Cube Of Magnetically Coupled Coils

Figure 1 shows a cubic frame with side length s s . The frame is made of a material with magnetic permeability μ \mu . Each arm of the frame has cross sectional area A A . In each arm, the magnetic field is uniform and also parallel to the arm. Also, s > > A s >> \sqrt{A} , and μ > > μ 0 \mu >> \mu_0 , where μ 0 \mu_0 is the magnetic permeability of free space.

An N N turn coil ( N > > 1 N >> 1 ) is wound around each arm of the frame. Figure 2 shows, for all arms of the frame, how a coil is wound around an arm. Also in Figure 2, pay particular attention to the direction of the magnetic field produced by the current in the coil.

Figure 3 shows how the coils are electrically connected. The shaded dots indicate the terminals of the system.

The inductance of the system as seen across its terminals is X Y μ N 2 A s \frac{X}{Y} \frac{\mu N^2 A}{s}

where X X and Y Y are positive coprime integers. Determine X + Y X+Y .


The answer is 17.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

The vertices of the cube are labeled according to this figure:

Symmetry

The system exhibits a symmetry across the plane 1207 1207 . Also, the upper half and the lower half of the cube are symmetric.

Gauss Law for Magnetic Fields

Knowing that the total magnetic flux entering each vertex is zero, and combining that with the symmetries of the problem:

μ A H 25 = μ A H 23 = μ A H 61 = μ A H 41 = μ A H 12 2 \mu A H_{25} = \mu A H_{23} = \mu A H_{61} = \mu A H_{41} = \dfrac{\mu A H_{12}}{2}

μ A H 50 = μ A H 30 = μ A H 76 = μ A H 74 = μ A H 07 2 \mu A H_{50} = \mu A H_{30} = \mu A H_{76} = \mu A H_{74} = \dfrac{\mu A H_{07}}{2}

μ A H 56 = μ A H 34 = μ A ( H x H y ) 2 \mu A H_{56} = \mu A H_{34} = \dfrac{\mu A (H_x - H_y)}{2}

where H x = H 12 H_x = H_{12} and H y = H 07 H_y = H_{07} .

Kirchoff's Current Law

Analogously, we can write the following equations for the currents:

I 25 = I 23 = I 61 = I 41 = I 12 2 I_{25} = I_{23} = I_{61} = I_{41} = \dfrac{I_{12}}{2}

I 50 = I 30 = I 76 = I 74 = I 07 2 I_{50} = I_{30} = I_{76} = I_{74} = \dfrac{I_{07}}{2}

I 56 = I 34 = I x I y 2 I_{56} = I_{34} = \dfrac{I_x - I_y}{2}

where I x = I 12 I_x = I_{12} and I y = I 07 I_y = I_{07} .

Figure 2 and Ampere's Law

Suppose that the left end of the arm in Figure 2 is labeled as J J and the right end K K . Suppose that as part of our Amperean loop, we traverse this arm from the left end to the right end. Thus, in our Ampere's Law equation, we add + s H J K + s H_{JK} to the left side of the equation, and + N I J K + N I_{JK} to the right side of the equation.

Ampere's Law

We apply Ampere's Law to loops 1256 1256 and 7056 7056 :

s ( H x + H x 2 + H x H y 2 + H x 2 ) = N ( I x + I x 2 + I x I y 2 + I x 2 ) s \left( \dfrac{H_x + H_x}{2} + \dfrac{H_x - H_y}{2} + \dfrac{H_x}{2}\right) = N \left( \dfrac{I_x + I_x}{2} + \dfrac{I_x - I_y}{2} + \dfrac{I_x}{2}\right)

s ( H y + H y 2 + H y H x 2 + H y 2 ) = N ( I y + I y 2 + I y I x 2 + I y 2 ) s \left( \dfrac{H_y + H_y}{2} + \dfrac{H_y - H_x}{2} + \dfrac{Hy}{2} \right) = N \left( \dfrac{I_y + I_y}{2} + \dfrac{I_y - I_x}{2} + \dfrac{I_y}{2}\right)

Solving for H x H_x and H y H_y in these two equations yields H x = N I x s H_x = \dfrac{N I_x}{s} and H y = N I y s H_y = \dfrac{N I_y}{s} .

Self Inductances and Mutual Inductances

Notice the parallelism between the equations derived from Gauss Law and the equations derived from KCL. Using the equations derived from Ampere's Law, it can be easily shown that, for all arms of the cubic frame, the magnetic field H H of an arm and its corresponding coil current I I are related by H = N I s H = \frac{NI}{s} . Notice that the magnetic field in an arm depends only on its corresponding coil current and does not depend on other coil currents. This means that we can effectively simplify the circuit of Figure 3 with all coils having the same effective self inductance and without worrying about mutual inductance.

Magnetic Flux Linkage and Equivalent Inductance

The magnetic flux linkage through a coil is N A μ N I s N A \mu \frac{NI}{s} . Thus, the effective self inductance of each coil is u N 2 A s \frac{u N^2 A}{s} . Simplifying the circuit of Figure 3:

12 5 μ N 2 A s \frac{12}{5} \frac{\mu N^2 A}{s}

Mr. @David Mattingly , I would like to respectfully ask, why is this problem still unrated? Thank you.

Ramon Vicente Marquez - 4 years, 11 months ago

@Ramon Vicente Marquez problem ratings are a function of who's trying and succeeding at the problem. It will take some more attempts before the rating is issued.

Brilliant Physics Staff - 4 years, 11 months ago

Hi @Ramon Vicente Marquez ! I edited your solution and LaTeX'ed all the equations, but I may have messed up something in the solution. If I made an error somewhere, feel free to message me here, or you can experiment with LaTeX.

Alex G - 4 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

@Brilliant Physics I believe that this problem must be moved to another topic/category. I designed this problem such that all of Maxwell's Equations are involved in the solution.

Ramon Vicente Marquez - 4 years, 5 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...