A necklace of circles

Geometry Level 2

10 identical circles of radius 2 are externally tangential to one another, as shown.

Connecting the centers of adjacent circles gives a 10-sided polygon, which divides the circles into two areas: blue and yellow. The positive difference between the blue and yellow areas is k π . k \pi.

What is k ? k?


The answer is 8.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

11 solutions

Edward So
Oct 15, 2017

Relevant wiki: Triangles - Exterior Angles

The sum of the angles for the different parts between the blue and yellow areas should always equal to 2 times the sum of exterior angle of the polygon.

Both red and green part are the exterior angle of the 10-sided polygon.

The sum of exterior angle of the polygon always be 360 degree(angle on yellow side will count as negative values).

Sum of red and green part exterior angle will be 2 times 360.

So the positive difference between the blue and yellow areas should be 2 times the area of one circle.

As the radius is 2, the positive difference between the blue and yellow areas will be 2 × π r 2 = 2 × π 2 2 = 8 π 2\times\pi r^2=2\times\pi2^2=\boxed{8}\pi

should always equal to 2 times the sum of exterior angle of the polygon

Why is this the case?

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

check on this link talk about Sum of Exterior Angles of a Polygon first. In the diagram I provided, the green part is a set of exterior angles of the 10-sided polygon. The red part is another set of exterior angles of that. If we take off the red and green part of each circle, the area of yellow part and blue part will be the same because the angle of these equal parts are vertical angles on two intersect straight lines. The angles in the same circle of green and red part are also vertical angles and the red and green part will be the different parts between the blue and yellow area. Hope my poor English can help you understand the case. :)

Edward So - 3 years, 7 months ago

This is genious! I love the solution

Michael Borrello - 3 years, 7 months ago
Jonathan Quarrie
Oct 3, 2017

Relevant wiki: General Polygons - Angles

The total degrees in 10 circles: 360 0 3600^\circ

The interior angle of a decagon (the yellow area): 144 0 = 2 5 3600 1440^\circ = \color{#CEBB00}\dfrac{2}{5} \color{#333333}3600

The full external angle of a decagon (the blue area): 360 0 144 0 = 216 0 = 3 5 3600 3600^\circ - 1440^\circ = 2160^\circ = \color{#3D99F6}\dfrac{3}{5} \color{#333333}3600

There are 10 identical circles of radius 2 2 , creating a total area: 10 π × 2 2 = 40 π 10 \pi \times 2^2 = 40\pi

The blue area: B = 3 5 40 π = 24 π \color{#3D99F6}B\color{#333333} = \color{#3D99F6}\dfrac{3}{5} \color{#333333}40\pi = 24\pi

The yellow area: Y = 2 5 40 π = 16 π \color{#CEBB00}Y\color{#333333} = \color{#CEBB00}\dfrac{2}{5} \color{#333333}40\pi = 16\pi


B Y = k π \color{#3D99F6}B\color{#333333} - \color{#CEBB00}Y\color{#333333} = k\pi

24 π 16 π = 8 π 24\pi - 16\pi = \boxed{8}\pi

It does not matter, how many circles are externally tangent to each other.

The difference in areas in such an arrangement will always be 2 pi r^2

Vijay Simha - 3 years, 8 months ago

Log in to reply

That is an interesting observation. Can we prove it?

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago

Nice and interesting problem.I have my solution here. Before that I made calculation mistake. Let the interior angles of the decagon are i1, i2,… , i10, The green area B=[( i1+ i2+,… +i10)/360] 4π. The blue area A = 4π. [10 (3600) - ( i1+ i2+,… +i10)]/(360)
A – B = 4π. [10 (3600) - 2 ( i1+ i2+,… +i10)]/(360) = 4π. [10 (3600) - 2 ( 8(180)]/(360) = 8π

rab gani - 3 years, 8 months ago

the average angle inside the yellow is .8PI the total angle of a circle is 2PI hence the blue is 1.2PI. the positive difference is .4PI. the total area is 40PI. the differential area is therefore 40PI x .4PI / 2PI= 8PI

Trevor Ponniah - 3 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

What does average mean here?

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago
Mike Davison
Oct 16, 2017

Relevant wiki: General Polygons - Area

The sum of interior angles equals 1440°

Sum of the exterior angles equals 2160°

This gives a ratio of blue:red = 2160:1440 = 6:4

Total area of circles = 10 × pi × 2^2 or 40 × pi.

