David's distance

Geometry Level 4

Let A B C D ABCD be a rectangle such that A B = 5 AB=5 and B C = 12 BC=12 . There exist two distinct points X 1 X_1 and X 2 X_2 on B C BC such that A X 1 D = A X 2 D = 9 0 \angle AX_1D=\angle AX_2D=90^\circ . Suppose that d d is the distance from X 1 X_1 to X 2 X_2 . What is d 2 d^2 ?

This problem is posed by David A .


The answer is 44.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

11 solutions

Let M M , N N be midpoints of A D AD , B C BC respectively.

So that, MN is a symmertry axis of rectangle A B C D ABCD , infer that MN is perpendicular to X 1 X 2 X_1X_2 . ( 1 ) (1)

We have X 1 X 2 X_1X_2 is a chord of circle that has center M M . ( 2 ) (2)

From ( 1 ) (1) and ( 2 ) (2) , we have X 1 X_1 and X 2 X_2 are symmetric by M N MN so d 2 = 4 N X 1 2 d^2=4NX_1^2 . ( 3 ) (3)

Apply Pythagorean theorem to right triangle N X 1 M NX_1M , we have N X 1 2 = M X 1 2 M N 2 = ( A D 2 ) 2 A B 2 = 6 2 5 2 = 11 NX_1^2=MX_1^2-MN^2=\left( \frac {AD}{2} \right)^2-AB^2=6^2-5^2=11 . ( 4 ) (4)

(note: X 1 M X_1M is a median of right triangle X 1 A D X_1AD )

From ( 3 ) (3) and ( 4 ) (4) , we have d 2 = 44 d^2=44 .

A similar solution to that presented, is to let Y 1 Y_1 be the reflection of X 1 X_1 across A D AD . Then X 1 X 2 Y 1 X_1X_2Y_1 is a right triangle with X 1 Y 1 = 10 , X 2 Y 1 = A D = 12 X_1Y_1 = 10, X_2Y_1 = AD = 12 . Hence, X 1 X 2 2 = 1 2 2 1 0 2 X_1 X_2 ^2 = 12^2 - 10^2 .

Most solutions hunted down the exact points, and calculated the lengths of B X 1 BX_1 or C X 2 CX_2 .

Calvin Lin Staff - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

Awesome.....

Sanjeet Raria - 6 years, 9 months ago
Nishanth Hegde
May 20, 2014

We know that, angle subtended in a right angle. So let us consider a circle with centre on midpoint of A D AD say O O Since A X 1 D = A X 2 D \angle AX_{1}D = \angle AX_{2}D We have to take diameter of this circle to be A D AD . Draw a perpendicular from O O to P P . O P = 5 OP=5 Draw segments O X 1 OX_{1} and O X 2 OX_{2} which are radii with radius = 6 6 We can prove that Δ X 1 P O Δ X 2 P O \Delta X_{1}PO \cong \Delta X_{2}PO by RHS congruency. Hence, X 1 P = X 2 O X_{1}P=X_{2}O By considering rt. Δ O P X 2 \Delta OPX_{2} with hypotenuse O X 2 = 6 OX_{2}=6 by pythagoras theorem we have P X 2 = 11 PX_{2} = \sqrt{11} , d = 2 11 d 2 = 44 d=2 \sqrt{11} \Rightarrow d^{2}=44

Miftahus Saidin
May 20, 2014

let DX1 = AX2 = x, AX1 = DX2 = y, and CX1 = BX2 = z by Phytagoras Theorem : x^2 + y^2 = 144 area of rectangle ABCD = 1/2 * 12 * 5 = 30 1/2 * x * y = 30, then y = 60/x.

x^2 + (60/x)^2 = 144 x^4 - 144x^2 + 3600=0 ( x^2 - (72+12 √(11) ) * ( x^2 - (72-12√(11)) ) = 0. x^2 = 72+12 √(11) or x^2 = 72-12 √(11) the value of x must be positive, then x = √(72-12 √(11)) = √66 - √6, y = 72 +12 √(11) = √66 + √6 and z = √((√66 - √6)^2 - 5^2)) = 6 - √11

the value of d^2 = (12 - 2 * z)^2 = (12 - 2 * (6 - √11) )^2 = (2√11)^2 = 44

Haroun Meghaichi
May 20, 2014

We have : A ( 0 , 0 ) , B ( 0 , 5 ) , C ( 12 , 5 ) , D ( 12 , 0 ) A(0,0),B(0,5),C(12,5),D(12,0) , We are trying to find some point M ( x , 5 ) M(x,5) laying on the line BC and verifying that the lines A M AM and M D MD are perpendicular this means that : A M M D = 0. \overrightarrow{AM}\cdot \overrightarrow{MD}=0.

