Flaneur in the rain - i

Suppose you're sauntering about Saint-Germain, Paris, from one cafe to the next, staying only as long as it takes you to knock down a few Brilliant problems. You're wrapping up at Brasserie Lipp and want to go to Cafè de Flore, which is across the road.

The only problem is: it's pouring rain!

If you want to make it from one cafe to the next while staying as dry as possible, how should you move?

Details

  • v r v_r and v w v_w are the speeds at which you can run or walk across the road, respectively, with v w < v r v_w < v_r .
Run across the road, face forward at speed v r v_r . It depends on what you're wearing on your head and body, and how well they each absorb water. Walk across the road at speed v w < v r v_w < v_r Shuffle across the road, shoulder forward at speed v r v_r .

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Josh Silverman Staff
May 25, 2014

A common misconception about this puzzle is that running quickly through the rain causes the runner to collect more rain on the front of their body. In fact this is not the case.

For both the vertical (head), and horizontal (body) rain collection, the runner simply collects the amount of water that exists in a rectangular prism whose dimensions are given by the details of their motion.

Head

The dimensions of the rectangular prism that is incident on the head of the runner is simply given by the cross sectional area of the head, times the velocity of the falling water, times the amount of time the runner is exposed to the rain. I.e. if the runner stands still in the rain for t 0 t_0 seconds, and the rain falls at v rain v_\text{rain} , a rectangular column of height v rain t 0 v_\text{rain}t_0 will fall on their head. In crossing the road, the runner spends d / v 0 d/v_0 seconds in the rain, in which time they collect an amount of water ρ A head v rain d / v 0 \rho A_\text{head}v_\text{rain}d/v_0 on their head. Clearly, this quantity can be reduced by increasing the velocity with which one crosses the road.

Body

Following the argument above, we can see that the runner moves through a rectangular prism of dimensions A body d A_\text{body}d . Notice that this has no dependence on the velocity of the runner, the speed of the falling rain, or anything else that can be changed by walking at differing speeds. The only parameter that can be modified is the cross sectional area that the body presents to the direction of motion, A body A_\text{body} . By shifting the body by π / 2 \pi/2 , the runner presumably slims his profile relative to the rain and therefore collects a smaller amount of water.

All together

Putting these together, we see that in crossing the road, a runner will collect a mass of water given by

m w = ρ d ( A body + A head v rain v 0 ) m_w = \rho d\left(A_\text{body} + A_\text{head}\frac{v_\text{rain}}{v_0}\right)

Which can be reduced by minimizing A body A_\text{body} and maximizing v 0 v_0 .

You presented this to me many years ago, I thought you had taught me running = wetter. One day I will be dry, just not today.

Moses Smith - 7 years ago

Ohhhh, that's what it meant, I totally mis-interpreted the choice.?

Beakal Tiliksew - 7 years ago

Shuffling is inherently slower than running, thus more time would be spend absorbing rain. V0 would be lowered significantly while Abody would only be halved if one were to shuffle as opposed to openly running.

Anthony Tran - 6 years, 9 months ago

Could you explain to me the difference between

"Shuffle across the road, shoulder forward."

and

"Run across the road, face forward."?

I am not a native speaker and only missed this one because of not having a clue of the difference between these two =S.

Shoulder forward? What is that supposed to mean?

Bernardo Sulzbach - 6 years, 11 months ago

Loved the way you explained it .Really appreciable solution !!

Ayaan Kudo - 3 years ago

why is density multiplied to the amount of water falling on head twice in the last equation?once we take density as a common factor why is there an additional density term?

Balagopal Indiradevi - 7 years ago

Log in to reply

good point, that's a mistake.

Josh Silverman Staff - 7 years ago

fast moving cause collection of more rain

Jalees Mughal - 6 years, 10 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...