Hunt for that Region! 2.0

Geometry Level 5

As shown, A B = 45 , B C = 60 , A C = 75 AB=45, BC=60, AC=75 in A B C . \triangle ABC.

Find the area of the region enclosed by the traces of P P moving inside A B C , \triangle ABC, satisfying ( Area of P A B ) > ( Area of P B C ) > ( Area of P A C ) . (\text{Area of } \triangle PAB) > (\text{Area of } \triangle PBC) > (\text{Area of } \triangle PAC).

You can try a similiar problem here.

This is part of the set Things Get Harder! .


The answer is 225.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Nikola Yanakiev
Jun 8, 2018

Realizing that the given figure is a right triangle, we could solve the problem graphically quite easily. First we place the triangle in a cartesian coordinate system as so:

We pick a random point P = ( x , y ) P = (x, y) where x = P x x = P_x and y = P y y = P_y . From the illustration the mentioned areas could be written as:

S P A B = 45 y 2 S_{\triangle PAB} = \frac{45y}{2}

S P B C = 60 x 2 S_{\triangle PBC} = \frac{60x}{2}

S P A C = S A B C S P B C S P A B = 45 60 2 60 x 2 45 y 2 S_{\triangle PAC} = S_{\triangle ABC} - S_{\triangle PBC} - S_{\triangle PAB} = \frac{45*60}{2} - \frac{60x}{2} - \frac{45y}{2}

Rearranging and solving the given inequalities we get:

90 y > 45 60 60 x 2 x + 3 y > 90 90y > 45*60 - 60x \Rightarrow 2x + 3y > 90 ( 1 ) (1)

45 60 45 y < 120 x 8 x + 3 y > 180 45*60 - 45y < 120x \Rightarrow 8x + 3y > 180 ( 2 ) (2)

45 y > 60 x 3 y > 4 x 45y > 60x \Rightarrow 3y > 4x ( 3 ) (3)

Since both ( 1 ) (1) and ( 2 ) (2) are linear inequalities we could easily find their solutions on the coordinate system using the extreme cases. Consequently the region that satisfies ( 1 ) (1) is the area ( w i t h (with g r e e n ) \color{#20A900} green) above the line y = 2 3 x + 30 y = -\frac{2}{3} x + 30 , for ( 2 ) (2) it is the area ( w i t h (with o r a n g e ) \color{#EC7300} orange) under y = 8 3 x + 60 y = -\frac{8}{3} x + 60 , for ( 3 ) (3) - the p u r p l e \color{#69047E}purple region above line y = 4 x 3 y = \frac{4x}{3} .

It so happens that all three functions intersect at one point D. The region that we are looking for is C E D \triangle CED . We find the coordinates of point D by putting the functions of the aforementioned lines equal to each other :

2 3 x + 30 = 8 3 x + 60 2 x = 30 D = ( 15 , 20 ) -\frac{2}{3} x + 30 = -\frac{8}{3} x + 60 \Rightarrow 2x = 30 \Rightarrow D = (15, 20) .

Point E is the intersection between C A CA and y = 4 x 3 y = \frac{4x}{3} . Therefore the x coordinate of E is the solution to the equation 4 x 3 + 60 = 4 x 3 x E = 22.5 ; y E = 30 C E = 37.5 -\frac{4x}{3} + 60 = \frac{4x}{3} \Rightarrow x_E = 22.5; y_E = 30 \Rightarrow CE = 37.5 . The distance from point D to C A CA can be found using the already mentioned formulas for the three areas. It turns out to be equal to 12. Finally, we can calculate the formula using the formula C E 12 2 = 225 \frac{CE*12}{2} = 225

P.S. Looking into the illustration I've provided above, it turns out that the point D is the center of mass of the triangle. This gives insight into a more elegant solution to the problem. Let P be a random point in the triangle and C P B A = M CP \cap BA = M . The ratio between S P B C S_{\triangle PBC} and S P A C S_{\triangle PAC} is just B M M A \frac{BM}{MA} . In order for that to be greater than one (this is what the problem implies) point M has to be in the right half of BA. In other words every point on a line to the right of the median from point C provides us with a solution to one of the inequalities. Doing this for all medians/inequalities, the area in question once again turns out to be C E D \triangle CED . Using ratios S C E D = 1 2 S C D A = 1 2 2 3 S C N A S_{\triangle CED} = \frac{1}{2} * S_{\triangle CDA} = \frac{1}{2} * \frac{2}{3} * S_{\triangle CNA} (point N is the midpoint of BA) = 1 2 2 3 1 2 S C B A = 1 6 S C B A = 225. = \frac{1}{2} * \frac{2}{3} * \frac{1}{2} * S_{\triangle CBA} = \frac{1}{6} * S_{\triangle CBA} = 225.

