If provided s + e + a = 0 and a function f is defined as f ( c ) = c s + c − e + 1 1 + c e + c − a + 1 1 + c a + c − s + 1 1 .
Find the derivative of f ( c ) at c = π .
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
f
(
c
)
=
c
s
+
c
−
e
+
1
1
+
c
e
+
c
−
a
+
1
1
+
c
a
+
c
−
s
+
1
1
f
′
(
c
)
=
(
c
s
+
c
−
e
+
1
)
2
−
1
(
s
c
s
−
1
−
e
c
−
e
−
1
)
+
(
c
e
+
c
−
a
+
1
)
2
−
1
(
e
c
e
−
1
−
a
c
−
a
−
1
)
+
(
c
a
+
c
−
s
+
1
)
2
−
1
(
a
c
a
−
1
−
s
c
−
s
−
1
)
Because answer is independent of c,s,a
Assuming
e = s = a = 0
f
′
(
π
)
=
(
π
0
+
π
0
+
1
)
2
−
1
(
0
×
π
0
−
1
−
0
×
π
0
−
1
)
+
(
π
0
+
π
0
+
1
)
2
−
1
(
0
×
π
0
−
1
−
0
×
π
0
−
1
)
+
(
π
0
+
π
0
+
1
)
2
−
1
(
0
×
π
0
−
1
−
0
×
π
0
−
1
)
f
′
(
π
)
=
0
It would be better to make the observation that f ( x ) is a constant, and hence f ′ ( x ) = 0 . This is a common setup in olympiad problems.
does it work for all values of e,s,and a?and if yes why? i took e=-2,s=1,a=1 and i got about -.1 its probably because i did a mistake in the calculation but i couldnt find it
thanks
Log in to reply
Yes,you can take any arbitarary e,s,a in which given function is defined.
Log in to reply
thanks and @Taufik Hakiki s proof made it clearer too
@Calvin Lin , In competitive exams like Jee , our main aim is to choose the correct option from the given options. So,Is it correct approach for quick solving ?
Log in to reply
My point is that, it is much easier to see that f ( x ) = 1 rather than to find f ′ ( x ) .
With reference to your comment, I do not care about "All I want is the final correct answer". You might as well say "I answered 0 and you said I was correct, so I am correct". There is very little understanding in such an approach. Sure, you can use it to guess what the correct answer should be, but after that you should substantiate your conjecture especially if you intend to present a solution and ask the challenge masters to review it.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
We note that, c s + c − e + 1 1 + c e + c − a + 1 1 = c s + e + c e + 1 c e + c e + c − a + 1 1 = c e + c − a + 1 c e + 1 ( 1 ) . Because s + e = − a . Next, since − s = e + a ) , c a + c − s + 1 1 = c a + c e + a + 1 1 = c a + c e c a + 1 1 ( 2 ) . If we multiply ( 2 ) by c − a c − a , then ( 2 ) become c a + c − s + 1 1 = c a + c e + a + 1 1 c − a c − a = c e + c − a + 1 c − a ( 3 ) . Summing up ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) , we have f ( c ) = c e + c − a + 1 c e + c − a + 1 = 1 . Hence f ′ ( c ) = 0 at c = π .