When a conical bottle rests on its flat base, the water in the bottle is 8 cm from the cone's vertex.
When the same conical bottle is turned upside down, the water surface is 2 cm from the flat base.
What is the height (in cm) of the bottle?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
General and nice simple approach
In the third sentence, did you mean V = k x 3 ?
Why the volume of the cone of height x is directly proportional to x^3?
Log in to reply
Volume V of any solid of a fixed shape is directly proportional to cube of its linear dimension x , that is V ∝ x 3 . Consider a cube of unit side length x = 1 , then V 1 = 1 3 = 1 , if x is increase to 2 , then V 2 = 8 , V 3 = 2 7 , ⟹ V n = n 3 . Therefore, volume of cube is directly proportional to x 3 . Now instead of x = 1 , let x → d x become infinitesimal, then V → d V . Note that any solid can be made up ∫ d V . When d x → n d x , d V → n 3 d V and the volume of the whole solid increases to n 3 times its original volume. Similarly, area A ∝ x 2 .
the solution is very good, what it doesnt make sense to me is tha you let x to be the distance of the cone vertex to the water surface, which means that as x decreases the volume increases.
Log in to reply
I said the volume of the cone (not water) is directly proportional to x 3 .
Let the conical bottle have a radius of r and a height of h . The volume of a cone is V = 3 1 π r 2 h .
The volume of the water in the right side up bottle is the difference of the volume of the whole cone and the volume of the cone of air (with a radius of r a and a height of 8 ), so V w = 3 1 π r 2 h − 3 1 π r a 2 8 . Since these two cones are similar, r r a = h 8 , and substituting this gives V w = 3 1 π r 2 h − 3 1 π ( h 8 r ) 2 8 .
The volume of the water in the upside down bottle is a cone (with a radius of r b and a height of h − 2 ), so V w = 3 1 π r b 2 ( h − 2 ) . Since this cone is similar to the conical bottle, r r b = h h − 2 , and substituting this gives V w = 3 1 π ( h ( h − 2 ) r ) 2 ( h − 2 ) .
Equating the two equations gives V w = 3 1 π r 2 h − 3 1 π ( h 8 r ) 2 8 = 3 1 π ( h ( h − 2 ) r ) 2 ( h − 2 ) , which simplifies to h 3 − 5 1 2 = ( h − 2 ) 3 , and solves to a positive solution of h = 1 + 8 5 ≈ 1 0 . 2 1 9 5 .
This also shows that if we replaced "8 and 2" (from the problem statement) with any other pair of positive integers, the answer cannot be an integer, as it contradicts Fermat's Last Theorem .
Log in to reply
where's the n > 2 ?
Log in to reply
The equation h 3 − 5 1 2 = ( h − 2 ) 3 (near the end) is equivalent to ( h − 2 ) 3 + 8 3 = h 3 , so when comparing it to Fermat's Last Theorem, the exponent is n = 3 , which is greater than 2 .
Since a cone's volume is proportional to its height cubed,
h
3
−
8
3
h
=
(
h
−
2
)
3
=
1
+
8
5
≈
1
0
.
2
1
9
5
cm
might be a stupid question but isn't (h-2)^3=h^3-6h^2+12h-8 ? h^3-8 should be (h-2)(h^2+2h+4)
Log in to reply
In my answer, my LHS is proportional to the 1 st shaded area (in the question), and my RHS is proportional to the 2 nd shaded area.
brilliant!
Key is that radius is propotional to height from the top (vertex). Setup the equation
h^3 - 8^3 = (h-2)^3 and solve.
Answer is h = 1+√85=10.219
Just take the volume of each cone and make them equal each other as they are the same cone. Then you get
h 3 − 8 3 = ( h − 2 ) 3
Solving for h you will get approximately 10.22
Let the volume of cone is v, and the volume of water w, and the height of the cone is h.Using similarity : (8/h)^3 = (v – w)/v, or (8/h)^3 = 1 – w/v, ....(1), for the left figure,and [(h – 2)/h]^3 = w/v .......(2), for right figure. Substitute eqs.(2) to eqs.(1), then we get, (8/h)^3 = 1 – [(h – 2)/h]^3, 8^3+(h-2)^3/h^3 = 1, h^2 – 3 h – 84 = 0, solving the quadratic equation, we get h=10.2195
I just added 8+2 and other people come up with these complicated equations xD
The answer is not 10.
Total cone volume=1/3 pi r^2(2+h)-----(1) Total cone volume=1/3 pi r^2(8+h1)-------(2) ratio=1 divide 1 &2 then h+2-h1-8=0 @ h=8 then h1=2 total height = 2+h=2+8=10 cm.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Let the distance from the cone vertex to the water surface be x . Then the volume of the cone of height x is directly proportional to x 3 . That is V ∝ x 3 or V = k v 3 , where k is a constant. Let the height of the conical bottle be h .
Then, the volume of water on flat base is V w = k h 3 − k ( 8 3 ) , and that when the bottle is turned upside down V w = k ( h − 2 ) 3 . Therefore,
k h 3 − k ( 8 3 ) h 3 − 5 1 2 6 h 2 − 1 2 h − 5 0 4 h 2 − 2 h − 8 4 h = k ( h − 2 ) 3 = h 3 − 6 h 2 + 1 2 h − 8 = 0 = 0 = 2 2 + 3 4 0 ≈ 1 0 . 2 1 9 5 Divide both sides by k Rearrange Divide both sides by 6 Solving the quadratic for h Note that h > 0