There are N rational numbers R such that
3 5 × 1 0 8 + R + 3 5 × 1 0 8 − R
is an integer. What are the last three digits of N ?
Details and assumptions
You may use the fact that 0 . 7 9 3 7 < 3 0 . 5 < 0 . 7 9 3 7 0 1
We choose the real value of the roots (where applicable).
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Excellent solution!
This expression is the solution of a monic cubic equation, with a rational constant, and no x 2 term (depressed cubic). Thus the coefficient for x is rational, which implies that R is rational. See Scipione for more details.
Log in to reply
You still need to establish that distinct K correspond to distinct R , whether you make the connection between K and R by hand or by Scipione.
Mark H., please see my solution. I think the calculation is easier.
We rely on our traditional method of finding roots of surds.
Let ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) + R = ( a + b ) 3 . Expanding RHS, & equating rational & irrational coefficients, we get:
a 3 + 3 a b = ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) ⇒ b = 3 a ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) − a 3 .
Also, R = ( 3 a 2 + b ) b ⇒ R = ( 3 a 2 + b ) 2 ( b ) = 2 7 a 3 ( ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) + 8 a 3 ) 2 ( ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) − a 3 ) . [on substituting for b ]
Clearly a must be positive, for R to be positive. Also, a 3 < ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) ⇒ a < 3 . 5 × 1 0 3 < 7 9 3 . 7 0 1 . For each value of a , we get a rational R .
The expression in the question evaluates to 2 a . Thus for 2 a to be integral, either a is integral, or is rational with denominator 2 .
Case 1: a ∈ N . Then a can be any of 1 , 2 , . . . , 7 9 3 giving 7 9 3 choices.
Case 2: a = 2 p (where p is odd) Then p < 2 × 7 9 3 . 7 0 1 = 1 5 8 7 . 4 0 2 ⇒ 1 ≤ p ≤ 1 5 8 7 . There are 7 9 4 odd numbers from 1 to 1 5 8 7 (inclusive) & p can be any of them.
Thus, there can be 7 9 3 + 7 9 4 = 1 5 8 7 values of a ,& correspondingly that many values for R .
You have assumed that the cube root of 5 × 1 0 8 + R can be written in the particularly neat form a + b with 2 a integral and b rational, and found solutions for R provided that 1 ≤ a ≤ ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) 3 1 .
How can you be sure that you have not missed out some values of R for which the cube root cannot be written that way? It is a nontrivial assumption - the number 1 + 2 is not equal to a + b 2 for any rational a , b .
The fact that the sum of the cube roots of 5 × 1 0 8 + R and 5 × 1 0 8 − R is an integer forces your assumption to be valid, but this needs to be proven.
Log in to reply
Right. Since sum of the cube roots given is integral, a is always rational. What about b ? Either ways b is always rational I guess,even in your quoted example ?
Log in to reply
1 + 2 = a + b c for any rational a , b , c .
Hi Paramjit S.
I see there already a sub-thread about whether you will always have an appropriate a , b rational. But I'd like to also point out that "equating rational & irrational coefficients" wouldn't work in the special case where R is the square of a rational.
1 obvious thing: if ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) + R = ( a + b ) 3 then ( 5 × 1 0 8 ) − R = ( a − b ) 3 . This is the benefit of surds. :) Mark H. has very aptly shown, using derivatives, that distinct a give distinct R . This might be included for a better proof.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Assume that R ≥ 0 , so that R is real. Write L = 5 × 1 0 8 , and suppose that K = ( L + R ) 3 1 + ( L − R ) 3 1 is an integer. It is clear that K ≥ 0 . Then K 3 = = L + R + 3 K ( L 2 − R ) 3 1 + L − R 2 L + 3 K ( L 2 − R ) 3 1 and hence ( K 3 − 2 L ) 3 = 2 7 K 3 ( L 2 − R ) It is clear from this equation that K = 0 , so K ≥ 1 . Then the requirement that R ≥ 0 tells us that ( K 3 − 2 L ) 3 K 3 − 2 L K 3 − 3 L 3 2 K − 2 L ( K + L 3 1 ) 2 ( K − 2 L 3 1 ) ≤ ≤ ≤ ≤ 2 7 K 3 L 2 3 L 3 2 K 0 0 so we deduce that 1 ≤ K ≤ 2 L 3 1 .
Now R = L 2 − ( 3 K K 3 − 2 L ) 3 and hence d K d R = − 3 ( 3 K K 3 − 2 L ) 2 ( 3 2 K + 3 K 2 2 L ) < 0 for all K > 0 . Thus we obtain a different rational value of R for every different positive integer value of K . Thus we deduce that there are ⌊ 2 L 3 1 ⌋ possible different values of R . For our value of L , this means that there are 1 5 8 7 possible different values of R , making the desired answer 5 8 7 .