How many fractions make 3/2018?

1 a + 1 b = 3 2018 \large \frac{1}{a}+\frac{1}{b}=\frac{3}{2018}

Find the number of all ordered pairs of integers ( a , b ) (a,b) , such that a b > 0 a \geq b \gt 0 .


The answer is 3.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Jordan Cahn
Jan 8, 2019

There is a relevant theorem by the Czech mathematician P. Bartoš. I'm having trouble finding the original 1970 paper containing the theorem, but it's Theorem 3 in this paper. The theorem states (rephrased):

Given m / n m/n with 1 m n 1\leq m\leq n and gcd ( m , n ) = 1 \gcd(m,n)=1 , ( x , y ) (x,y) is a positive integer solution to the equation 1 x + 1 y = m n \frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y} = \frac{m}{n} if and only if there exist f 1 , f 2 Z + f_1,f_2\in\mathbb{Z}^+ such that f 1 f 2 = n 2 f_1f_2=n^2 , x = n + f 1 m x=\frac{n+f_1}{m} and y = n + f 2 m y=\frac{n+f_2}{m} (and both of these are integers).

Applying this theorem to the case of m = 3 m=3 and n = 2018 n=2018 , we get that f 1 f 2 = 201 8 2 = 2 2 100 9 2 f_1f_2=2018^2=2^2\cdot1009^2 . This leaves five possibilities (up to the order of f 1 f_1 and f 2 f_2 ):

(1) f 1 = 1 f_1=1 and f 2 = 2 2 100 9 2 f_2=2^2\cdot1009^2
(2) f 1 = 2 f_1=2 and f 2 = 2 100 9 2 f_2=2\cdot 1009^2
(3) f 1 = 1009 f_1=1009 and f 2 = 2 2 1009 f_2=2^2\cdot1009
(4) f 1 = 2 2 f_1=2^2 and f 2 = 100 9 2 f_2=1009^2
(5) f 1 = f 2 = 2 1009 f_1=f_2=2\cdot 1009


Those cases for which both f 1 + 2018 f_1+2018 and f 2 + 2018 f_2+2018 are divisible by 3 3 will be our solutions. 2018 2 m o d 3 2018\equiv 2\bmod 3 , so we are looking for f 1 f 2 1 m o d 3 f_1\equiv f_2\equiv 1\bmod 3 . These are cases (1), (3), and (4) above. So there are 3 \boxed{3} solutions.


We can verify that these cases yield solutions, if desired.

(1) x = 1 + 2018 3 = 673 x=\frac{1+2018}{3} = 673 and y = 2 2 100 9 2 + 2018 3 = 1358114 y=\frac{2^2\cdot1009^2+2018}{3} = 1358114 1 673 + 1 1358114 = 3 2018 \frac{1}{673}+\frac{1}{1358114} = \frac{3}{2018} (3) x = 1009 + 2018 3 = 1009 x=\frac{1009+2018}{3} = 1009 and y = 2 2 1009 + 2018 3 = 2018 y=\frac{2^2\cdot1009+2018}{3} = 2018 1 1009 + 1 2018 = 3 2018 \frac{1}{1009}+\frac{1}{2018} = \frac{3}{2018} (4) x = 2 2 + 2018 3 = 674 x=\frac{2^2+2018}{3} = 674 and y = 100 9 2 + 2018 3 = 340033 y=\frac{1009^2+2018}{3} = 340033 1 674 + 1 340033 = 3 2018 \frac{1}{674}+\frac{1}{340033} = \frac{3}{2018}

Sathvik Acharya
Jan 9, 2019

Clearing the denominators and factorizing the equation gives 3 a b = 2018 ( a + b ) ( a 2018 3 ) ( b 2018 3 ) = 201 8 2 9 ( 3 a 2018 ) ( 3 b 2018 ) = 201 8 2 3ab=2018(a+b)\implies \left(a -\frac{2018}{3}\right)\left(b-\frac{2018}{3}\right)=\frac{2018^2}{9}\implies (3a-2018)(3b - 2018) = 2018^2 It it follows that { 3 a 2018 , 3 b 2018 } { { 1 , 201 8 2 } , { 4 , 100 9 2 } , { 1009 , 4036 } } , \{3a - 2018, 3b - 2018\} \in \big\{ \{1, 2018^2\}, \{4, 1009^2\}, \{1009, 4036\} \big\}, as the other three factorizations of 201 8 2 2018^2 do not give integers for a a and b b .

This gives us the solutions: { a , b } { { 673 , 673 2018 } , { 674 , 337 1009 } , { 1009 , 2018 } } . \{a, b\} \in \big\{ \{673, 673 \cdot 2018\}, \{674, 337 \cdot 1009\}, \{1009, 2018\} \big\}.

Note: This was the first problem on the 2018 Putnam test .

Joshua Lowrance
Jan 8, 2019

The solutions are ( 2018 , 1009 ) , ( 340033 , 674 ) (2018,1009), (340033,674) , and ( 1358114 , 673 ) (1358114,673) . First, I figured that there is no solution for where a = b a=b , and that b < 1346 b \lt 1346 . Solving for a a , you get that a = 2018 b 3 b 2018 a=\frac{2018b}{3b-2018} . If 3 b 2018 3b-2018 is a factor of 2018 2018 , a a is an integer. The only times when 3 b 2018 3b-2018 is a factor of 2018 2018 , and 3 b 2018 3b-2018 is positive (because a a cannot be negative) is when 3 b 2018 = 1 3b-2018=1 and 3 b 2018 = 1009 3b-2018=1009 , where b = 673 , 1009 b=673,1009 . Another way a a is an integer is if 3 b 2018 3b-2018 is a factor of b b or b 2 \frac{b}{2} or b 1009 \frac{b}{1009} (as 2018's factors are 2 and 1009). The only time this happens is when b = 674 b=674 and 3 b 2018 = 4 3b-2018=4 .

1 pending report

Vote up reports you agree with

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...