Heating water

A resistor of resistance R R is connected to a power supply of constant EMF E = 12 V \mathcal{E}=12~\mbox{V} and internal resistance r = 3 Ω r=3~\Omega . The energy dissipated in the resistor R R is used to heat water. What resistance R R in Ohms gives the maximum power dissipated in the resistor?


The answer is 3.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

9 solutions

Albert Han
May 20, 2014

Since the resistor is in series with the battery, the equation

ε = I ( R + r ) \varepsilon = I (R+r)

can be created.

Then, we can express the current I I as

I = ε r + R I = \frac {\varepsilon} {r+R} .

Then, since

P = I V = I 2 R P = IV = I^{2}R ,

we can substitute I I to ε r + R \frac {\varepsilon} {r+R} by using the previous equation, to show P P , which shows the amount of power the resistor dissipated to the surroundings, can be represented as a function of R R since ε \varepsilon and r r are constant.

Then,

P = ( ε r + R ) 2 R = ε 2 R ( r + R ) 2 = 144 R ( 3 + R ) 2 P = ( \frac {\varepsilon} {r+R} )^2 R = \frac {\varepsilon^2 R} {(r+R)^2} = \frac {144R} {(3+R)^2} .

After this point, if you do not know calculus, you can simply graph this equation into a calculator and find the maximum point. Then, the answer is 3.000 Ω 3.000 \Omega .

If you know calculus, you can differentiate this equation. To find the maximum power, we have to search the point where the value of d P d R \frac {dP} {dR} must be zero or undefined. Then, by using the quotient rule,

d P d R = ( 3 + R ) 2 ( 144 ) 144 R ( 2 ( 3 + R ) ) ( 3 + R ) 4 = 144 ( R 2 9 ) ( 3 + R ) 4 = 144 ( R 3 ) ( 3 + R ) 3 \frac {dP} {dR} = \frac {(3+R)^2 (144) - 144R(2(3+R))} {(3+R)^4} = \frac {-144 (R^2 - 9)} { (3+R)^4} = \frac {-144 (R-3)} {(3+R)^3} .

Then, the only points where P P is zero or undefined is when R = 3 R = 3 , R = 3 R = -3 , or R = R= \infty However, since the resistance cannot be negative, the only possible critical point is when R = 3 R=3 , R = 0 R = 0 , and R = R = \infty (0 can be a critical point since it is the endpoint of the interval of the resistance value, [ 0 , ) [0 , \infty) .

However, the R = 0 R =0 and R = R = \infty are local minima, and the absolute maximum point is when R = 3 R=3 .

Therefore, the resistance R R in Ohms that gives the maximum power dissipated in the resistor is when R = 3.000 Ω R=3.000 \Omega .

Very nicely done!

David Mattingly Staff - 7 years ago

The current through the load resistor is given by:

i = E r + R i = \frac{E}{r+R}

So, power dissipated in the load resistance is

P = i 2 R = ( E r + R ) 2 R P = i^2 R = (\frac{E}{r+R})^2 R

Now since for a particular source,the EMF E E & the internal resistance r r of the source are constant, P P depends on the value of R only,as asked in the problem, & P P is maximum when

d P d R = 0 \frac{dP}{dR} = 0

or, E 2 [ ( r + R ) 2 2 R ( r + R ) ( r + R ) 4 ] = 0 E^2 [\frac{(r+R)^2 - 2R(r+R)}{(r+R)^4}] = 0

or, ( r + R ) 2 2 R ( r + R ) = 0 (r+R)^2 - 2R(r+R) = 0

or, ( r + R ) ( r R ) = 0. (r+R)(r-R) = 0.

As ( r + R ) 0 (r+R) \neq 0 ,hence r = R r=R .

Back to our problem, R = r = 3 R = r = 3 ohm.

John Chaddock
May 20, 2014

Consider a battery, with EMF ε \varepsilon and internal resistance r r . The battery is connected to a resistor. If the current drawn is I I , and the resistance of the connected resistor is R R , the voltage across the battery, and thus the resistor, V V , is given by the followng equation:

V = ε I r V=\varepsilon-Ir -- (1)

Also, if the voltage across the resistor is V V , and the current drawn by the resistor is I I , the power drawn by the resistor, P P , is given by:

P = I V P=IV -- (2)

By substituting (1) into (2):

P = I ( ε I r ) P=I(\varepsilon-Ir) -- (3)

By expanding (3), an equation relating the power dissipated by a resistor to the current flowing through that resistor can be found:

