How many tuples? - Part 1

Let T T be a finite set of 7 7 elements. What is the number of 10 10 -tuples ( T 1 , T 2 , . . . , T 9 , T ) (T_1, T_2, ..., T_9, T) of sets T i T_i , such that T 1 T 2 . . . T 9 T ? T_1 \subset T_2 \subset ... \subset T_9 \subset T \quad ?


Note : the T i T_i may be empty. \\ Bonus : generalize. \\ Part 2? -> klick here ;) <-


The answer is 10000000.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Patrick Corn
May 7, 2021

If T T has a a elements and we want a chain of b b -tuples, the general answer is b a . b^a. In this case, that is 1 0 7 = 10000000 . 10^7 = \fbox{10000000}.

Here's a proof of the general fact. There is a bijection between the set of all such chains and the set of all functions F : T { 1 , , b } , F: T \to \{1, \ldots, b\}, as follows: given a chain satisfying the condition, let F ( t ) F(t) be the index of the first set in the chain in which t t appears. Note that this is well-defined, since every t t appears in the last set. I'll leave the proof that it's a bijection to you (given a function F , F, it's clear how to construct the chain that corresponds to F F ). The number of functions F : T { 1 , , b } F: T \to \{1, \ldots, b\} is just b a , b^a, since there are b b choices for the image of each of the a a elements of T . T. So there are b a b^a such chains.


(I must confess that my original proof was less elegant: Let f ( a , b ) f(a,b) be the number of b b =tuples satisfying the condition on a finite set of a a elements. Then clearly f ( a , 1 ) = 1 f(a,1) = 1 for all a . a. Now, suppose we choose T b 1 T_{b-1} of size k . k. There are ( a k ) \binom{a}{k} choices for such a set, and then the number of chains including T b 1 T_{b-1} as their penultimate element is just f ( k , b 1 ) . f(k,b-1). So we get the recursion f ( a , b ) = k = 0 a f ( k , b 1 ) ( a k ) . f(a,b) = \sum_{k=0}^a f(k,b-1) \binom{a}{k}. Now it's clear by induction that f ( a , b ) = b a , f(a,b) = b^a, since b a = k = 0 a ( b 1 ) k ( a k ) b^a = \sum\limits_{k=0}^a (b-1)^k \binom{a}{k} by the binomial theorem (and the base case is 1 a = 1 1^a = 1 for all a a ). But once I realized that the answer was b a , b^a, then it was just a matter of thinking about what combinatorial set had that cardinality and constructing the appropriate bijection. So the first proof is much better.)

Correct! Very nice :)

Simon Kaib - 1 month ago

I assumed this was a trick question and so indicated it as 0. What did I miss?

There are 7 elements in T (including an eighth when taking null set), 10-tuples of the set T_i where each is a subset previously to the next. By assuming subset, I assume that the elements in the prior subset is contained in the proceeding set and so on, where repeated elements cannot exist in the following subset and is unique per element ({1,2,3} == {3,1,2} for instance).

If T contains 8 elements, how is it possible to have 10-tuple sets based on the condition that i.e. {null, element 1, element 2} ->{null, element 1, 2 & 3)-> {null, 1,2,3, element 7}? Regardless of the permutations {null, 7 choose 1, 6 choose 1 etc..} wouldn't it just max out within 8 subsets and hence 8-tuples?

C Ho - 3 weeks, 1 day ago

Some of the T i T_i are allowed to be equal to each other.

Patrick Corn - 3 weeks, 1 day ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...