Falzoon's Ellipse

Calculus Level 3

A circle and an ellipse of the same area share the interior of a larger circle, without overlap.

For the size of the smaller circle, the ellipse has the largest possible area that could fit in the space between the smaller and larger circle. Let a a be the combined areas of the ellipse and the small circle, and let b b be the area of the large circle.

Find 10000 a b \left\lfloor 10000\dfrac { a }{ b } \right\rfloor

You may want to use a computer for this.


The answer is 6349.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Michael Mendrin
Sep 4, 2014

First, let the radius of the big circle be 1 1 . Then let

r r be the radius of the small circle
R R be the major axis of the ellipse
k k be the shrink factor of the ellipse

We set up the equations of the circles and ellipse such that the bottom of the ellipse is at the origin ( 0 , 0 ) (0,0) tangent to the small circle which is itself tangent to the large circle at ( 0 , 2 r ) (0,-2r) . Then to find the intersection of the ellipse and the big circle, we solve the equation

( 1 2 r ) + 1 x 2 = k ( R + R 2 x 2 ) (1-2r)+\sqrt { 1-{ x }^{ 2 } } =k(R+\sqrt { { R }^{ 2 }-{ x }^{ 2 } } )

Let B = ( 1 2 r ) k R B=(1-2r)-kR to reduce clutter

Expanding and re-arranging, we have the quadratic in x 2 { x }^{ 2 } to solve

( 1 2 k 2 + k 4 ) x 4 + ( 2 + 2 B 2 + 2 k 2 + 2 B 2 k 2 + 2 R 2 k 2 2 R 2 k 4 ) x 2 + ( 1 2 B 2 + B 4 2 k 2 R 2 2 B 2 k 2 R 2 + k 4 R 4 ) = 0 (1-2{ k }^{ 2 }+{ k }^{ 4 }){ x }^{ 4 }+(-2+2{ B }^{ 2 }+2{ k }^{ 2 }+2{ B }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }+2{ R }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }-2{ R }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 4 }){ x }^{ 2 }+(1-2{ B }^{ 2 }+{ B }^{ 4 }-2{ k }^{ 2 }{ R }^{ 2 }-2{ B }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }{ R }^{ 2 }+{ k }^{ 4 }{ R }^{ 4 })=0

For the intersections to be points of tangency, the radical in the quadratic solution must vanish, which means this condition must be satisfied

( 2 + 2 B 2 + 2 k 2 + 2 B 2 k 2 + 2 R 2 k 2 2 R 2 k 4 ) 2 4 ( 1 2 k 2 + k 4 ) ( 1 2 B 2 + B 4 2 k 2 R 2 2 B 2 k 2 R 2 + k 4 R 4 ) = 0 { (-2+2{ B }^{ 2 }+2{ k }^{ 2 }+2{ B }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }+2{ R }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }-2{ R }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 4 }) }^{ 2 }-4(1-2{ k }^{ 2 }+{ k }^{ 4 })(1-2{ B }^{ 2 }+{ B }^{ 4 }-2{ k }^{ 2 }{ R }^{ 2 }-2{ B }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }{ R }^{ 2 }+{ k }^{ 4 }{ R }^{ 4 })=0

Expanding and re-arranging, this reduces to

16 B 2 k 2 ( 1 + B 2 + k 2 + R 2 k 2 R 2 ) = 0 16{ B }^{ 2 }{ k }^{ 2 }(-1+{ B }^{ 2 }+k^{ 2 }+{ R }^{ 2 }-{ k }^{ 2 }{ R }^{ 2 })=0

Plugging B = ( 1 2 r ) k R B=(1-2r)-kR back in, we end up with the quadratic to solve for k k

k 2 2 ( 1 2 r ) R k + ( R 2 4 r ( 1 r ) ) = 0 { k }^{ 2 }-2(1-2r)Rk+({ R }^{ 2 }-4r(1-r))=0

which gets us

k = ( 1 2 r ) R + 2 r ( 1 r ) ( 1 R 2 ) ) k=(1-2r)R+2\sqrt { r(1-r)(1-{ R }^{ 2 }) } )

The area of the ellipse is pi times k R 2 k{ R }^{ 2 } . We differentiate this with respect to R R to find the maximum. After re-arranging, we have the quadratic in R 2 { R }^{ 2 } to solve

