Cosmic dust

A spherical comet of mass M = 1 0 14 kg M=10^{14}~\text{kg} and diameter is D = 8 km D=8~\text{km} , travelling at v 0 = 100 km/s v_{0}=100~\text{km/s} enters a cloud of stationary cosmic meteoroids (small rocks). The average density of the cloud is ρ = 1 kg / m 3 \rho= 1~\text{kg}/\text{m}^3 . When a meteoroid impacts the comet it adheres to its surface. As a result the comet slows down and after traveling L = 500 km L=500~\text{km} it exits the cloud. How much time in seconds does the comet spend in the cloud?


The answer is 5.628.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Josh Silverman Staff
Dec 8, 2013

Consider the diagram below:

img img

as the comet moves through the cloud, it presents a normal area, π r 2 \pi r^2 , to the meteoroids and each area element on its surface, d A dA , accumulates meteoroid matter in vertical stacks. By this mechanism, the comet grows in such a way that its two ends maintain their spherical character while the middle becomes a cylinder of height L L with diameter equal to the diameter of the original sphere. The rate of matter accumulation is therefore given by the normal area times the velocity times the density of the accumulating meteoroid matter ( m ˙ = ρ π r 2 v \dot{m} = \rho\pi r^2 v ).

By the end of the trip through the cloud, each normal area element d A dA on the surface will pick up the mass ρ L d A \rho L dA , and therefore the comet will have picked up the new mass ρ π r 2 L \rho\pi r^2 L .

The important idea here is that the comet maintains its original momentum throughout its transit of the cloud. Mathematically, we have:

0 = p ˙ = m ˙ v + m v ˙ v ˙ = m ˙ m v \displaystyle 0 =\dot{p} = \dot{m}v + m\dot{v} \rightarrow \dot{v} = -\frac{\dot{m}}{m}v

Employing the rate of matter accumulation we found above, this becomes:

v ˙ = ρ π r 2 v 2 m \displaystyle \dot{v} = -\rho\pi r^2 \frac{v^2}{m}

Multiplying the top and bottom by v v , we find

v ˙ = ρ π r 2 v 3 p \displaystyle \dot{v} = -\rho\pi r^2 \frac{v^3}{p}

As the momentum, p p , is conserved throughout the process, it is a constant, p 0 = M v 0 p_0 = Mv_0 , in the above relation. We therefore have a simple equation governing the velocity of the comet. Solving, we have:

v ( t ) = v 0 1 + 2 π ρ r 2 t v 0 M \displaystyle v(t) = \frac{v_0}{\displaystyle\sqrt{1+\frac{2 \pi \rho r^2 t v_0}{M}}}

The final velocity of the comet can be found by the conservation of momentum:

M v 0 = ( M + ρ π r 2 L ) v f v f = v 0 1 + ρ π r 2 L M \displaystyle \begin{aligned} M v_0 &= \left(M + \rho\pi r^2 L\right)v_f \\ v_f &= \frac{v_0}{\displaystyle 1 + \frac{\rho\pi r^2 L }{M}} \end{aligned}

We can now solve for the time t t^* at which the comet reaches its final velocity (when it exits the cloud). We find:

t = L π L ρ r 2 + 2 M 2 M v 0 \displaystyle \boxed{t^* =\displaystyle L\frac{\pi L \rho r^2+2 M}{2 M v_0}}

To summarize, the comet velocity goes as

img img

This is really admirable. +1 :)

jatin yadav - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

It's an honor to serve you, my lord.

Josh Silverman Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago

wow its so mind-blowing bro !

my mind is blown watching it

Soham Zemse - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

I can't believe I was able to give you that kind of an experience. I don't know what to say.

Josh Silverman Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago

that was incredible, great work lol

Jord W - 7 years, 6 months ago

Beautiful! .

Pinku Deb Nath - 7 years, 6 months ago
Benson Li
Dec 8, 2013

There are no external forces, so linear momentum is conserved. Furthermore, The comet experiences inelastic collisions with each particle in the cloud because we are given that each particle sticks onto the comet.

Let M M equal the mass of the comet and v f v_{f} be the velocity at some time after the comet enters the gas cloud. Also, let m m be the mass gained by the comet at some time. Writing our momentum equation, we get M × v o = ( M + m ) × v f M \times v_{o} = (M+m) \times v_{f} . Solving for v f v_{f} , we get

v f = M × v o ( M + m ) v_{f}=\frac{M \times v_{o}}{(M+m)} ( 1 ) (1)

Lets also imagine what happens when the comet plows through the gas cloud. It will leave in its wake a cylinder with formula V = ρ A x V=\rho A x , where A = π D 2 4 A= \pi \frac{D^{2}}{4} is the circle with the comet's radius.