So blue area = 24 pi, and yellow area = 16 pi.

24 - 16 = 8

How did we calculate these interior angles?

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago
Antoine G
Oct 16, 2017

Relevant wiki: Polygon triangulation / Grids

The sum of interior and exterior degrees do not depend on the shape (you can see this by triangulating). So put the circles in two rows of 5 so that the resulting polygon is a rectangle. 6 circles are then cut in half (so they do not contribute to the difference). The remaining 4 circles are 1/4 in and 3/4 out: a difference of 1/2 each. So the difference is in total 4 1 2 = 2 4 \cdot \tfrac{1}{2} =2 circles. The Area of two circles is 2 π 2 2 = 8 π 2 \cdot \pi \cdot 2^2 = 8 \pi .

Peter Hauge
Oct 20, 2017

The arrangement is not quantitatively specified, implying the answer is invariant.

Arrange them in a 4x3 rectangle with two center circles removed; connect their centers. Six of the circles are bisected, contributing zero to the area difference. The other four are quartered, contributing 1/2 of their area to the difference. Four half-areas totals 8 pi.

This is a nice hack. How do we prove that the answer is invariant, though?

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago
Kyle Proctor
Oct 18, 2017

I imagined moving the balls into a 2-across by 5 deep pattern (still all touching at their radii) such that the center 3 pairs were cut in half, and the outer 4 (2 on top and 2 on the bottom) were sectioned into 1/4 yellow and 3/4 blue. Then, the center 3 pairs cancel out having equal area blue and yellow, and the outer 4 having total area equal to 4 pi, pi of which is yellow, and 3 pi of which is blue. (3 pi - pi) * 4 = 8 pi, thus k = 8

So, your solution was basically by assuming that the decagon is actually a rectangle? This approach is fine, except that you'd have to show that moving the balls around preserves angles.

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago
Gregory Lewis
Oct 16, 2017

The number of circles doesn't matter. You can follow a path through the circles, and every time that path changes direction, the difference between the yellow and blue areas is a wedge of twice the angle of the change in direction. The total of all the changes in radians is τ. So the wedges add up to 2τ (or 2 complete circles.) With a radius of 2, that's 4τ, or 8π.

Paul Muren
Oct 16, 2017

Imagine that each circle begins evenly split between blue and yellow.

Each circle must "give up" degrees to contribute to the total 360° that will be the sum of the yellow polygon's exterior angles.

Because there are 10 circles, each circle must give up an average of 36°.

For each circle, contributing these 36° also means converting 10% of its yellow area to blue area.

So, on average, circles must be 40% yellow and 60% blue by area.

That is, the average difference between blue and yellow area in each circle will be 20% of the circle's area.

20% * 4π * 10 = 8π

This is the most beautiful elegant solution imho :)

John Boyd - 3 years, 7 months ago
Aldo Voogt
Oct 22, 2017

Each circle has an area of 4PI. Rearrange the circles in a 2x5configuration. Each of the 6 circles NOT at a corner has equal blue and yellow areas, so the difference is 0. The remaining 4 circles at a corner have 3PI blue an 1PI yellow for a difference of 2PI each. 4x2PI=8PI.

Aldus Botha
Oct 21, 2017
  • // Java solution for any number of circles:
  • int circles = 10;
  • int radius = 2;
  • // PI not included so devision later is not required.
  • double circleSurface = Math.pow(radius, 2);
  • double removedSurface = (circleSurface / 2) - circleSurface / circles;
  • double remainingSurface = circleSurface - removedSurface;
  • double blue = remainingSurface * circles;
  • double yellow = removedSurface * circles;
  • double k = blue - yellow;

Does this code compile?

Agnishom Chattopadhyay - 3 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

Copied it after running it.

Aldus Botha - 3 years, 7 months ago
Aleksander Lund
Oct 18, 2017

Doing a displacement of the cirles so that they are aranged ind two lines of 4 circles, we can pair the four edges in pairs of two of Pi each. Then we see that the rest of the circles have yellow area of Pi each. Those are 6 circles not cornered, and 2 pairs of corners. Which sums up to 8 Pi. You can expand this to a general solution of k circles being (k-2)*Pi

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...