Wow, linear programming. Bravo! I did not see that coming. Well done!

donglin loo - 3 years ago

@Nikola Yanakiev
Hold on. You might want to take a look at inequality 2. The inequality 2 you wrote corresponds to area of Δ P A C > \Delta PAC> area of Δ P B C \Delta PBC . Hope u would amend that a bit.

donglin loo - 3 years ago

Log in to reply

Thank you for your comment! The solution has now been fixed.

Nikola Yanakiev - 3 years ago
Donglin Loo
Jun 5, 2018

In the diagram above, point G G is defined such that area of Δ G A B = \Delta GAB= area of Δ G B C = \Delta GBC= area of Δ G A C \Delta GAC

The desired region is the green triangle Δ C G H \Delta CGH .

Area of Δ A B C = 45 60 2 = 1350 \Delta ABC=\cfrac{45\cdot60}{2}=1350

area of Δ G A B = \Delta GAB= area of Δ G B C = \Delta GBC= area of Δ G A C = 1350 3 = 450 \Delta GAC=\cfrac{1350}{3}=450

1 2 G F 45 = 1 2 G E 60 = 1 2 G J 75 = 450 \cfrac{1}{2}\cdot GF\cdot45=\cfrac{1}{2}\cdot GE\cdot60=\cfrac{1}{2}\cdot GJ\cdot75=450

G F = 20 GF=20 , G E = 15 GE=15 , G J = 12 GJ=12

E B F G EBFG is a rectangle.

E B = G F = 20 \therefore EB=GF=20

tan E B G = G E E B = 15 20 = 3 4 \tan \angle EBG=\cfrac{GE}{EB}=\cfrac{15}{20}=\cfrac{3}{4}

tan B C A = 45 60 = 3 4 \tan \angle BCA=\cfrac{45}{60}=\cfrac{3}{4}

G H J = E B G + B C A \angle GHJ=\angle EBG+\angle BCA

tan G H J = tan ( E B G + B C A ) = 3 4 + 3 4 1 ( 3 4 ) 2 = 3 2 7 16 = 3 2 16 7 = 24 7 \therefore \tan \angle GHJ=\tan (\angle EBG+\angle BCA)=\cfrac{\cfrac{3}{4}+\cfrac{3}{4}}{1-(\cfrac{3}{4})^2}=\cfrac{\cfrac{3}{2}}{\cfrac{7}{16}}=\cfrac{3}{2}\cdot\cfrac{16}{7}=\cfrac{24}{7}

tan G H J = G J H J = 24 7 \tan \angle GHJ=\cfrac{GJ}{HJ}=\cfrac{24}{7}

12 H J = 24 7 \cfrac{12}{HJ}=\cfrac{24}{7}

H J = 12 7 24 = 7 2 HJ=\cfrac{12\cdot7}{24}=\cfrac{7}{2}

C E + E B = C B CE+EB=CB

C E = 60 20 = 40 CE=60-20=40

By Pythagorean Theorem \textbf{Pythagorean Theorem} ,

C E 2 + G E 2 = C G 2 CE^2+GE^2=CG^2

G J 2 + C J 2 = C G 2 GJ^2+CJ^2=CG^2

C E 2 + G E 2 = G J 2 + C J 2 \therefore CE^2+GE^2=GJ^2+CJ^2

4 0 2 + 1 5 2 = C J 2 + 1 2 2 40^2+15^2=CJ^2+12^2

C J 2 = 4 0 2 + ( 1 5 2 1 2 2 ) = 4 0 2 + 9 2 = 4 1 2 CJ^2=40^2+(15^2-12^2)=40^2+9^2=41^2

C J = 41 CJ=41

C J = C H + H J CJ=CH+HJ

C H = 41 7 2 = 75 2 CH=41-\cfrac{7}{2}=\cfrac{75}{2}

\therefore Area of desired region = = Area of Δ C G H \Delta CGH = 1 2 75 2 12 = 225 =\cfrac{1}{2}\cdot\cfrac{75}{2}\cdot{12}=225

1 pending report

Vote up reports you agree with

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...