I'm not speeding, officer!

Calculus Level 2

A motorist is driving down the freeway that has a speed limit of 60 60 MPH. The police car he passes at 10 : 30 10\text{:}30 AM records him as going 60 60 MPH, so he isn't pulled over. Two hours and 156 156 miles later, he passes another police car, again registering as traveling at 60 60 MPH, so once again he is not pulled over. At some point during the trip, was he speeding? If so, you know this due to which theorem?

Yes, Fermat's Theorem Yes, Mean Value Theorem No Yes, Intermediate Value Theorem

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Discussions for this problem are now closed

Bhagirath Mehta
May 5, 2014

The Mean Value Theorem as applied to the velocity of this function states that the average value of the velocity equals the instantaneous velocity of the function at some point, as long as the function is continuous and differentiable. If we take the car's position as our function, we can use the velocity to apply the Mean Value Theorem. The car's average velocity was equal to 156 miles/2 hours = 78 mph. Therefore, at some point, the car had to be traveling at least at that speed, if not more, meaning that the car was definitely speeding in the distance between the two police cars.

Colin Tang
May 10, 2014

Let us assume for the sake of contradiction that the car's velocity was never greater than 60 miles per hour. Then, integrating the car's velocity over the two hours between 10 : 30 AM 10:30 \text{AM} and 12 : 30 PM 12:30 \text{PM} , we find that the car's displacement is never greater than ( 2 hours ) ( 60 miles hour ) = 120 miles (2 \text{hours})(60 \frac{\text{miles}}{\text{hour}}) = 120 \text{miles} . However, we are given that the car's displacement is 156 miles, which is clearly greater than 120 miles. Therefore, our initial assumption is false and the car at one point was speeding.

Eshan Abbas
May 13, 2014

Since in two hours, the car traveled 156 miles, the average speed in these 2 hours is 156/2= 78 miles. This is higher than the speed limit. Therefore, at some point, the car was speeding between the two police cars, though it may be at more than 1 point.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...