Elastic Collisions

Six identical balls are lined in a straight groove made on a horizontal, frictionless surface, as shown below. Two similar balls each moving with velocity v v collide with the row of 6 balls from left.

What will happen after the collision, if the collisions are perfectly elastic?

Two balls from the right roll out with speed v v each and the remaining balls remain stationary One ball from the right rolls out with speed 2 v 2v and the remaining balls remain at rest All six balls roll out with speed v 6 \frac v6 each and the two colliding balls come to rest One ball from left rolls back with the same speed v v and one from right rolls forward with v v

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Rohit Gupta
Feb 5, 2016

When an elastic ball collides with another identical ball, then their velocities get exchanged. Therefore, if a ball is moving with velocity 'v' hits a stationary ball, then the first will come to rest and the latter will start moving with velocity 'v'.
The situation in problem can be thought of multiple collisions between the balls. The balls can be thought at an infinitely small distance apart. To simplify, consider the situation with four balls.

The balls are numbered. First collision can be taken between ball 2 and ball 3. After the collision ball 2 will come to rest and ball 3 moves with speed 'v'.

Now, the ball 3 and 1 collides with ball 4 and 2, after that ball 1 and 3 comes to rest and ball 4 and 2 start moving with speed 'v'

Now, the ball 2 collides with ball 3 to come to rest and ball 3 moves with speed v. Thus, eventually balls 3 and 4 moves with speed 'v'.

If the situation is extended to 8 balls, still the result will be same last two balls will roll with velocity 'v' each and rest of the balls will come to rest.

Nice illustration. Newton's Cradle is an example of this principle.

Ajit Deshpande - 5 years, 4 months ago

NYC explanation...... thanks a lot

Qadiri Smarty - 4 years, 4 months ago

You cannot treat this collision as a series of 2-ball collisions. That is an incorrect model to use when analysing a Newton's Cradle.

If all of the balls are touching at the moment of impact, then the subsequent motion cannot be uniquely determined by just using the conservation of momentum & conservation of energy formula. This is becomes you only have two equations to determine 4 final velocities - there is insufficient information.

To fully analyse the system, you need to consider the compression wave as it travels through the series of balls. The mathematics can become complicated!

In reality ALL of the balls have some velocity after the initial impact, most of the moment is carried away by the final ball in the chain.

Ged Langosz - 1 year ago

Log in to reply

They weren’t touching at the start.

Isaiah Scott - 2 weeks ago

Think of every two balls in this picture as a "big" ball would help you to analyze. It's just a Newton's cradle.

Junning Huang - 5 months, 1 week ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...