From the coordinates, we get : A M ( x 5 ) \overrightarrow{AM} \left( \begin{matrix} x \\ 5 \end{matrix} \right) , and : M D ( 12 x 5 ) \overrightarrow{MD} \left( \begin{matrix} 12-x \\ -5 \end{matrix} \right) , Hence we get : x ( 12 x ) 25 = 0 x = 6 ± 11 . x(12-x)-25=0 \Longrightarrow x=6\pm \sqrt{11}. We conclude that there are two possibilities for M as stated in the problem : X 1 ( 6 + 11 , 5 ) , X 2 ( 6 11 ) X_1(6+\sqrt{11},5),X_2(6-\sqrt{11}) , the distance between them is : d = 2 11 d= 2 \sqrt{11} ,

Finally, we have : d 2 = ( 2 11 ) 2 = 44 d^2=\left(2\sqrt{11}\right)^2=44 .

Let O O be the midpoint of A A and D D . Let θ 1 \theta_1 and θ 2 \theta_2 be A O X 1 \angle AOX_1 and D O X 2 \angle DOX_2 , respectively.Let M M be the midpoint of X 1 X_1 and X 2 X_2 .

Because A X 1 D = A X 2 D = 9 0 o \angle AX_1D = \angle AX_2D = 90^o we can say that X 1 a n d X 2 X_1 and X_2 lies on a circle whose diameter is A D AD , specifically it's center is O O . Let's call this circle γ \gamma .

Since A B C D ABCD is a parallelogram, then we can say that the perpendicular distance of M M to line segment A D AD is A B = 5 AB=5 . Since the radius of the circle γ = A D 2 = 6 \gamma = \frac{AD}{2} = 6 , then the distance from O O to X 1 X_1 and X 2 X_2 is also 6 6 .

Thus if we use the pythagorean relation to the right triangle X 1 M O X_1MO , we can see that X 1 M = 11 X_1M = \sqrt{11} . Moreover, using the same line of argument X 2 M = 11 X_2M = \sqrt{11} . It is clear that M O MO is perpendicular to A D AD and B C BC because c o s θ 1 = c o s θ 2 cos \theta_1 = cos \theta_2 and A B C D ABCD is a rectangle.

Therefore the distance, d d , from X 1 X_1 to X 2 X_2 is 2 11 2\sqrt{11} . Thus, d 2 = ( 2 11 ) 2 = 44 d^2 = (2\sqrt{11})^2 = 44

Marina Lauren
May 20, 2014

Let x1 and x2 divide BC into 3 segments with each of the length is (6-d/2), d, and (6-d/2). Suppose that Ax1 is x and Ax2 is y X^2=25+(6-d/2)^2 Y^2=25+(6+d/2)^2 And also x^2+y^2=144 By subtitution method, we can get d^2=44

Given the rectangle A B C D ABCD with A B = C D = 5 AB = CD = 5 and B C = A D = 12 BC = AD = 12 , and the two points X 1 X_1 and X 2 X_2 such that A X 1 D ∠AX_1D and A X 2 D ∠AX_2D are both equal to 9 0 90^∘ . So we draw line segments from A A to X 1 X_1 , X 1 X_1 to D D , A A to X 2 X_2 , and X 2 X_2 to D D inside A B C D ABCD .

Let us focus now on trapezoid A B X 2 D ABX_2D , which is so because A D B X 2 AD || BX_2 . Within A B X 2 D ABX_2D are two triangles, A B X 2 ABX_2 and A X 2 D AX_2D , which are both right triangles because they contain the right angles A B X 2 ∠ABX_2 and A X 2 D ∠AX_2D , respectively. Also, X 1 X_1 is in the segment B X 2 BX_2 .

Let x x be the length of segment A X 2 AX_2 , y y be that of segment D X 2 DX_2 , z z , that of segment B X 1 BX_1 , and w = z + d w = z + d ( d d is the length of segment X 1 X 2 X_1X_2 ; w w = length of segment B X 2 BX_2 ). Furthermore, the side X 2 X_2 is common between the triangles A B X 2 ABX_2 and A X 2 D AX_2D . From these information and the Pythagorean Theorem, A B 2 + B X 2 2 = A X 2 2 AB^2 + BX_2^2 = AX_2^2 and A X 2 2 + D X 2 2 = A D 2 AX_2^2 + DX_2^2 = AD^2 , or equivalently,

1.25 + w 2 = x 2 1. 25 + w^2 = x^2

2. x 2 + y 2 = 144 2. x^2 + y^2 = 144

By substitution, we have 25 + w 2 + y 2 = 144 25 + w^2 + y^2 = 144 , or

3. w 2 + y 2 = 119 3. w^2 + y^2 = 119 .