P = ε I I 2 r P=\varepsilon I-I^2r -- (4)

To find what resistance gives the maximum power from a resistor, we need to find what volatge and current maximises power. By inspection, we can see that (4) is a negative quadratic of current. This means that the only place where d P d I \frac {dP}{dI} is zero, is also the point at which power is at its greatest. Differentiating (4):

d P d I = ε 2 I r \frac {dP}{dI}=\varepsilon-2Ir -- (5)

Substituting the values given in the question into (5), and setting d P d I \frac {dP}{dI} to zero gives:

0 = 12 ( 2 × 3 ) I 0=12-(2 \times 3)I

Thus giving a maximum current of 2 A 2A . By substituting this current, and the values given in the question into (1), the voltage that this current occurs at can be found:

V = 12 2 × 3 V=12-2 \times 3

Thus giving a maximum voltage of 6 V 6V . By using the fact that V = I R V=IR , R R can be found.

R = V I = 6 2 = 3 Ω R=\frac {V}{I}=\frac {6}{2}=3\Omega

We know that V=IR. V=12 Volts and the equivalent resistance is R+3. P=\frac {I^2} {R}. I=\frac {12}{3+R}.So P=\frac {144R]{(R+3)^2}. So now we take the derivative of P with respect to R to get \frac {dP}{dR} = \frac {(R^2+6R+9)144-144R(2R+6)}{(R+3)^4}=\frac {-144(R^2-9)}{(R+3)^4}. Now we set that equal to 0 to get \frac {-144(R^2-9)}{(R+3)^4}=0 \rightarrow -144(R^2-9)=0 \rightarrow R^2-9=0 \rightarrow R^2=9 \rightarrow R=3.

Tan Gian Yion
May 20, 2014

We know that the internal resistance of r= 3 Ohms. Therefore,

d P d R \frac{dP}{dR}

= d I 2 R d R \frac{dI^{2}R}{dR}

= d d R V 2 R ( R + r ) 2 \frac{d}{dR} \frac{V^{2}R}{(R + r)^{2}}

= V 2 d d R R ( R + r ) 2 V^{2} \frac{d}{dR} \frac{R}{(R + r)^{2}}

= V 2 ( R + r ) 2 2 R ( R + r ) ( R + r ) 4 = 0 V^{2} \frac{(R + r)^{2} - 2R( R + r )}{(R + r)^{4}} = 0

Hence, from the numerator we can simplify the equation into

R 2 + 2 R r + r 2 2 R 2 2 R r = 0 R^{2} +2Rr + r^{2} - 2R^{2} - 2Rr = 0

r 2 R 2 = 0 r^{2}-R^{2} = 0

( r + R ) ( r R ) = 0 (r+R)(r-R) = 0

Since resistance cannot have a negative value, r R = 0 r-R=0

R = r = 3 O h m s R= r = 3 Ohms

Vitaly Breyev
May 20, 2014

This is a straightforward application of the maximum power theorem that states that maximum power transfer in a purely resistive circuit occurs when R = r. For the derivation see wikipedia , for example.

David Mattingly Staff
May 13, 2014

The power dissipated in the resistor R R (load) can be expressed as P = I 2 R P=I^{2}R where I I is current. This current can be found using Ohm's Law. It is simply the source voltage E \mathcal{E} over the total resistance r + R r+R . Thus the power-resistance dependence is given by the following function: P ( R ) = E 2 R ( r + R ) 2 . P(R)= {\mathcal{E}}^{2}\frac{R}{(r+R)^{2}}. The first derivative can be easily computed: d P d R = E 2 r R ( r + R ) 3 . \frac{dP}{dR}={\mathcal{E}}^{2}\frac{r-R}{(r+R)^{3}.} From this expression we see that the function P ( R ) P(R) has a critical point at R = r = 3 Ω R=r=3~\Omega , so this point is either a maximum or minimum. Substituting back into the original expression for the power we see that it is indeed a maximum.

Abanoub Hanna
May 20, 2014

from Maximum Power Transfer Theorem in order to get the maximum power dissipated in the resistor

the resistor must equal the internal resistance

proof:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum power transfer theorem#Calculus-based proof for purely resistive circuits

Jiahai Feng
May 20, 2014

The Maximum Power Transfer Theorem basically states that to obtain the maximum power, a resistor must have the same resistance as the internal resistance of the circuit. As such, the answer is simply the given internal resistance r = 3 Ω r = 3Ω . For the proof for this theorem, you can refer to this wikipedia article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum power transfer theorem#Calculus-based proof for purely resistive circuits

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...