Disintegrated Disk Debris

Classical Mechanics Level pending

A circular disk of radius R R and area mass density σ \sigma is positioned in the x y xy plane with its center at the origin. A point on the disk has position P d \vec{P}_d , which varies with the polar coordinates.

The disk is then blasted into infinitesimal pieces, with each piece initially having speed v 0 v_0 . The initial velocity of each piece is directed along the line from P \vec{P} to P d \vec{P}_d (see details). There is an ambient gravitational acceleration g g in the negative z z direction.

The disk fragments eventually land in the x y xy plane, where they remain fixed in place. Let I 0 I_0 be the moment of inertia of the original disk with respect to the z z axis, and let I I be the moment of inertia of the final debris field with respect to the z z axis.

What is I I 0 \large{\frac{I}{I_0}} ?

Details and Assumptions:
1) R = 1 R = 1
2) σ = 1 \sigma = 1
3) v 0 = 5 v_0 = 5
4) g = 10 g = 10
5) P = ( 1 , 0 , 1 ) \vec{P} = (-1,0,-1)
6) Neglect mutual gravitational interactions between disk fragments


The answer is 13.98.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Karan Chatrath
Jan 14, 2020

General outline of the solution: Consider a mass element of mass d m = ρ r d r d θ dm = \rho r dr d\theta . It has an initial position:

P d = r cos θ i ^ + r sin θ j ^ \vec{P}_d = r\cos{\theta} \hat{i} + r\sin{\theta} \hat{j}

Let:

n = P d P \vec{n} = \vec{P}_d - \vec{P} n ^ = P d P P d P \hat{n} = \frac{\vec{P}_d - \vec{P}}{\mid \vec{P}_d - \vec{P} \mid}

The initial velocity vector of this mass element is:

v o = v o x i ^ + y v o y j ^ + v o z k ^ = v o n ^ \vec{v}_o = v_{ox} \hat{i} +yv_{oy} \hat{j}+v_{oz} \hat{k} = v_o \hat{n}

The acceleration vector of this elementary mass is:

a = g k ^ \vec{a} = -g \hat{k}

Solving for the motion of the element mass yields:

x ( t ) = v o x t + r cos θ x(t) = v_{ox}t + r\cos{\theta} y ( t ) = v o y t + r sin θ y(t) = v_{oy}t + r\sin{\theta} z ( t ) = v o z t 1 2 g t 2 z(t) = v_{oz}t -\frac{1}{2}gt^2

When the mass strikes the XY plane again, it does so when z = 0 z = 0 . This occurs at a time:

T = 2 v o z g T = \frac{2v_{oz}}{g}

Using this, the x and y coordinates of landing can be found by replacing time T T in x ( t ) x(t) and y ( t ) y(t) . Let the final coordinates after flight be X X and Y Y . Using these exact results, the moment of inertia of this mass element about the Z-axis can be found as such:

d I = d m ( X 2 + Y 2 ) dI = dm(X^2 + Y^2) I = 0 1 0 2 π ( X 2 + Y 2 ) ρ r d r d θ I = \int_{0}^{1}\int_{0}^{2\pi} (X^2 + Y^2) \rho r dr d\theta

Substituting all expressions and simplifying gives the exact integrand. One may attempt to get a closed-form solution (not checked), but I have integrated this expression numerically to obtain:

I I o 14 \boxed{\frac{I}{I_o} \approx 14}

Steven Chase
Jan 14, 2020

See the solution by @Karan Chatrath for details. Below is a picture of the debris field. To make this image, I divided the disk into 4 × 1 0 4 4 \times 10^4 pieces and plotted the landing coordinates for all of them. I used a much higher resolution to derive the moment ratio. The bulk of the matter forms a crescent pattern on the right. The banding is an artifact of the finite resolution used to divide the disk.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...