Because m = ρ V = ρ A x m=\rho V =\rho A x , we see that the comet gains mass linearly with distance. Plugging this into ( 1 ) (1) , we get that v f = M × v o ( M + ρ A x ) v_{f}=\frac{M \times v_{o}}{(M+\rho A x )} . We see that this is a differential equation by setting v f = M × v o ( M + ρ A x ) = d x d t v_{f}=\frac{M \times v{o}}{(M+\rho A x )}=\frac{\mathrm{dx} }{\mathrm{d} t} . Integrating, 0 t f ( M × v o ) d t = 0 x f ( M + ρ A x ) d x \int_{0}^{t_{f}} (M \times v_{o} )dt= \int_{0}^{x_{f}} (M+\rho A x )dx , with x f = 500 k m x_{f}=500km and plugging in the other given constants, we get t f = 5.628 t_{f}=5.628

slick

Josh Silverman Staff - 7 years, 6 months ago

my bad, the V = ρ A x V= \rho A x should be V = A x V=A x

Benson Li - 7 years, 6 months ago

I like this solution! It is quite easy to understand! :) +1 from me.

Rohan Rao - 7 years, 6 months ago

Very clear, crisp and neat...liked it a lot...thank you!

Sathish Kumar - 7 years, 5 months ago
Cody Johnson
Dec 10, 2013

By the drag equation, we know that d v d t = k v 2 \frac{dv}{dt}=kv^2 , where k = ρ C D A 2 m k=-\frac{\rho C_DA}{2m} . Integrating, we get 1 v 0 1 v = k t v = d x d t = v 0 1 v 0 k t \frac{1}{v_0}-\frac{1}{v}=kt\implies v=\frac{dx}{dt}=\frac{v_0}{1-v_0kt} . Integrating again, we get x = 1 k ln ( 1 v 0 k t ) t = 1 e k x v 0 k x=-\frac{1}{k}\ln(1-v_0kt)\implies t=\frac{1-e^{-kx}}{v_0k} . Plugging in our values, we get k = ( 1 0 9 ) ( 0.47 ) ( 4 π ( 8 / 2 ) 2 ) 2 ( 1 0 14 ) = 4.725 × 1 0 4 k=-\frac{(10^9)(0.47)(4\pi(8/2)^2)}{2(10^{14})}=-4.725\times10^{-4} , and so t = 1 e 4.725 × 1 0 4 ( 500 ) 100 ( 4.725 × 1 0 4 ) = 5.64 s t=\frac{1-e^{4.725\times10^{-4}(500)}}{100(-4.725\times10^{-4})}=\boxed{5.64\text{s}}

Hi Cody Could you explain why you used the drag equation? For all we knew the resistive force might have been just F α v F \alpha\ v .

Siddharth Iyer - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

Hi, sid, if you are talking abt. F = 6 π η R v F = 6 \pi \eta Rv , then that is viscous force , not the drag force.

jatin yadav - 7 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

Hi Jatin! My point is, can we say that the comet follows the drag equation by observation of question? If we conserve momentum at any instant of time, write the instantaneous velocity as time derivative of distance travelled and differentiate we can see that the comet follows the drag equation. But is there any other method?

Siddharth Iyer - 7 years, 6 months ago
Akash Yadav
Jun 23, 2017

In this question we have to ignore the gravitational field due to the comic dust. Otherwise we cannot conserve linear momentum

Steven Liang
Dec 12, 2013

This problem involves use of conservation of linear momentum, kinetics and geometry. With initial mass and velocity given, we must find the final mass to find out the final velocity. So:

Cross Sectional Area of comet = (pie)x(radius)^2 = (pie)x(4km)^2 = 16(pie) km^2 --> Be careful with units!! Volume of cloud = (pie)x(L)x(R^2) = 16(pie)x500 km^3 = 8000(pie) km^3 Mass gained by comet = density x volume of cloud = 10^9 x 8000(pie) kg = 8x10^12 x (pie) kg Final Mass= (10^14 + 8x10^12xpie) kg According to conservation of linear momentum, pi = pf, so

mi x vi = mf x vf (plug in the values!!)

10^16 = Vf x (10^14 + 8x10^12 x pie) Vf= 79.92 km/s

Using the kinetics formula, S=0.5x(u+v)t,

500=0.5(100+80)t, and t comes out to be 5.5555 (please note that the slight discrepancy with official answer results as rounded-off values)

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...