Incoming electrons

Choose coordinates x x and y y on a horizontal 2-d graphene sheet. We will inject electrons into the sheet from the origin O O such that they enter the upper half-plane ( y > 0 y>0 ) but the direction is otherwise totally random. The speed of electrons in graphene is v F v_F , and the mass of each electron is m m .

We now put an electron detector along the x x -axis ( y = 0 y=0 ) and apply an external magnetic field B 0 B_0 perpendicular to the plane (parallel with the z z -axis). At what value of x x in meters will the detector receive the greatest signal?

Assume that every electron that goes to the lower half plane ( y < 0 y<0 ) will disappear (for example, the lower half plane is made of a special material which absorbs electrons).

Details and assumptions

To make the problem numerically simpler, use the following values for your calculation:

  • v F = 1 m/s v_F=1~\mbox{m/s}

  • m = 1 kg m=1~\mbox{kg}

  • B 0 = 1 T B_0=1~\mbox{T}

  • The electron charge is e = 1 C e=1~\mbox{C} .


The answer is 2.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Nguyen Tuan
May 20, 2014

Since the magnetic field B 0 B_0 is in the z direction, every electron will enter a circular path with radius of r = B 0 e m v F = 1 × 1 1 × 1 = 1 r= \frac {B_0e} {mv_F} = \frac {1 \times 1} {1\times 1} = 1 . Let this path be P θ P_\theta where θ \theta is the angle that an electron made with the x-axis when entering the plane.

The initial direction is tangential to the circular path and so is perpendicular to the radius of the path at the origin O O . Therefore, the center of path P θ P_\theta , let's call it C θ C_\theta is at a polar coordinate ( r , θ ) (r,\theta) , in which r r is the distance from origin O O and θ \theta is the angle measured from positive y-axis.

We now determine the position, x θ x_\theta , which this electron meets x-axis the second time (first time is when it is injected at origin O O ). Since electron goes in circular path, the center C θ C_\theta , origin O O , and x θ x_\theta , these 3 points make up a isosceles triangle. Thus, the distance x θ x_\theta from O O is x θ = 2 r sin θ x_\theta=2r\sin\theta . Looking at the graph of function sin θ \sin \theta for 0 θ 18 0 0^\circ \leq \theta \leq 180 ^ \circ , these electrons will be most concentrated when d d θ sin θ = 0 \frac {d} {d\theta} \sin \theta=0 , which yields θ = 9 0 \theta = 90 ^ \circ .

Substitute, we get x m a x = 2 r sin 9 0 = 2 r = 2.00 x_{max}=2r \sin 90 ^ \circ = 2r = 2.00

Dao Zhou
May 20, 2014

We can think the 2-D graphene as a mass sheet on which electrons enter from one point (the origin) and can flow anywhere else except the lower half of the sheet. There are innumerable electrons flowing randomly on the sheet with the same speed v F v_F . At one instance, a magnetic field of B 0 B_0 is turned on and suddenly all the electrons flow clockwise in a circle of R = m v F e B 0 R=\frac{mv_F}{eB_0} .

Now let’s examine the conditions for the electrons to reach a point along the x x -axis. We draw many circles of radius R R that passes through the point. Any electrons that reaches that point along the x x -axis must be on one of those circles we draw and must have the velocity tangential to the circle, when the magnetic field is turned on. Since all the electrons on the lower half of the sheet are absorbed, there are only electrons flowing from upper half to lower half, but none from lower half to upper half. This means, all the electrons at any position along the x x -axis are flowing downward or along the axis, except for the origin, where electrons are injected, so they can have velocity either upward or downward or along the x x -aixs. (By downward, I mean velocity that has downward component, not limited to vertically downward.)

If we analyzing the circles more carefully, we can obtain the position along x x -axis that most electrons flow to by drawing a semi-circle, of which the left intersection with the axis is the origin and the right intersection is the position we want to find. Putting the origin at the left intersection of the semi-circle allows the electrons flowing vertically upward clockwise in the magnetic field to reach the position, which is 2 R 2R distance away from the origin.

Hence the distance from the origin is 2 R = 2 m v F e B 0 = 2 m 2R=2\frac{mv_F}{eB_0}=2 m

David Mattingly Staff
May 13, 2014

Every electron that's injected on the graphene sheet makes some random angle c c with the x x -axis, so it will hit the x x -axis at position x = 2 m v F e B sin ( c ) x=\frac{2mv_F}{eB}\sin(c) . If the electrons are injected with no preferential direction, the focusing point must be the place where the absolute value of d c / d x dc/dx is maximum, as d x / d c = 2 m v F e B cos ( c ) = 0 c = π / 2 dx/dc=\frac{2mv_F}{eB}\cos(c)=0 \rightarrow c=\pi/2 , so we get the focusing point is just x f = 2 m v F e B x_f=\frac{2mv_F}{eB} .

Use the numerical values and we get the result!

Could you please explain how you got the condition dc/dx must be maximum. I used the logic that the detector will receive the greatest signal at the point where the electron has to traverse the mimimum path to go there. So, the concentration of electrons will be high there(Since electrons are being continuously generated from the origin). But, in your solution, you took the angle for the maximum circular path traversed by the electron. Can you please explain why I am wrong?

Mahathir Ahmad - 6 years, 5 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...