Cut it in half

Geometry Level 4

In how many ways can we cut the triangle, as shown, with one straight line such that the two parts have equal area and equal perimeter?

0 3 2 6 5 1 4

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Chew-Seong Cheong
Jun 24, 2020

Label the triangle as A B C ABC and the cut be D E DE such that A D = a AD=a and A E = b AE=b . Then the area of A D E \triangle ADE is half of that of A B C \triangle ABC or

a b sin A 2 = 1 2 20 21 2 a b 2 20 29 = 1 2 20 21 2 a b = 304.5 b = 304.5 a \begin{aligned} \frac {ab \sin A}2 & = \frac 12 \cdot \frac {20\cdot 21}2 \\ \frac {ab}2\cdot \frac {20}{29} & = \frac 12 \cdot \frac {20\cdot 21}2 \\ \implies ab & = 304.5 \\ b & = \frac {304.5}a \end{aligned}

And also the perimeter of A D E \triangle ADE is the same as quadrilateral D E C B DECB or:

a + b + D E = 20 + 21 a + 29 b + D E a + b = 70 ( a + b ) a + b = 35 a + 304.5 a = 35 a 2 35 a + 304.5 = 0 a , b 16.17712434 , 18.82287566 \begin{aligned} a + b + DE & = 20+21-a + 29-b + DE \\ a+b & = 70 - (a+b) \\ \implies a+b = 35 \\ a + \frac {304.5}a & = 35 \\ a^2 - 35a + 304.5 & = 0 \\ \implies a, b & \approx 16.17712434, 18.82287566 \end{aligned}

Since 21 , 29 > a , b 21, 29 > a, b , there are two ways of "cutting off A \angle A " (the two red dash lines).

Now, using the same logic to cut off C \angle C , then a b = 290 ab=290 , a + b = 35 a+b=35 , and a , b 13.46887113 , 21.53112887 a,b \approx 13.46887113, 21.53112887 . Since 20 < 21.53112887 20 < 21.53112887 , there is only one way of cutting off C \angle C .

To cut off B \angle B , we have a b = 210 ab= 210 , a + b = 35 a+b=35 , and a , b 7.689291565 , 27.31070844 a,b \approx 7.689291565, 27.31070844 . Since 27.31070844 > 21 > 20 27.31070844 > 21 > 20 , there is no way to cut off B \angle B .

Therefore there are 3 \boxed 3 ways to do the equal cut.

Here is the cutting triangle problem

Yuriy Kazakov - 11 months, 3 weeks ago
Chan Lye Lee
Jun 23, 2020

One straight line will pass through 2 sides of the triangle (or 1 vertex and 1 side, which will be included too). There are 3 cases: (i) A C AC and B C BC (ii) A B AB and B C BC (iii) A B AB and A C AC

The case (i) is considered now: Let the side lengths of triangle (on the upper right) be as shown, where 0 < x 21 0 <x \le 21 and 0 < y 29 0 <y \le 29 . Then the side lengths of the quadrilateral (on the lower right) are as shown. Note that the side length z z is in fact unnecessary.

If both parts have the same perimeter, then x + y + z = 20 + ( 29 y ) + ( z ) + ( 21 x ) x+y+z = 20 +(29-y)+(z)+(21-x) , which means that x + y = 35 \textcolor{#D61F06}{x+y=35} . On the other hand, both parts have the same areas implies that 1 2 x y sin C = 1 2 ( 1 2 ( 21 ) ( 29 ) sin C ) \frac{1}{2} xy \sin C = \frac{1}{2} \left( \frac{1}{2}(21)(29)\sin C \right) , that is x y = 304.5 \textcolor{#D61F06}{xy=304.5} . From the sum and product, x x and y y are roots of the equation u 2 35 u + 304.5 = 0 u^2-35u+304.5=0 . Solve the equation, we obtain u u \approx 16.18 or 18.82. Note that both answers less than 21, which means that ( x , y ) = ( 16.18 , 18.82 ) , ( 18.82 , 16.18 ) (x,y) = (16.18,18.82), (18.82, 16.18) are both possible answers. There are 2 \large \textcolor{#3D99F6} {2} answers in this case.

The case (ii) is considered now: Using the same argument, we have r + s = 35 \textcolor{#D61F06}{r+s=35} and r s = 290 \textcolor{#D61F06}{rs=290} where 0 < r 29 0<r\le29 and 0 < s 20 0<s\le 20 . Both r r and s s are roots of equation w 2 35 w + 290 = 0 w^2-35w+290=0 . Solve the equation, we obtain w w\approx 13.47 or 21.53. Hence ( r , s ) = ( 21.53 , 13.47 ) (r,s)=(21.53, 13.47) is an answer while ( r , s ) = ( 13.47 , 21.53 ) (r,s)=(13.47,21.53) is rejected as s > 20 s>20 . There is 1 \large \textcolor{#3D99F6} {1} answer in this case.

The case (iii) is considered now: Using the same argument, we have p + q = 35 \textcolor{#D61F06}{p+q=35} and p q = 210 \textcolor{#D61F06}{pq=210} where 0 < p 21 0<p\le21 and 0 < q 20 0<q\le 20 . Both p p and q q are roots of equation v 2 35 v + 210 = 0 v^2-35v+210=0 . Solve the equation, we obtain v v\approx 7.69 or 27.31. Both answers rejected as either p p or q q > 21. There is 0 \large \textcolor{#3D99F6} {0} answer in this case.

So, there are 3 \large \boxed{\textcolor{#3D99F6}{3}} such lines.

Remarks: There is always a way to cut a convex shape in two so that they have equal area and equal perimeter.

Discussion can be found in this video .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...