta + 15 sin\theta = 1 s i n θ ( 15 s i n θ 8 c o s θ ) = 0 \implies sin\theta (15sin\theta - 8cos\theta) = 0 s i n θ = 0 \implies sin\theta = 0 θ = 0 \implies \theta = 0^{\circ} s i n θ + 4 c o s θ = 0 + 4 1 = 4 \implies sin\theta + 4 cos\theta = 0 + 4*1 = 4

Only the options contains + 4 +4 is ( + 4 , 4 ) (+4, -4) . So, the answer is ( + 4 , 4 ) (+4, -4)

V H
Dec 7, 2014

1.Square first eqn. \newline 2.Expand sin^2 and cos^2 using the formula (cos(A))^2=1-(sin(A))^2 \newline 3.You will get an expression which nothing but square of second eqn.\newline \cos{A}^{2} + 16\sin{A}^{2} - 8\cos{A} \sin{A} = 1 \newline 1 - \sin{A}^{2} + 16 - 16\cos{A}^{2} - 8\cos{A} \sin{A} = 1 \newline -[\sin{A}^{2} + 16\cos{A}^{2} + 8\cos{A} \sin{A} ] = -16 \newline or (\sin{A} + 4\cos{A})^2 = 16 \newline \therefore \sin{A} + 4\cos{A} = 4 or -4

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...