Getting back to the old things #6

A solid body of mass M M is in the shape of a quadrant sphere of radius R R . It is released from rest in a position such that the curved portion is at a height R R .

The collision is perfectly elastic. The angular velocity of the body just after striking the ground is represented in the form a b c g R \dfrac{a}{b} \sqrt{\frac{cg}{R}} , where g g represents acceleration due to gravity. Here a a and b b are coprime positive integers and c c is square free.

Submit your answer as a + b + c a+b+c .


The answer is 325.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Mark Hennings
Jun 22, 2017

The quarter sphere has its axis horizontal, and can be defined in polar coordinates by the inequalities 0 r R 1 2 π θ π 1 2 π ϕ 1 2 π 0 \le r \le R \hspace{1cm} \tfrac12\pi \le \theta \le \pi \hspace{1cm} -\tfrac12\pi \le \phi \le \tfrac12\pi Assume that the sphere has uniform density and total mass M M , then the centre of mass G G of the quarter sphere now has coordinates ( c , 0 , c ) (c,0,-c) , where c = 3 8 R c = \tfrac38R . If I ^ \hat{I} is the moment of inertia of the quarter sphere about the y y -axis, then I ^ = 2 5 M R 2 \hat{I} \; = \; \tfrac25MR^2 since this is just the moment of inertia of a slice of a sphere about its diameter (we have one quarter of a whole sphere, but also one quarter of the mass of a whole sphere, so the formula for the moment of inertia is the same as that of a whole sphere).

If the centre of mass of the quarter sphere is moving downwards with speed V V just before the collision, and is moving downwards with speed W W just after the collision, and if the quarter sphere also has angular velocity ω \omega after the collision, having received an impulse of J J from the floor, then we have the impulsive equations of motion: M W = M V J J c = I ω MW \; = \; MV - J \hspace{2cm} Jc \; = \; I\omega where I I is the moment of inertia of the quarter sphere about the axis passing through the centre of mass G G which is parallel to the y y -axis. Then the loss of kinetic energy during the collision is Δ T = 1 2 M V 2 1 2 M W 2 1 2 I ω 2 = 1 2 M V 2 1 2 M W 2 1 2 M ( V W ) c ω = 1 2 M ( V W ) ( V + W c ω ) \begin{aligned} \Delta T & = \tfrac12MV^2 - \tfrac12MW^2 - \frac12I\omega^2 \; = \; \tfrac12MV^2 - \tfrac12MW^2 - \tfrac12M(V-W)c\omega \\ & = \tfrac12M(V-W)(V+W - c\omega) \end{aligned} Since the collision is perfectly elastic, Δ T = 0 \Delta T = 0 , and hence V + W = c ω V + W = c\omega . Thus I ω = J c = M c ( V W ) = M c ( 2 V c ω ) ( I + M c 2 ) ω = 2 M V c \begin{aligned} I\omega & = Jc \; = \; Mc(V-W) \; = \; Mc(2V - c\omega) \\ (I + Mc^2)\omega & = 2MVc \end{aligned} By the Parallel Axes Theorem, I ^ = I + 2 M c 2 \hat{I} = I + 2Mc^2 , so we deduce that I + M c 2 = I ^ M c 2 = 2 5 M R 2 9 64 M R 2 = 83 320 M R 2 I + Mc^2 \; = \; \hat{I} - Mc^2 \; = \; \tfrac25MR^2 - \tfrac{9}{64}MR^2 \; =\; \tfrac{83}{320}MR^2 and so ω = 2 M V c I + m c 2 = 2 M V c × 320 83 M R 2 = 640 V c 83 R 2 = 240 V 83 R \begin{aligned} \omega & = \frac{2MVc}{I + mc^2} \; = \; 2MVc \times \frac{320}{83MR^2} \; = \; \frac{640Vc}{83R^2} \; = \; \frac{240 V}{83 R} \end{aligned} Finally, V = 2 g R V = \sqrt{2gR} , and so ω = 240 83 2 g R \omega \; = \; \frac{240}{83}\sqrt{\frac{2g}{R}} making the answer 240 + 83 + 2 = 325 240 + 83 + 2 = \boxed{325} .

@Joe Wsp Therapper please post your solution.

Please address my latest report...

I suspect that the (incorrect) argument might go:

  • The velocity of the point of impact changes from V V to V -V , which represents a change of 2 M V × 3 8 R = 3 4 M V R 2MV\times\tfrac38R = \tfrac34MVR of angular momentum about the centre of mass.
  • The moment of inertia of a quarter sphere is one quarter the the moment of inertia of a whole sphere, and so it 1 4 × 2 5 M R 2 = 1 10 M R 2 \tfrac14 \times \tfrac25MR^2 = \tfrac{1}{10}MR^2 .
  • Dividing these two, the change in angular momentum brings about an angular velocity of 15 V 2 R = 15 2 2 g R \frac{15V}{2R} = \tfrac{15}{2}\sqrt{\tfrac{2g}{R}} . This would give an answer of 19 19 .

However:

  • the change in velocity of the point of contact is brought about by an impulse which alters the speed of the centre of mass of the object as well as the angular velocity of the object - we need to consider the change in velocity relative to the centre of mass,
  • the MoI of a quarter sphere is one quarter of the MoI of a sphere - true. But the mass of a quarter sphere is one quarter of the mass of a sphere, and so the formula for the MoI of a quarter sphere is 2 5 M R 2 \tfrac25MR^2 .
  • added to this, this MoI is about the axis passing along the diameter of the quarter sphere, and is not the MoI about the correct axis.

@Calvin Lin

Mark Hennings - 3 years, 11 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...