Equable Cone

Geometry Level 3

If a right circular cone with an integer height and an integer radius has the same numerical value for its volume and its surface area, find its slant height.


The answer is 10.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Chris Lewis
May 26, 2021

A cone with base radius r r and height h h , has volume, surface area and slant height V = 1 3 π r 2 h ; S = π r 2 + π r r 2 + h 2 ; s = r 2 + h 2 V=\frac13 \pi r^2 h;\;\;\;S=\pi r^2+\pi r\sqrt{r^2+h^2};\;\;\;s=\sqrt{r^2+h^2} respectively. Equating V V and S S , 1 3 π r 2 h = π r 2 + π r r 2 + h 2 r h = 3 r + 3 r 2 + h 2 r h 3 r = 3 r 2 + h 2 r 2 h 2 6 r 2 h + 9 r 2 = 9 r 2 + 9 h 2 r 2 h 2 6 r 2 h = 9 h 2 r 2 h 6 r 2 = 9 h \begin{aligned}\frac13 \pi r^2 h &= \pi r^2+\pi r\sqrt{r^2+h^2} \\ rh &= 3r+3\sqrt{r^2+h^2} \\ rh-3r &=3\sqrt{r^2+h^2} \\ r^2 h^2-6r^2 h+9r^2 &=9r^2+9h^2 \\ r^2 h^2-6r^2 h &=9h^2 \\ r^2 h-6r^2 &=9h \end{aligned}

We need to solve this in positive integers. Using the usual factorising trick, r 2 h 6 r 2 = 9 h r 2 h 6 r 2 9 h + 54 = 54 ( r 2 9 ) ( h 6 ) = 54 \begin{aligned} r^2 h-6r^2 &=9h \\ r^2 h-6r^2-9h+54&=54 \\ \left(r^2-9\right)(h-6)&=54 \end{aligned} so that r 2 = 9 + 54 h 6 r^2=9+\frac{54}{h-6}

We can now just check factors of 54 54 ; the only solution comes when h = 8 h=8 , r = 6 r=6 and we find the slant height s = 10 s=\boxed{10} .

It's nice but shouldn't be too surprising that the slant height turns out to be an integer as well - the surface area can also be written S = π r 2 + π r s S=\pi r^2 + \pi rs

and the volume is a rational multiple of π \pi .

Chris Lewis - 2 weeks, 3 days ago

Log in to reply

This comment inspired me to write a different solution, where first I show that 3 l 3l must be an integer and then I solve the equation for 3 l 3l . (In my solution the slant height is l l .)

David Vreken - 2 weeks, 1 day ago
David Vreken
May 28, 2021

Since the volume and surface area have the same numerical value, 1 3 π r 2 h = π r 2 + π r l \frac{1}{3}\pi r^2 h = \pi r^2 + \pi r l , which rearranges to 3 l = r h 3 r 3l = rh - 3r , so 3 l 3l must also be an integer.

Substituting h = l 2 r 2 h = \sqrt{l^2 - r^2} into the above equation, this rearranges to l = r + 9 r + 3 9 r 3 l = r + \cfrac{9}{r + 3} - \cfrac{9}{r - 3} .

This can be rearranged to 3 l ( r + 3 ) = 3 r ( r + 3 ) + 54 + 162 r 3 3l(r + 3) = 3r(r + 3) + 54 + \cfrac{162}{r - 3} and 3 l ( r 3 ) = 3 r ( r 3 ) + 54 162 r + 3 3l(r - 3) = 3r(r - 3) + 54 - \cfrac{162}{r + 3} , which tells us that r 3 r - 3 and r + 3 r + 3 are factors of 162 162 .

The difference between these two factors is ( r + 3 ) ( r 3 ) = 6 (r + 3) - (r - 3) = 6 , and the only positive factors of 162 162 (which include 1 , 2 , 3 , 6 , 9 , 18 , 27 , 54 , 81 , 162 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, 18, 27, 54, 81, 162 ) that are 6 6 apart are 3 3 and 9 9 , which means r 3 = 3 r - 3 = 3 or r = 6 r = 6 , and l = r + 9 r + 3 9 r 3 = 6 + 9 6 + 3 9 6 3 = 10 . l = r + \cfrac{9}{r + 3} - \cfrac{9}{r - 3} = 6 + \cfrac{9}{6 + 3} - \cfrac{9}{6 - 3} = \boxed{10}.

Ryan S
May 27, 2021

Volume V = 1 3 π r 2 h V=\frac13\pi r^2h , surface area S = π r 2 + π r r 2 + h 2 S=\pi r^2+\pi r\sqrt{r^2+h^2} .

Through algebraic manipulation, V = S r = 3 h h 6 V=S\iff r=3\sqrt{\frac h{h-6}} .

r , h N h h 6 N h h 6 = n 2 r,h\in\mathbb N\implies\sqrt{\frac h{h-6}}\in\mathbb N\implies \frac h{h-6}=n^2 for n N 7 h n\in\mathbb N\implies7\leq h (as h 6 > 0 h-6>0 ), and h 12 h\leq12 (as h h 6 2 \frac h{h-6}\geq2 ( 2 2 not 1 1 since never does h = h 6 h=h-6 ))

7 h 12 7 n 2 2 7\leq h\leq12\implies7\geq n^2\geq2

4 4 is the only square in this range.

n 2 = 4 h = 8 r = 6 r 2 + h 2 = 10 \implies n^2=4\implies h=8\implies r=6\implies\sqrt{r^2+h^2}=10

Great solution!

David Vreken - 2 weeks, 1 day ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...