9 R 4 + 3 ( 3 2 r ) ( 2 r + 1 ) R 2 + 16 r ( 1 r ) = 0 9{ R }^{ 4 }+3(3-2r)(2r+1){ R }^{ 2 }+16r(1-r)=0

which gets us

R = 1 6 ( 3 2 r ) ( 2 r + 1 ) ( 2 r 1 ) 4 r 2 4 r + 9 R=\frac { 1 }{ \sqrt { 6 } } \sqrt { (3-2r)(2r+1)-(2r-1)\sqrt { 4{ r }^{ 2 }-4r+9 } }

Then we solve by numerical means the equation

k R 2 r 2 = 0 k{ R }^{ 2 }-{ r }^{ 2 }=0

to find that r = 0.5634366252335449 r=0.5634366252335449…

From this, the answer to this problem is

Floor 10000 ( 2 r 2 ) = 6349 \left\lfloor 10000(2{ r }^{ 2 }) \right\rfloor =6349

Trivial expression is a mistake.

Lu Chee Ket - 6 years, 9 months ago
Lu Chee Ket
Sep 8, 2014

Equating x^2 and d y/ d x of big circle and ellipse makes the answer.

Fix small circle at x^2 + (y - 1)^2 = 1 where radius of 1 unit is taken as reference for ratios. Take x^2/ a^2 + (y - b - 2)^2/ b^2 = 1 for ellipse. Since Pi a b = Pi r^2 and r = 1, 1/ a = b.

x^2 + (y - b - 2)^2/ b^4 = 1/ b^2 is the ellipse above the circle x^2 + (y - 1)^2 = 1 .

x^2 + (y - h)^2 = h^2 is taken for big circle.

Subtract big circle by ellipse:

(b^4 - 1) y^2 - 2 (b^4 h - b - 2) y - 4 (b + 1) = 0

Differentiate big circle x^2 + y^2 - 2 h y = 0,

d y/ d x = x/ (h - y)

Differentiate ellipse b^ 4 x^2 + (y - b - 2)^2 = b^2,

dy/ d x = b^4 x/ (2 + b - y)

Equate tangent of ellipse to tangent of big circle,

y = (b^4 h - b - 2)/ (b^4 - 1)

Substitute y = (b^4 h - b - 2)/ (b^4 - 1) into (b^4 - 1) y^2 - 2 (b^4 h - b - 2) y - 4 (b + 1) = 0,

(b^4 h - b - 2)^2/ (1 - b^4) = 4 (1 + b)

=> h = (2 + b +/- 2 sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)))/ b^4

d h/ d b = 0 for minimum h

=> b +/- (b - 4 b^4 - 5 b^5)/ sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)) = 8 + 4 b +/- 8

sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b))

Since removing surd form will make polynomial of high degree which must only be solved by iteration method for real roots, knowing 0 < b < 1 and 1 + b < h < 2, direct substitution can solve this equation. Found that only b - (b - 4 b^4 - 5 b^5)/ sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)) = 8 + 4 b - 8 sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)) is changing sign between b = 0.7 and b = 0.8 for the range when arranged,

b = 0.724911899756926

hence h = 1.77482250037526

Maximum (ellipse + small circle)/ (big circle) = [Pi (a b + r^2)]/ [Pi h^2] = 2/ h^2 = 0.634921661309133

Floor(0.634921661309133 x 10000) = 6349

Solving 9 b^10 + ... = 0 for interest:

b -/+ (b - 4 b^4 - 5 b^5)/ sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)) = 8 + 4 b -/+ 8 sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b))

=> -/+ (b - 4 b^4 - 5 b^5)/ sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)) +/- 8 sqrt((1 - b^4)(1 + b)) = 8 + 3 b

=> 9 b^10 + 24 b^9 + 16 b^8 + 9 b^7 + 15 b^6 + 8 b^5 + 0 b^4 - 9 b^3 - 8 b^2 = 0

=> b^2 (b + 1)^2 (b^2 - b + 1) (9 b^4 + 15 b^3 + b^2 - b - 8) = 0

For 9 b^4 + 15 b^3 + b^2 - b - 8 = 0 of a genuine quartic equation,

  b = 0.724911899756926

or b = -1.73574947813852

or b = -0.3279145441425 + j 0.77389400250686

or b = -0.3279145441425 - j 0.77389400250686

Not substituted all to original equation for check and therefore uncertain unless checked.

If tangents not equated, then an elongated ellipse can have four intersections with the big circle. On the other hand, equating only tangents ought to suffer a lost of constant or location. With both, (b^4 h - b - 2)^2/ (1 - b^4) = 4 (1 + b) for many sets are obtainable. The only extreme is a minimum h^2 as denominator and a fixed numerator of 1 for a maximum.

Lu Chee Ket - 6 years, 7 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...