Let us now take in triangle D C X 2 DCX_2 , which is also a right triangle because of right angle D C X 2 ∠DCX_2 . Furthermore, segment D X 2 DX_2 is the hypotenuse of D C X 2 DCX_2 . So letting a a be the length of side C X 2 CX_2 ,

4. a 2 + 25 = y 2 4. a^2 + 25 = y^2

Another substitution gives us:

5. w 2 + a 2 = 94 5. w^2 + a^2 = 94

Another thing about a a is that it is also equal to 12 w 12 - w . Solving for w w in terms of a a ( w = 12 a w = 12 - a ), and substituting this into 5 5 :

6. ( 12 a ) 2 + a 2 = 94 6. (12 - a)^2 + a^2 = 94

Simplifying, and multiplying both sides of the equation by 1 2 \frac {1}{2} :

7. a 2 12 a + 25 = 0 7. a^2 - 12a + 25 = 0

Using the Quadratic Formula to find a a , a = C X 2 = 6 ± 11 a = CX_2 = 6 \pm \sqrt{11} .

This is one part. The second one comes when we consider trapezoid D C X 1 A DCX_1A with triangles A X 1 D AX_1D and D C X 1 DCX_1 , and triangle A B X 1 ABX_1 , and the variables are assigned to corresponding segments on both polygons. Using the similar line of argument as the one we had before, we have B X 1 = 6 ± 11 BX_1 = 6 \pm \sqrt{11} .

Finally, it can be verified that B X 1 + X 1 X 2 + C X 2 = B C BX_1 + X_1X_2 + CX_2 = BC . Thus, the lengths of B X 1 BX_1 and C X 2 CX_2 must not exceed that of B C BC , which is 12. Out of the two possible values for B X 1 BX_1 and C X 2 CX_2 , the only acceptable value is 6 11 6 - \sqrt{11} . Therefore, B X 1 BX_1 = C X 2 CX_2 = 6 11 6 - \sqrt{11} , leaving X 1 X 2 = 2 11 X_1X_2 = 2\sqrt{11} , which is the exact value of d d . The required answer is d 2 = ( 2 11 ) 2 = 44 d^2 = (2\sqrt{11})^2 = 44 .

Fox To-ong
Jan 22, 2015

using to-ong triangular theorem

What's the "to-ong" triangular theorem?

Also, did you find this problem through a wiki page?

Calvin Lin Staff - 6 years, 4 months ago
Ahmed Essam
Jun 10, 2014

let's assume that D X = x DX = x

in the right angle triangle A D X ADX :

A X 2 = 5 2 + x 2 AX^2 = 5^2 + x^2

and in the right angle triangle X B C XBC

X B 2 = 5 2 + ( 12 x ) 2 XB^2 = 5^2 + (12-x)^2

and in the right angle triangle A B X ABX

A X 2 = 1 2 2 X B 2 AX^2 = 12^2 - XB^2

A X 2 = 1 2 2 ( 5 2 + ( 12 x ) 2 ) AX^2 = 12^2 -( 5^2 + (12-x)^2 )

since A X = A X AX = AX :D we can say that

1 2 2 ( 5 2 + ( 12 x ) 2 ) = 5 2 + x 2 12^2 - ( 5^2 + (12-x)^2 ) = 5^2 + x^2

we can solve this equation easily and we will get that

x = 6 11 x = 6 - \sqrt{11} ... which is D X 1 DX1

x = 6 + 11 x = 6 + \sqrt{11} ... which is D X 2 DX2

we subtract them to get X 1 X 2 = 2 11 X1X2 = 2 \sqrt{11}

we square to get 44 \boxed{44}

Aneesh Kundu
Jun 5, 2014

A X 1 D AX_{1}D and A X 2 D AX_{2}D lie in the same circle with circumcenter as the midpoint of AD, so the circumradius comes out to be A D 2 = 6 \frac {AD}{2}=6 . Draw perpendiculars X 1 E X_{1}E and X 2 F X_{2}F to A D AD . X 1 E = X 2 E = A B = 5 X_{1}E = X_{2}E = AB = 5 . In triangle E X 1 O EX_{1}O , E X 1 = 5 EX_{1} = 5 , X 1 O = 6 X_{1}O = 6 . By applying pythagorean theorem on right triangle E X 1 O EX_{1}O , we obtain E O = 11 EO = \sqrt{11} . By symmetry we get E O = O F = 11 EO = OF = \sqrt{11}

E F = 2 11 \Rightarrow EF = 2 \sqrt{11}

Since E X 1 X 2 F EX_{1}X_{2}F is a rectangle.

X 1 X 2 = E F = 2 11 \Rightarrow X_{1}X_{2} = EF = 2 \sqrt{11}

X 1 X 2 2 = 44 \Rightarrow X_{1}X^2_{2} = 44

Hans Ardisa
May 20, 2014

i just draw it on paper,with my 90 degree ruler, and i got d is 6,6 so d^2=43,56 which mean 43 or 44 i answer 44 for the first time and it true :D

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...