Can we place a distinct integer from 1 to 8 into each black circle such that the sums along the 7 colored paths are the same?
For example, we have filled up the circles, but not all of the colored paths have the same sum.
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
The configuration of this puzzle strongly resembles the "magic circle" above, first mentioned by the Japanese mathematician Isomura in 1660. You can fill the circles with digits from 1 through 8 (each used only once) such that the two circles and the two lines each add to the same value.
Edit: The solution has been updated with an explicit construction. It is now complete.
How does this demonstrate that the answer is yes? What you have to do, is to show that this can indeed be achieved. To me, your solution simply says "My working shows that I haven't reached a contradiction as yet", and hence it is incomplete.
One way of presenting the solution for this problem would be to
1. Give the explicit construction.
2. Provide the logical steps that you took, to demonstrate that the answer can be obtained by non-trial and error approaches.
This example seems wrong: for example the top side adds up to 1+8+2=11 while the left side adds up to 1+5+6=12.
YOU NEED TO SWAP 3 AND 2 THEN IT IS CORRECT
If we select any number from 1 to 8 and put it any box. Then we have 7 eqn and 7 variables and this can be solved so "yes".
Log in to reply
Not quite. How do you know that the solutions will be the other 7 integers?
E.g. In the given example, if we tried setting the sum to 11, then a solution would have the circle with 8 replace with 5. Solving that system of 7 equations does not lead to "distinct integers from 1 to 8".
The sum = 36; since the periferical vertical and horizontal lines have 3 terms 36/3 =12 So the arrangement will be: Top horiz. line 1+5+6 =12 Ctr. horiz. line 8 + 4 = 12 Bott horiz. line 3+7+2 =12 Vertical lines 12 12 12 Circle: 1+6+2+3 =12
You said "each of the circles is intersected by two lines". It's inaccurate. Because the corner circles are at the intersections of three lines.
So basically the step where you add "2" is redundant. You can simply replace each sum with S and then say 3S=36.
Unnecessarily complicated. See solution of @Danny Whittaker.
if we write it like 1-3-6-8 and 2-4-5-7 along the lines, then it is following the rules.
I don't understand your solution: how did you get 36 at step 1
The sum of the 8 numbers is 36.
The circles can be divided up into 3 disjoint sets: Green Circle, Red Line, Dark Blue Line.
These 3 sets must total 36, so each set must total 12.
Since the sum is even, there must always be 2 odds or 0 odds in each row.
It becomes fairly simple to place them now, especially since 12 can only be formed as 7+5 or 8+4.
Very similar to my solution. Easy and quick.
A deductive logic solution in 4 steps that should be familiar to avid players of Kakuro:
-Given that there is one sum with 4 addends, the minimum common result for all sums has to be 10. (1+2+3+4=10). Similarly, given that there are two sums with 2 addends, the maximum possible common result is 13, as 14 and 15 can only be obtained with one sum each. (8+6 and 8+7). This gives us a possible range of results of 10-13.
-It is immediately evident that the hypothetical results of 10 and 11 can only be obtained in one exact way in the four-addends sum (1+2+3+4 and 1+2+3+5), and since there are only 8 possible numbers, it is also readily evident that there's no way of making two two-addends sums with a result of 10 or 11 with the four leftover numbers for each case. Thus, we're looking at a potential result of 12 or 13.
-The fact that our minimum possible result is now 12 means that 1, 2, and 3 cannot possibly appear in two-addend sums, meaning that they have to be placed in three of the four corners AND that 1 and 2 cannot be connected by a line, as there's no one number big enough to add to their sum that results in 12 or 13. Thus, they have to be in opposite corners and we have two side sums that read (1+/ /+3 and 3+/ /+2).
-This quickly leads to the realisation that the only possible number on the 1+/ /+3 sum is 8 and that the common result is 12. The rest of the numbers, then, can be filled in easily.
Solve it like solving a sodoku :)
Oh wow, on second viewing, this question really looks like a sudoku question. Thanks for sharing your technique.
If we write no. In each box as a variable(a,b,c,d,e,f,g,h) in clockwise direction we can solve this easily.
See, a+b+c=x as it is given .
Also,
c+d+e=x,
e+f+g=x,
g+h+a=x and also
e+h=x,b+f=x.
So, 2(a+b+c+d+e+f+g+h)=6x ,I hav added all the equations,
sum of all boxes is 36 as we know1+2+3+4+5+6+7+8=36.
so,36=3x and x=12.so a+b+c=12.
And the clockwise order of numbers is 1,8,3,7,2,4,6,5
First, notice that the eight numbers can be partitioned into three disjoint sets, the outer circle and the central horizontal and vertical lines, each of which needs to add up to the same number. Since the sum of the eight numbers is 36, each row/column/circle sum must be 12.
The central segments only have two numbers, and there are only two pairs of numbers that sum to 12: 5+7 and 4+8. Those must be placed in the four non-corner spots, with 4 opposite 8 and 5 opposite 7. 1 and 3 must be in the corners next to 8. There are two choices at this point: next to 5 or next to 7. Putting the 1 next to the 7 would require the '4' to be in two places. OTOH, if the 1 is next to the 5, the 6 slots in on the other side, with the 2 in the opposite corner.
Solution:
6 - 4 - 2
5 - * - 7
1 - 8 - 3
Any solution is a reflection/rotation (or combination) of this pattern.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Let x 1 , x 2 , x 3 , and x 4 be the values in the corners. Let y 1 , y 2 , y 3 , and y 4 be the values in the sides. y 1 and y 4 are opposite each other, and y 2 and y 3 are opposite each other.
The sum of all integers is x 1 + x 2 + x 3 + x 4 + y 1 + y 2 + y 3 + y 4 = 3 6
Suppose that y 1 + y 4 = y 2 + y 3 = x 1 + x 2 + x 3 + x 4
Since each of the circles is intersected by two lines, then the integer in the circle occurs twice in the sum. In this case, 2 ( x 1 + x 2 + x 3 + x 4 + y 1 + y 2 + y 3 + y 4 ) = 7 2
Set S = x 1 + x 2 + x 3 + x 4 , so 2 ( ( x 1 + x 2 + x 3 + x 4 ) + ( y 1 + y 4 ) + ( y 2 + y 3 ) ) 2 ⋅ 3 S 6 S S = 7 2 = 7 2 = 7 2 = 1 2
So since S is an integer, we can place distinct integers in each circle, such that y 1 + y 4 = y 2 + y 3 = 1 2
Since there are several ways to present the sum of 2 terms as 1 2 out of the given integers, the possibilities for y 1 , y 2 , y 3 , y 4 are ( 4 , 8 ) and ( 5 , 7 ) . The candidates for x 1 , x 2 , x 3 , x 4 are 1 , 2 , 3 and 6 .
Here is the corrected diagram as an example: