Icosahedron of Resistors

One of my first physics problems.

Each edge of an icosahedron is a 1­ Ω \Omega resistor. If the effective resistance between two adjacent vertices can be represented as a b Ω \frac {a}{b} \Omega where a a and b b are co-prime positive integers, find a + b a + b .

An icosahedron consists of 20 equilateral triangles. It has 12 vertices and 30 edges, with 5 edges meeting at each vertex.

Image credit: Wikipedia DTR


The answer is 41.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Michael Mendrin
Jul 10, 2014

I prefer systematic computations of these kinds of problems. Here, we have 12 12 nodes, and we can use Kirchhoff's circuit laws use the fact the net current at any node is 0 0 , so that we have 12 12 equations of the form ( v v being voltages, and resistors being 1 1 Ohm)

5 v a v b v c v d v e v f = 0 5{ v }_{ a }-{ v }_{ b }-{ v }_{ c }-{ v }_{ d }-{ v }_{ e }-{ v }_{ f }=0

except that for two of the nodes (vertices) in which we're trying to determine the effective resistance of the net, the equations are of the form

5 v 1 v b v c v d v e v f 1 R ( v 1 v 2 ) 5{ v }_{ 1 }-{ v }_{ b }-{ v }_{ c }-{ v }_{ d }-{ v }_{ e }-{ v }_{ f }-\frac { 1 }{ R } ({ v }_{ 1 }-{ v }_{ 2 })

where v 1 { v }_{ 1 } and v 2 { v }_{ 2 } are those two nodes, set at some arbitrary voltages differing by 1 1 and R R is the equivalent resistance of the icosahedron net. Solve for R R and find that it's 11 30 \dfrac { 11 }{ 30 } . You can find the effective resistance between other pairs of nodes in this fashion, the only 2 2 other possible resistance values being 7 15 \dfrac { 7 }{ 15 } and 1 2 \dfrac { 1 }{ 2 }

Can anyone post the solution using symmetry?

Tushar Gopalka - 6 years, 10 months ago

Very nice solution. :D

Sharky Kesa - 6 years, 11 months ago

Fantastic solution

Anil P Anil - 6 years, 10 months ago
Anupam Khandelwal
Jul 20, 2014

simply use the formula R=2(v-1)r/v.n where v- total vertices; n- no. of edges meeting a vertex; r- resistance of an edge; NOTE: one can use this formula to calculate equivalent resistance between any two adjacent vertices of a regular polyhedron

can u plz give derivation of that

parvatham charunya - 6 years, 10 months ago

Let vertices 1 1 and 2 2 be adjacent. Consider the setup where a current of 1 A 1A enters through vertex 1 1 , and a current 1 11 A \frac{1}{11}A leaves through the other 11 11 vertices. Note that, due to symmetry, a current 1 5 A \frac{1}{5}A flows through each of the 5 5 edges leaving vertex 1 1 . Hence, the voltage between vertices 1 1 and 2 2 is: V 1 V 2 = ( 1 5 A ) ( 1 Ω ) = 1 5 V V_{1} - V_{2} = ( \frac{1}{5} A)(1Ω) = \frac{1}{5}V Consider a second setup, where a current of 1 A 1A leaves through vertex 2 2 , and a current of 1 11 A \frac{1}{11}A enters through the other 11 11 vertices. Again, note that a current of 1 5 \frac{1}{5} A flows through each of the 5 5 edges entering vertex 2 2 . Hence, the voltage between vertices 1 1 and 2 2 is: V 1 V 2 = ( 1 5 A ) ( 1 Ω ) = 1 5 V V_{1} - V_{2} = ( \frac{1}{5} A)(1Ω) = \frac{1}{5}V Using the superposition principle we have:

  • A current of 12 11 A \frac{12}{11}A enters through vertex 1 1 ,
  • A current of 12 11 A \frac{12}{11}A leaves through vertex 2 2 ,
  • No current enters or leaves through the other 10 10 vertices, and
  • The voltage between vertices 1 1 and 2 2 is:

V 1 V 2 = 1 5 V + 1 5 V = 2 5 V V_{1} - V_{2} = \frac{1}{5}V + \frac{1}{5}V = \frac{2}{5}V We have constructed precisely the experimental setup that serves to determine the effective resistance between vertices 1 1 and 2 2 . That is, we have inserted a current at vertex 1 1 , taken it out at vertex 2 2 , and measured the voltage between the two points. The effective resistance between vertices 1 1 and 2 2 is therefore given by:

V = R I 2 5 V = ( R e f f ) ( 12 11 A ) R e f f = 11 30 Ω V = RI \longrightarrow \frac{2}{5}V = (R_{eff})(\frac{12}{11}A) \longrightarrow \boxed{R_{eff} = \frac{11}{30}Ω} a b = 11 30 a = 11 , b = 30 \frac{a}{b} = \frac{11}{30} \longrightarrow a = 11 , b = 30 a + b = 41 \large \boxed{a + b = 41}

Amazing !! Can you explain more about superposition principle ?

Akshat Sharda - 5 years, 4 months ago

My solution is here: https://pa1ejo.wordpress.com/2018/01/28/icosaeder-with-resistors/

Ejo Schrama - 3 years, 4 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...